Equititrust Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) v Tucker

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Equititrust Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) v Tucker & ors [2019] QSC 308

PARTIES:

EQUITITRUST LIMITED (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQUIDATION) ON ITS OWN ACCOUNT AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE EQUITITRUST PREMIUM FUND
ACN 061 383 944

(plaintiff)

v
DAVID ROBERT WALTER TUCKER

(first defendant)
TUCKERLOAN PTY LTD ON ITS OWN ACCOUNT AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE TUCKERLOAN TRUST
ACN 101 109 157
(second defendant)
DAVID ROBERT WALTER TUCKER AND RICHARD TERRICK COWEN, CARRYING ON THE PRACTICE AS PARTNERS UNDER THE NAME TUCKER & COWEN SOLICITORS (A FIRM)
(fifth defendants)
TCS SOLICITORS PTY LTD
ACN 601 321 509
(sixth defendant)

FILE NO:

BS No 7399 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED EX TEMPORE ON:


4 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 December 2019

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDERS:

1.   Pursuant to rule 742(6)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, paragraphs 3.1(a), 3.2(a) and 5 of the costs assessor’s decision included in the Costs Assessment Certificate dated 17 October 2019 (the “Certificate”) are set aside.

2. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(b), paragraphs 3 and 6 of the costs assessor’s decision included in the Certificate are varied by:

a.   deleting references to the sum of $173,752.41; and

b.   inserting in its place the sum of $86,747.52.

3.   Pursuant to rule 742(6)(c), the Order of the Registrar made on 28 October 2019 is varied by deleting from paragraph 1 the sum of $173,752.41 and inserting the sum of $86,747.52.  

4.   Pursuant to rule 742(6)(d), the items in the costs statements relating to the fees claimed by the Second Defendant (if any) are to be referred back to the costs assessor for reconsideration.

5.   Pursuant to rule 742(6)(d) and (e), the question of which party is entitled to be paid the costs of the assessment in paragraph 4 of the costs assessor’s certificate dated 17 October 2019, and any further costs incurred since that date or to be incurred in respect of the costs assessment, including the costs of the provision of the reasons, are to be referred back to the costs assessor for reconsideration.

6.   The first, second and first-named fifth defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the application dated 21 November 2019.

The Court directs that:

7.   The first defendant, the second defendant, and the first-named fifth defendant are to provide the costs assessor a copy of the reasons of Bradley J of 4 December 2019.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – GENERAL MATTERS – NATURE OF COSTS: INDEMNITY DOCTRINE – APPLICATION TO PARTICULAR PERSON OR PARTY – LEGAL PRACTITIONER ACTING FOR SELF – where the plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of several defendants in respect of two applications successfully brought against the plaintiff – where the costs assessor decided to include in the award of costs professional fees incurred by the first defendant, a solicitor, in acting for himself and the second defendant –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Equititrust Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 308
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Equititrust Limited (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) v Tucker involved a dispute over the costs incurred in a litigation process between the plaintiff, Equititrust, and the Tucker defendants. The Tucker defendants, including Mr. Tucker, a solicitor, successfully challenged the statement of claim filed by Equititrust and were ordered to be paid a significant portion of the costs by Equititrust. The costs assessor allowed certain professional fees claimed by Mr. Tucker, who appeared for himself and the second defendant. Equititrust applied for a review of the costs assessor's decision, arguing that the assessor failed to appropriately apply the decision in Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow, which found that the Chorley exception was not part of the common law of Australia. The Tucker defendants argued that the decision in Bell Lawyers was not applicable as the costs were sought pursuant to a legislative regime.

The court considered whether the costs assessor erred in law by including the professional fees incurred by Mr. Tucker in the award of costs. The court examined the decision in Bell Lawyers, which held that the Chorley exception was not part of the common law of Australia, and found that the exception was inconsistent with the equality of all persons before the court. The court concluded that the costs assessor had erred in law by including the professional fees claimed by Mr. Tucker in the award of costs. The court set aside certain paragraphs of the costs assessor's decision and varied the sums awarded, referring the matter back to the costs assessor for reconsideration. The court also ordered the Tucker defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application.

In summary, the court held that the costs assessor erred in law by including the professional fees claimed by Mr. Tucker in the award of costs. The court set aside certain paragraphs of the costs assessor's decision and varied the sums awarded, referring the matter back to the costs assessor for reconsideration. The court ordered the Tucker defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, paragraphs 3.1(a), 3.2(a) and 5 of the costs assessor’s decision included in the Costs Assessment Certificate dated 17 October 2019 (the “Certificate”) are set aside.

2. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(b), paragraphs 3 and 6 of the costs assessor’s decision included in the Certificate are varied by:

a. deleting references to the sum of $173,752.41; and

b. inserting in its place the sum of $86,747.52.

3. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(c), the Order of the Registrar made on 28 October 2019 is varied by deleting from paragraph 1 the sum of $173,752.41 and inserting the sum of $86,747.52.

4. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(d), the items in the costs statements relating to the fees claimed by the Second Defendant (if any) are to be referred back to the costs assessor for reconsideration.

5. Pursuant to rule 742(6)(d) and (e), the question of which party is entitled to be paid the costs of the assessment in paragraph 4 of the costs assessor’s certificate dated 17 October 2019, and any further costs incurred since that date or to be incurred in respect of the costs assessment, including the costs of the provision of the reasons, are to be referred back to the costs assessor for reconsideration.

6. The first, second and first-named fifth defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the application dated 21 November 2019.

The Court directs that:

7. The first defendant, the second defendant, and the first-named fifth defendant are to provide the costs assessor a copy of the reasons of Bradley J of 4 December 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application was heard on 4 December 2019 in the applications list. These reasons comprise the revised ex tempore reasons for the decision provided at the conclusion of the hearing, augmented by the inclusion of extracts of referenced documents, some defined terms and foot-noted references. One matter dealt with after the judgment in exchanges with counsel – about a contractual liability in a costs agreement – has been also included in the reasons.Background Earlier this year, Mr Tucker and Tuckerloan (the Tucker defendants) and other defendants were successful, to some extent, in a challenge to the statement of claim filed by Equititrust. The Tucker defendants were wholly successful in an application for Equititrust to provide security for their costs.[1] [1]Both applications were heard on 14 February 2019 before Justice Bowskill. Her Honour’s orders and reasons were published in Equititrust Limited v Tucker & Ors [2019] QSC 51. On 18 March 2019, Equititrust was ordered to pay 80% of the Tucker defendants’ costs of the challenge to the statement of claim and all their costs of the application for security. The process for the assessment of those costs proceeded.[2] On 17 October 2019, the costs assessor delivered a certificate of assessment (Certificate).[2]The Tucker parties served a costs statement. Equititrust served a notice of objection. The registrar appointed a costs assessor. The costs assessor issued a number of directions to the parties. The parties made submissions to the costs assessor. “COSTS ASSESSOR’S CERTIFICATEI, Edward Thomas Skuse, of Skuse and Co. Solicitors and Costs Assessors, 20 Robert Street, Mudgeeraba in the State of Queensland 4213 certify that – On 21 October 2019, Equititrust sought reasons from the costs assessor for the decision to allow the Tucker defendants professional fees of $66,766.89.[3] On 8 November 2019, the costs assessor delivered written reasons. [3]This figure is the total of the two amounts allowed in paragraphs 3.1(a) and 3.2(a) of the Certificate.The application for review The review application was made under rule 742 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR). The court will interfere in a costs assessor’s decision where a discretion has not been exercised or where it has been exercised in a manner that is manifestly wrong.[4] [4]The court’s approach to a review was identified by the Tucker parties in their written submissions, citing: Redfern v Mineral Engineers Pty Ltd [1987] VR 518 at 523 (Tadgell J); Hannover International Ltd v Robson [2012] QSC 47 at [17]-[18], [47] (Ann Lyons J); Australian Coal and Shale Employees’ Federation v The Commonwealth (1953) 94 CLR 621 at 627-628 (Kitto J); and Farrar v Julian-Armitage & Anor [2015] QCA 289 at [15] (Henry J, McMurdo P and Morrison JA agreeing). For Equititrust the same position was adopted, relying on Australian Coal and Shale Employees Federation v The Commonwealth (op cit) at 627 and Nashvying Pty Ltd & Ors v Giacomi [2009] QSC 31 at [4] (Jones J).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In this application, the court’s consideration was confined to the five grounds set out in the application. The first ground: the Bell Lawyers decision The first ground concerns the effect of the recent decision of the High Court in Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow.[5] In that decision, the court dealt with the so-called “Chorley exception.” By a majority, the court held that the exception was not part of the common law of Australia. [5][2019] HCA 29. The exception, and its title, derive from a decision of Lord Brett MR in London Scottish Benefit Society v Chorley.[6] There, the Master of the Rolls said: “When, however, we come to the case of a solicitor, the question must be viewed from a different aspect. There are things which a solicitor can do for himself, but also he can employ another solicitor to do them for him; and it would be unadvisable to lay down that he shall not be entitled to ordinary costs if he appears in person, because in that case he would always employ another solicitor.”[7] [6](1884) 13 QBD 872.[7]at 875. The Chorley exception, as its name betrays, was an exception to the common law rule: that where a party appears for himself or herself, the party is not indemnified for the loss of time incurred in doing so. It was common ground between Equititrust and the Tucker defendants that the rationale for the decision in Bell Lawyers was that an award of costs in litigation is to partially indemnify a successful party for the costs incurred in conducting the litigation and the general position is a person acting for themselves is not entitled to an award of costs. As the Tucker defendants identified, costs are a creature of statute. They submitted the High Court had found: that the Chorley exemption “had been displaced” by the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW).[8] That submission, which reflects “one view” considered by the plurality,[9] does not accord with their Honours’ conclusions.[10] The Tucker defendants correctly identified the High Court’s observations that “the privilege of Chorley is inconsistent with the equality of all persons before the court” and that the relevant costs “are costs rendered under a contract of service.” [8]In their submissions, the Tucker defendants described this as “the NSW equivalent of the UCPR”. [9]Kiefel CJ, Bell, Keane and Gordon JJ at [15].[10]See: [33], [44] and [57]. Mr Tucker is a solicitor. He appeared for the Tucker defendants at the hearing of the applications. The professional fees claimed by the Tucker defendants (and allowed by the costs assessor) were for attendances and work by Mr Tucker. The Tucker defendants submitted that the decision in Bell Lawyers had no relevant operation here, because they “did not rely upon the previous Chorley common law position to recover solicitors’ costs”. Instead, it was submitted, they relied upon: “the statutory regime for costs in s 15 of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011, the recovery of solicitors' costs pursuant to Part 3.4 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (costs agreements) and rule 691 of the UCPR.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.