ENVIRO SYSTEMS RENEWABLE RESOURCES PTY LTD v AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
[2001] SASC 11
Civil Jurisdiction
1................ MARTIN J......... The plaintiff (“Enviro”) seeks a declaration that a scheme in which it invites investors to participate in the growing, harvesting and sale of timber is a franchise for the purposes of Chapter 5C of the Corporations Law (“the Law”). The defendant (“ASIC”) opposes the application and asserts that Enviro has been operating a managed investment scheme in breach of the provisions of the Law. I have been asked to determine the application upon the basis of restricted points of claim and defence and a statement of agreed facts with accompanying documentation.
The definition of managed investment scheme in s 9 of the Law specifically excludes a franchise. If Enviro is correct, the provisions of Chapter 5C of the Law do not apply. For the purposes of these proceedings, Enviro concedes that if the scheme is not a franchise, it is operating a managed investment scheme.
Aussie Glass (Operations and Marketing) Pty Ltd (“Aussie Glass”) developed documentation for a “timber merchant franchise” scheme. Using the registered business name “Enviro Systems Renewable Resources”, Aussie Glass offered interests in the scheme pursuant to that documentation from about April 1997 until about June 1998. From about June 1998, Enviro began operating the scheme and offering interests in it. It operates the scheme under licence from Aussie Glass and pays a royalty to Aussie Glass for the use of what has been called the “E S System”.
Maritime Funding Pty Ltd (“Maritime Funding”) has been retained by Enviro to market and sell interests in the scheme. Commission sales agents engaged by Maritime Funding make initial contact with potential participants. They provide potential participants with copies of an Information Memorandum, a disclosure document and a third document referred to as the “Blue Gum brochure”. A number of documents are provided with the Information Memorandum, including legal advice as to the tax deductibility of fees paid in connection with the scheme, financial projections, plans of the areas concerned, a “timber merchant franchise agreement”, a questions and answers document and a single page form of agreement between Enviro and a participant. As the parties sign only the single page form of agreement, the terms of the contract between Enviro and each participant are to be ascertained by reference to all of the documents I have mentioned together with 34 pages of “Regulations for Timber Merchant Franchises” (“the Regulations”) prepared by Enviro.
The documentation speaks of Enviro as a “Franchisor” and a participant as a “Franchisee”. In essence, the documentation provides that Enviro offers participants the right to use identified half hectare Woodlots to grow Tasmanian Blue Gum trees and the rights to harvest and sell the timber or timber products. The Woodlots are situated on two separate parcels of land. Participants do not have a registrable interest in any of the land. One parcel is leased by Enviro. The lease provides that if the lease is terminated as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Enviro Systems Renewable Resources Pty Ltd v ASIC and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 11
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi