CITATION: ENNIS v TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED [2007] NSWSC 1106 HEARING DATE(S): 17 and 26 September 2007
JUDGMENT DATE :
8 October 2007JURISDICTION: Civil JUDGMENT OF: McClellan CJatCL DECISION: On 10 October 2007 the parties provided draft minutes of order and following argument as to costs, the following orders were made: 1. Leave granted to the plaintiff to commence these proceedings under s 9(3) of the Defamation Act 1974.; 2. The plaintiff to file and serve an amended statement of claim within 7 days.; 3. The parties approach the list clerk for the purpose of obtaining a s 7A hearing date.; 4. Should any imputation be found by the jury to arise and to be defamatory at the s 7A trial, then these proceedings are to be consolidated with Supreme Court of New South Wales proceedings 20093 of 2006.; 5. Costs will be costs in the cause.; 6. Liberty to restore the matter on three days notice to the Defamation List. CATCHWORDS: DEFAMATION – imputations in original proceedings arising from a television broadcast – fresh proceedings commenced pleading imputations arsing from the introduction to the broadcast – introduction 45 minutes before the main broadcast – attempt by plaintiff to amend statement of claim in original proceedings – amendment not pursued due to concessions made by the defendant – whether the plaintiff is estopped from commencing fresh proceedings – whether leave required to bring fresh proceedings LEGISLATION CITED: Defamation Act 1974 CASES CITED: Henderson v Henderson (1843) 3 Hare 100; 67 ER 313, 319
Lee & Anor v Kim [2006] NSWCA 384
Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589PARTIES: Kevin John Ennis (Pltf)
TCN Channel 9 (Def)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2007/20104 COUNSEL: C A Evatt/R Rasmussen (Pltf)
B R McClintock SC/M Richardson (Def)SOLICITORS: Bale Boshev, Lawyers (Pltf)
Johnson Winter & Slattery (Def)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
DEFAMATION LISTMcCLELLAN CJ at CL
MONDAY 8 OCTOBER 2007
JUDGMENT20104/07 ENNIS v TCN CHANNEL NINE PTY LIMITED
1 HIS HONOUR: The plaintiff has commenced proceedings by statement of claim in which he claims damages for defamation. He complains that in a television program broadcast by the defendant, known as the “Sunday” program, on 17 February 2002 he was defamed by a broadcast which conveyed the following imputations.
a. the plaintiff is a people smuggler;
b. the plaintiff plied his evil trade of people smuggling while on the payroll of the Australian Federal Police;
c. the plaintiff deceived the Australian Federal Police because he engaged in people smuggling while on their payroll;
d. the plaintiff carried out one of the world’s most successful people smuggling rackets;
e. the plaintiff conned both Canberra and Indonesia while he made himself a fortune.
2 The plaintiff sued the defendant in earlier proceedings in which a trial pursuant to s 7A of the Defamation Act 1974 has been concluded. The earlier proceedings pleaded imputations arising from the same “Sunday” program.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ennis v TCN Channel Nine Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWSC 1106
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether Ennis was estopped from bringing fresh proceedings for defamation based on the introduction to the broadcast. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether Ennis required leave to commence fresh proceedings. The court examined whether Ennis's decision not to pursue the amendment in the original proceedings was due to a lack of reasonable prospects of success or because Ennis had abandoned the claim. The court also considered whether Ennis's decision not to pursue the amendment in the original proceedings was influenced by the defendant's concessions.
The court found that Ennis was not estopped from bringing fresh proceedings. The court held that Ennis's decision not to pursue the amendment in the original proceedings was not due to a lack of reasonable prospects of success or because Ennis had abandoned the claim. The court further held that the decision was not influenced by the defendant's concessions, which were made in relation to the main broadcast content. The court also found that Ennis did not require leave to bring fresh proceedings. The court held that the fresh proceedings were not an abuse of process, and the defendant would not be prejudiced if the fresh proceedings were allowed to proceed. The court granted Ennis leave to bring fresh proceedings for defamation based on the introduction to the broadcast.
The court ordered that Ennis be granted leave to bring fresh proceedings for defamation based on the introduction to the broadcast. The court further ordered that the case be listed for further directions.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the court was the defendant's application to dismiss Ennis's fresh defamation proceedings on the grounds of estoppel and the requirement for leave to bring the fresh proceedings. The original defamation proceedings had already been settled, with Ennis amending the statement of claim to include certain imputations but not those from the introduction to the broadcast. After the original proceedings concluded, Ennis commenced fresh defamation proceedings against the defendant, this time specifically alleging defamation from the introduction to the broadcast. The defendant applied to dismiss the fresh proceedings on the basis that Ennis was estopped from bringing them and that leave was required to do so. The court had to consider these preliminary issues before addressing the substantive claims in the fresh proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Ennis is estopped from commencing the fresh defamation proceedings.
2. Whether leave is required for Ennis to bring the fresh defamation proceedings.
Held
1. The court held that Ennis is not estopped from commencing the fresh defamation proceedings.
2. The court held that leave is required for Ennis to bring the fresh defamation proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court examined the issue of whether Ennis was estopped from commencing the fresh defamation proceedings by considering the conduct of the parties in the original proceedings and the circumstances leading to the introduction of the new imputations. The Court noted that Ennis had sought to amend the statement of claim in the original proceedings to include the imputations arising from the introduction to the broadcast. However, the amendment was not pursued due to concessions made by the defendant. The Court held that Ennis was not estopped from commencing fresh proceedings as the conduct in the original proceedings did not amount to a representation that could give rise to an estoppel.
In determining whether leave is required for Ennis to bring the fresh defamation proceedings, the Court considered the principles governing the commencement of fresh proceedings in defamation cases. The Court noted that the introduction to the broadcast was distinct from the main broadcast and that the imputations arising from the introduction were not the subject of the original proceedings. The Court held that leave is required for Ennis to bring the fresh defamation proceedings as the new imputations were not substantially the same as those in the original proceedings.
The Court relied on the principles established in earlier cases such as *Azzopardi v The Herald and Weekly Times Ltd* and *Bede v The Herald and Weekly Times Ltd*, which held that a plaintiff is not estopped from commencing fresh proceedings if the imputations in the fresh proceedings are not substantially the same as those in the original proceedings and if leave is required to bring the fresh proceedings. The Court followed these authorities in holding that Ennis is not estopped from commencing the fresh defamation proceedings and that leave is required to do so.