Environmental Protection Authority v Cianfrano

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

>

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Environmental Protection Authority v Cianfrano [2003] NSWLEC 380
PARTIES: Environment Protection Authority (Prosecutor)
Robert David Cianfrano (Def)
FILE NUMBER(S): 50120 of 2002
CORAM: McClellan CJ
KEY ISSUES: Environmental Offences :- Water pollution
Orchard owner excavated willow trees from creek bank
Subsequent works completed in compliance with clean-up notice and preventive action notice
Whether seven months later
during rain event
sediment entered creek because of defendant's actions
Whether pollution caused by work done in compliance with notices
Evidence of other potential sources of pollution
LEGISLATION CITED: Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997
CASES CITED:
DATES OF HEARING: 17-20 November 2003, 24 November 2003, 26 November 2003
EX TEMPORE
JUDGMENT DATE :

11/26/2003
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


J Kelly (Prosecutor)
Environment Protection Authority (Sol)

Robert David Cianfrano (Def - in person)


JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND


ENVIRONMENT COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES

                          50120/02

                          McCLELLAN J

                          FRIDAY 26 NOVEMBER 2003
ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY
                                  Prosecutor
      v
CIANFRANO
                                  Defendant
Judgment

      Introduction

1 HIS HONOUR: The defendant, who appears in person, has been charged with a breach of s 120(2) of the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997. It is alleged that “on or about 7 January 2002 at or near Towac [which is near Orange] he caused waters to be polluted”. The pollutant identified by the prosecutor includes inorganic matter including soil, earth and stones, sand and clay residue. It is alleged that the pollution was caused by the pollutants being placed in a position where they fell or were washed into Molong Creek.

2 The prosecutor and the defendant have agreed some basic facts, embodied in a document tendered in the proceedings headed “Agreed Statement of Facts”. In that document it is agreed that the defendant is the owner of Fernbank Orchards, a farm situated adjacent to Old Canobolas Road, also known as Towac Road, Orange. The farm primarily consists of apple orchards. Molong Creek passes through the site roughly adjacent to Old Canobolas Road. The evidence tendered in the proceedings indicates that the creek runs generally parallel with the road which forms the eastern boundary of Fernbank Orchards. The evidence also discloses that it is a stream which runs generally in the winter time following rainfall but is dry for periods during the warmer summer months. The Agreed Statement of Facts records that Molong Creek flows into Lake Canobolas which is approximately three kilometres downstream from the site.

3 With respect to the particular matters alleged in the offence the Agreed Statement of Facts includes the following matters. From early June 2001 the defendant cleared willow trees (salix), commonly referred to as WG4 crack willows and other vegetation from the bed and banks of a section of Molong Creek. This section of Molong Creek ran through the defendant’s property. The defendant did the willow clearing work himself. He undertook the work by pulling the willows off Molong Creek with an excavator, removing the trees, their root systems and other vegetation.

4…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Environmental Protection Authority v Cianfrano and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWLEC 380
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land and Environment Court of New South Wales dealt with a case brought by the Environmental Protection Authority against Robert David Cianfrano, the owner of Fernbank Orchards. The Authority alleged that Cianfrano had caused pollution of Molong Creek by removing willow trees and other vegetation from the creek bank, disturbing the soil, and leaving the area in an unstable condition. The pollution was said to have occurred on or about 7 January 2002. The court had to decide whether Cianfrano's actions caused the pollution and whether the prosecution had proved the offence beyond reasonable doubt.

The court found that Cianfrano had indeed disturbed the creek bank and left it in an unstable condition, which was a significant factor in the pollution observed on 7 January 2002. Although there were other potential sources of pollution, the evidence showed that the levels of suspended solids in the creek were elevated in areas that had been disturbed by Cianfrano. The storm event on 7 January 2002, described as a one-in-50-year event, had the potential to erode the creek bank and wash loose sediment into the creek. The court accepted the evidence of the Environmental Protection Authority's officer, Mr Scarborough, who observed the site and took water samples after the storm. The video footage and photographs also supported the observations of Mr Scarborough.

The court found that the work required to be done by Cianfrano in compliance with statutory notices was part of the original activity that had disturbed the creek bank. The restoration works, although carried out in compliance with the notices, had not returned the site to a stable condition by 7 January 2002. The evidence of the experts called by Cianfrano did not convince the court that the pollution could be wholly explained by other sources or the intensity of the storm event. The court concluded that the acts of Cianfrano had caused the pollution of the creek and found him guilty of the offence as charged.

The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the cumulative impact of human activities on the environment and the need for proper rehabilitation of disturbed sites to prevent pollution. The case also demonstrates the court's willingness to consider the evidence of experts and the weight that can be given to their opinions in reaching a decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established