Land and Environment Court
of New South Wales
CITATION:
Environment Protection Authority V Shell Co. of Australia Ltd (No 1) [1999] NSWLEC 286
PARTIES
PROSECUTOR
Environment Protection AuthorityDEFENDANT
Shell Co. of Australia Ltd
NUMBER:
50071 of 1997
CORAM:
Bignold J
KEY ISSUES:
Environmental Offences :- Environmental Offences - Negligently cause substance to leak in a manner that harms environment. - whether a "continuing offence", whether bad for "duplicity"
LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 s 6(1)
DATES OF HEARING:
11/01/1999; 11/02/1999; 11/03/1999; 11/04/1999
DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:
11/04/1999
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
PROSECUTOR
Mr D Buchanan SC with Mr D Jordan, BarristerSOLICITORS
Environment Protection AuthorityDEFENDANT
SOLICITORS
Mr N Hemmings QC with Mr I Hemmings, Barrister
Coudert Bros
JUDGMENT:
IN THE LAND AND Matter No . 50071 of 1997
ENVIRONMENT COURT OF Coram : Bignold J.
NEW SOUTH WALES 4 November 1999
ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY
Prosecutor
v
SHELL CO. OF AUSTRALIA LTD (No 1)
Defendant
JUDGMENT
Bignold J:
1. By its Notice of Motion filed on 27 October 1999, the Defendant, which is charged with an offence against the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 s 6(1), seeks an order that the summons be dismissed, because the charge of a continuing offence is not within the ambit of s 6(1) of the Act. In the alternative, the Defendant seeks a declaration that the charge is duplicitous, inasmuch as the charge, as particularised discloses a number of separate offences against s 6(1) of the Act. In the event of such a declaration being made, the Defendant seeks an order that the Prosecutor elect which single offence upon which it wishes to proceed and an order for particulars of that single offence.
2. In the alternative, the Defendant seeks an order that the Prosecutor separate the offences and particularise each of them.
3. The charge has been extensively particularised. Those particulars appear in the document prepared by the Defendant and tendered as Exhibit A. I have had regard to those particulars. I have also had regard to the reasons for judgment of Cowdroy AJ delivered on 25 September 1998 in which his Honour dismissed the Defendant’s Notice of Motion seeking further and better particulars. At par 16, his Honour stated:
- The Prosecutor, in its particulars, has made it plain that the alleged negligence arises from Shell’s failure to do the things referred to above. With the particulars already provided Shell ought to have no difficulty in comprehending the offence with which it is charged, and how it should plead to such offence, and in obtaining evidence detailing any measures taken in answer to the claim of negligence as particularised.
4. I respectfully agree.
5. According to the amended summons, the Defendant is charged with the offence that
that -
between 1 January 1991 and 15 July 1994 at Cooma in the State of New South Wales it committed an offence against the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 in that it did, without lawful authority, negligently cause a substance to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Environment Protection Authority v Shell Co. of Australia Lt... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] NSWLEC 286
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the offence charged under s 6(1) of the Act could be considered a continuing offence and whether the charge was duplicitous. The court had to determine if the act of leaking a substance in a negligent manner over a period of time constituted a single offence or multiple separate offences. Additionally, the court examined whether the particularised charge complied with legal principles regarding duplicity in criminal charges.
The court, presided over by Bignold J, concluded that the offence charged was capable of being a continuing offence. The verb "to leak" was interpreted to naturally embrace a continuing action, meaning the offence could occur over an extended period. This conclusion was supported by legal precedent, including the judgment of Lord Roskill in Chiltern District Court v. Hodgetts, which held that a criminal offence could take place over a period of time, whether continuously or intermittently. The court further found that the charge did not involve duplicity, as it satisfied exceptions to the principle of duplicity, including the charge of a continuing offence and a charge involving multiple acts within the same criminal enterprise or activity.
As a result, the court dismissed Shell Co. of Australia Ltd's Notice of Motion in its entirety. The court found that the charge, as particularised, did not suffer from the defects argued by the Defendant. The offence under s 6(1) of the Environmental Offences and Penalties Act 1989 could indeed constitute a continuing offence, and the charge did not involve duplicity. Consequently, the prosecution could proceed with the charges as laid.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi