TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Enviro Harvesting Systems Australia Pty Ltd to the registration of trade mark application number 723668 in the name of Garasill Pty Ltd for the trade mark ENVIRO HARVESTER in Class 7.
Background
Trade mark application number 723668 was filed on 11 December 1996 in the name of Garasill Pty Ltd (Garasill). That application was for the registration of the word trade mark ENVIRO HARVESTER and covered the statement of goods, "Fruit and nut harvester which cleans, dehusks and collects", in Class 7. Subsequent to examination, the trade mark was advertised as accepted in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks of 5 June 1997.
A notice of opposition to the trade mark’s registration was filed by Enviro Harvesting Systems Australia Pty Ltd (Enviro Harvesting Systems), on 5 September 1997. That notice listed a number of grounds. However, prior to the hearing of the matter, Enviro Harvesting Systems' attorney advised that it would rely primarily on those grounds under ss.41, 58, 59 and 60.
Enviro Harvesting Systems requested that the matter be heard by the Registrar. The matter then came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar, for hearing in Canberra on 29 May 2001. Mr Paul Kildea, Patent Attorney of Canberra, appeared at the hearing on behalf of Enviro Harvesting Systems. He was accompanied by Mr Des Renehan, Enviro Harvesting Systems' Managing Director. Garasill did not appear at the hearing but relied instead upon written submissions from its attorney, Mr Paul Grant of Paul A Grant and Associates, Patent Attorneys.
The Evidence
The evidence in support comprises a declaration by Desmond Lawrence Renehan, dated 28 February 1999 (first Renehan declaration); and also a declaration by Warwick Graham, dated 1 March 1999.
The evidence in answer comprises declarations by Robert John Thompson, dated 6 September 1999 (first R. Thompson declaration); Philip John Thompson, dated 5 September 1999 (first P. Thompson declaration); and Erina Marion Thompson, dated 5 September 1999 (first E. Thompson declaration).
The evidence in reply consists of declarations by Desmond Renehan, dated 5 June 2000 (second Renehan declaration); and Ron Delary-Simpson, dated 6 June 2000.
Both parties served further evidence in the matter. Garasill's evidence consisted of declarations by Robert Thompson, dated 25 November 2000 (second R. Thompson declaration); Philip Thompson, dated 28 November 2000 (second P. Thompson declaration); and Erina Thompson, dated 25 November 2000 (second E. Thompson declaration); Thomas Michelsen, dated 26 June 2000; and Paul Ainsworth Grant, dated 21 November 2000.
Enviro Harvesting Systems' further evidence comprised of a declaration by Desmond Renehan, dated 9 March 2001 (third Renehan declaration).
Submissions and analysis
I think it is common between the parties that Garasill is a company which was formed purely to manufacture and sell harvesters. Mr Desmond Renehan and Mr Robert Thompson are both Directors and 50% shareholders in the company. Mr Renehan is also the Managing Director and major shareholder of Enviro Harvesting Systems. Mr Renehan…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Enviro Harvesting Systems Australia Pty Ltd v Garasill Pty L... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] ATMO 55
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had a genuine dispute with the respondent regarding the debt claimed in the statutory demand, or whether the applicant had a closely related offsetting claim. The court was required to assess whether the evidence presented by the applicant demonstrated a sufficient basis for such a dispute or claim to warrant setting aside the demand.
Justice Forno reasoned that the applicant's claim of a contractual breach by the respondent, leading to a significant loss, constituted a genuine dispute. The court found that the applicant had provided sufficient evidence to raise a real question as to the existence of the debt. Consequently, the court ordered that the statutory demand be set aside.
Background
Background to the litigation
Desmond Renehan and Robert Thompson are both directors and 50% shareholders in Garasill, with Renehan also being the managing director and major shareholder of Enviro Harvesting Systems. The evidence presented by both parties included declarations from their respective directors and patent attorneys, with further evidence being served later in the case. The opposition hearing revealed significant personal and business differences between Renehan and Thompson, with Renehan opposing the trade mark application and Thompson pursuing it despite Renehan's objections.
The disputed trade mark ENVIRO HARVESTER was first used by Renehan's former company and himself on a harvester he invented. The evidence showed that the trade mark had been used since at least April 1994, with five harvesters made to Thompson's design bearing the mark between that date and June 1996, prior to the incorporation of Garasill. Garasill was incorporated on 24 June 1996, and the trade mark application was filed on 11 December 1996. The evidence presented conflicting accounts regarding the ownership of the trade mark and the intentions of the parties involved. While it was clear that Renehan was the creator of the trade mark, it was uncertain whether he relinquished his ownership rights to Garasill during the company meetings in July and December 1996.
The matter before the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks originated from an opposition by Enviro Harvesting Systems Australia Pty Ltd (Enviro Harvesting Systems) to the registration of trade mark application number 723668 filed by Garasill Pty Ltd (Garasill) for the trade mark ENVIRO HARVESTER in Class 7. Garasill's application was accepted and advertised for registration on 5 June 1997. Enviro Harvesting Systems filed a notice of opposition on 5 September 1997, primarily relying on grounds under sections 41, 58, 59, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The opposition was heard by the delegate of the Registrar on 29 May 2001, with Enviro Harvesting Systems represented by Mr Paul Kildea, Patent Attorney, and Garasill relying on written submissions from Mr Paul Grant, Patent Attorney. Extensive evidence was presented by both parties, including declarations from key individuals involved in the dispute. The delegate considered the evidence and submissions, ultimately finding that the application for registration should not proceed due to fundamental flaws, and further that the opposition was successful on the grounds of sections 58, 59, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Costs were ordered to be borne by Garasill in relation to the substantive matter, while each party was to bear their own costs regarding extraneous evidence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" inherently capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods from those of other persons under s.41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Is the applicant, Garasill Pty Ltd, the owner of the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" under s.58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. Does Garasill Pty Ltd intend to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" in Australia under s.59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
4. Is the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, a trade mark that has acquired a reputation in Australia under s.60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
Held
1. Is the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" inherently capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods from those of other persons under s.41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the trade mark is inherently capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods from those of other persons. The opposition based on s.41(2) was dismissed.
2. Is the applicant, Garasill Pty Ltd, the owner of the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" under s.58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that Garasill Pty Ltd is not the owner of the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER." The opposition based on s.58 was successful.
3. Does Garasill Pty Ltd intend to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" in Australia under s.59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that Garasill Pty Ltd does not intend to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" in Australia. The opposition based on s.59 was successful.
4. Is the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, a trade mark that has acquired a reputation in Australia under s.60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" is deceptively similar to a trade mark that has acquired a reputation in Australia. The opposition based on s.60 was successful.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The opposition to the registration of the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" filed by Enviro Harvesting Systems Australia Pty Ltd (Enviro Harvesting Systems) against Garasill Pty Ltd (Garasill) was primarily based on sections 41, 58, 59, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court considered each of these grounds in turn, providing detailed analysis on the reasoning behind its findings.
Under section 41(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, the application for registration of a trade mark must be rejected if the trade mark is not capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods or services from those of other persons. Enviro Harvesting Systems argued that the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" could not distinguish Garasill's goods from those of others. However, the court held that section 41 is concerned with whether the mark is inherently capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods, and not whether other parties might have used the same or similar marks. Since Enviro Harvesting Systems did not provide evidence to demonstrate that the mark was incapable of distinguishing Garasill's goods, the court dismissed the opposition based on section 41.
Section 58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 allows opposition on the ground that the applicant is not the owner of the trade mark. The court found that the issue of ownership was clouded by the personal and business disputes between the parties, particularly between Mr Renehan and Mr Robert Thompson, both Directors and 50% shareholders in Garasill. Despite the ambiguity in the evidence, the court concluded that there was no convincing evidence that Mr Renehan relinquished his common law ownership rights in the trade mark to Garasill. Therefore, the opposition based on section 58 was successful.
Section 59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 provides that the registration of a trade mark may be opposed if the applicant does not intend to use, or authorise the use of, the trade mark in Australia. The court found that there was considerable confusion as to Garasill's intention to use the trade mark at the time of the opposition. Mr Thompson declared that Garasill was not using the trade mark and would never use it again, while Mr Renehan stated that he never intended for the mark to be registered in Garasill's name. Consequently, the opposition based on section 59 was also successful.
Finally, the opposition based on section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 argued that the registration of the trade mark should be opposed because it was substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, a trade mark that had acquired a reputation in Australia. Enviro Harvesting Systems needed to establish that its reputation was sufficient among a substantial number of persons and that use of the trade mark by Garasill would likely lead to deception or confusion. The court concluded that Mr Renehan's companies had been using the trade mark since 1990 and had built a reputation in the particular niche market. Given the specialised nature of the market and the relatively short period Garasill could have used the mark, the court found that the use of the trade mark by Garasill would likely cause deception or confusion. Therefore, the opposition based on section 60 was successful.
In conclusion, the court found that the application for registration of the trade mark "ENVIRO HARVESTER" was fundamentally flawed due to the contentious circumstances surrounding its filing. Furthermore, the opposition based on sections 58, 59, and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 was successful. Consequently, the court refused to register the trade mark and ordered Garasill to pay Enviro Harvesting Systems' costs for the substantive matter, while each party bore its own costs for the further evidence.