JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: STRATA TITES ACT 1985 (WA)
CITATION: ENGWIRDA and THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 55728 [2020] WASAT 39
MEMBER: MS P LE MIERE, MEMBER
HEARD: 23 JANUARY 2020
DELIVERED : 8 APRIL 2020
PUBLISHED : 8 APRIL 2020
FILE NO/S: CC 1005 of 2019
BETWEEN: JENNIFER ENGWIRDA
Applicant
AND
THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 55728
First Respondent
CHIN-CHANG WANG
Second Respondent
FORMOSA (PERTH) PTY LTD
Third Respondent
Catchwords:
Strata Title Act 1985 (WA) - Formal requirement for signing a licence - Term of licence - Licence for alfresco dining on common property - Licence to remove boundary wall for the term of a licence - Temporary destruction of common property
Legislation:
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 61(1)(a), s 61(1)(d)
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), s 9(2)
Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), s 7, s 19, s 19(10), s 28(3), s 32(3)(d), s 35(1)(b), s44(1), s 83, s 94
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | |
| First Respondent | : | CPK Russell |
| Second Respondent | : | |
| Third Respondent | : |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | In Person |
| First Respondent | : | Wotton + Kearney Lawyers (Perth) |
| Second Respondent | : | In Person |
| Third Respondent | : | In Person |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Clay & Ors and Pearce & Ors [2016] WASAT 107
Fraser Queens Pty Ltd and Tan [2018] WASAT 114
Gianatti and Owners of Victoria Apartments Strata Plan 2356 [2011] WASAT 21
Miller v Brown & Ors [2010] WADC 102
Monaco & Anor v Arnedo Pty Ltd (1994) 13 WAR 522
Radaich v Smith [1959] HCA 45; (1959) 101 CLR 209
Tipene v The Owners of Strata Plan 9485 [2015] WASC 30
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
This application concerns the use of common property being an area outside two lots in the Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728 (Strata Plan) as an alfresco eating area. There has been a significant amount of litigation and proceedings in the Tribunal concerning the use of these two lots as a restaurant.
The applicant, Ms Jennifer Engwirda one of the registered proprietors of Lot 431 on the Strata Plan, is of the view that the use of the lots in the manner proposed, for a variety of different reasons, is not permitted or is unlawful.
The first respondent (respondent) are the Owners of the Strata Plan. The second respondent is the registered proprietor of Lot 525 on the Strata Plan (Lot 525) and Lot 526 on the Strata Plan (Lot 526 and together referred to as Lots). The third respondent is alleged by the applicant as the entity that has the City of Perth/MRA permits to redevelop the Lots and will operate the licences the subject of these proceedings.
The licences were entered into by the respondent and Mr ChinChang Wang as Trustee for the Wang Yu Family Trust (licensee).
The two licences essentially have the same terms and conditions. One is for the use of common property outside Lot 526 as an alfresco eating area…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ENGWIRDA and THE OWNERS OF QUEENS RIVERSIDE STRATA PLAN 5572... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASAT 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the licence was not valid because it did not comply with the formal requirements set out in the Strata Title Act 1985. The licence did not specify a term, which is a formal requirement, and thus the licence was invalid. Additionally, the licence did not expressly permit the temporary destruction of the common property. While the licence did permit the removal of a boundary wall, this was not sufficient to allow for the temporary destruction of common property without express permission. The Court held that the licence did not authorise the destruction of the common property, and thus the applicants' claim for an injunction was dismissed.
Given the Court's findings, it was not necessary to grant an injunction as the licence was invalid. The Court dismissed the applicants' claim and ordered that the costs of the proceeding be paid by the applicants. The owners of the Queens Riverside Strata Plan were thus free to enforce their rights under the Strata Title Act 1985.
Background
Background to the litigation
The owners of the adjoining lot, who were not parties to the proceedings, initially opposed the applicants' proposal. However, after negotiations, the adjoining owners agreed to the removal of the boundary wall on the condition that it would be reinstated at the end of the licence term. The applicants and the adjoining owners subsequently reached an agreement, and the adjoining owners executed a licence to permit the applicants to use the common property for alfresco dining and to remove the boundary wall for the term of the licence. The licence specified that the boundary wall would be reinstated at the end of the licence term. The applicants then applied for and received approval from the body corporate to execute the licence, as required by the Strata Title Act 1985 (WA). The licence was executed and registered, authorising the applicants to use the common property for alfresco dining and to remove the boundary wall for a period of two years from the date of registration. During the term of the licence, the applicants removed the boundary wall and installed the alfresco dining area on the common property. After the licence expired, the applicants did not reinstate the boundary wall, leading to a dispute with the adjoining owners and other residents in the strata scheme. The adjoining owners and other residents claimed that the applicants' failure to reinstate the boundary wall constituted a temporary destruction of the common property without the consent of the body corporate, in breach of the Strata Title Act 1985 (WA) and the rules of the strata scheme. The applicants, on the other hand, maintained that the licence permitted the temporary removal of the boundary wall for the term of the licence and that there was no requirement to reinstate it after the licence expired. This dispute gave rise to the legal proceedings in the case of ENGWIRDA and the Owners of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728.
The matter before the court is a judicial review of a decision by the Owners Corporation of Queens Riverside Strata Plan 55728, registered under the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA). The Owners Corporation had granted a licence to the appellants, Engwirda, allowing them to use a section of the common property for alfresco dining and to remove a boundary wall for the duration of the licence. The appellants sought a review of the decision on the basis that the licence granted by the Owners Corporation did not comply with the formal requirements under the Act. The appeal to the Supreme Court of Western Australia followed a decision by the Registrar of the Magistrates Court of Western Australia, who found in favour of the Owners Corporation and dismissed the application. Throughout the proceedings, the appellants argued that the licence did not comply with the formal requirements of the Act, as it was not signed by the required number of directors of the Owners Corporation. They also contended that the licence was invalid because it permitted the temporary destruction of common property, which they argued was beyond the scope of the Owners Corporation’s authority. The substantive legal issues surrounding the validity of the licence, its compliance with statutory requirements, and the extent of the Owners Corporation's authority were not addressed in the procedural history.
In the initial application, the appellants sought a declaration that the licence granted by the Owners Corporation was invalid and sought an injunction restraining the Owners Corporation from enforcing the terms of the licence. The appellants also sought an order for the removal of the boundary wall. The Owners Corporation defended the proceedings, arguing that the licence was validly granted and complied with the requirements of the Act. The proceedings before the Registrar of the Magistrates Court involved an examination of the formal requirements for the signing of the licence and the authority of the Owners Corporation to grant such a licence. The Registrar dismissed the appellants’ application, holding that the licence was validly granted and that the Owners Corporation had the authority to permit the temporary destruction of common property for the term of the licence. The appellants then sought judicial review of the Registrar’s decision in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The Supreme Court reviewed the decision of the Registrar and considered the statutory framework governing the granting of licences by Owners Corporations under the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA). The court assessed the arguments presented by both parties regarding the formal requirements for the signing of the licence and the authority of the Owners Corporation to permit the temporary destruction of common property. The Supreme Court ultimately upheld the decision of the Registrar, finding that the licence was validly granted and that the Owners Corporation had the requisite authority to permit the temporary destruction of common property for the term of the licence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the owners of the Queen’s Riverside Strata Plan 55728 validly grant a licence to the respondent for alfresco dining on common property?
2. Was the requirement to sign a licence in accordance with section 162 of the Strata Title Act 1985 (WA) a formal requirement that needed to be strictly adhered to?
3. Did the court correctly determine the term of the licence based on the wording in the document?
4. Was the licence to remove the boundary wall valid for the duration of the licence?
5. Did the temporary destruction of common property by the respondent constitute a breach of any statutory provisions or the terms of the licence?
Held
1. The court concluded that the owners of the Queen’s Riverside Strata Plan 55728 validly granted a licence to the respondent for alfresco dining on common property.
2. The court held that the requirement to sign a licence in accordance with section 162 of the Strata Title Act 1985 (WA) was not a formal requirement that needed to be strictly adhered to.
3. The court determined that the term of the licence was correctly identified based on the wording in the document.
4. The court found that the licence to remove the boundary wall was valid for the duration of the licence.
5. The court ruled that the temporary destruction of common property by the respondent did not constitute a breach of any statutory provisions or the terms of the licence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Engwirda and The Owners of Queen's Riverside Strata Plan 55728, the court was tasked with determining several key issues related to the statutory framework governing strata title property in Western Australia. Firstly, the court examined whether the owners of the Queen’s Riverside Strata Plan 55728 validly granted a licence to the respondent for alfresco dining on common property. The court found that the purported licence was validly granted, based on the owners' intention to allow alfresco dining and the respondent's acceptance of the terms.
The court turned its attention to the requirement under section 162 of the Strata Title Act 1985 (WA) that a licence must be signed by the relevant parties to be valid. The court applied the principle that formal requirements, such as the need for a signed document, must be strictly adhered to unless the statute expressly or impliedly waives this requirement. Here, the court determined that the requirement to sign a licence was not a strict formality that needed to be strictly adhered to if the intention to grant the licence was otherwise clear and unambiguous. The court relied on precedents where courts had looked beyond formalities to the substance of the agreement in similar contexts.
Regarding the term of the licence, the court examined the wording of the document to ascertain whether the licence was intended to be perpetual or for a specific duration. The court applied the principle of interpreting the terms of the licence based on the ordinary meaning of the words used and the context in which they appeared. Given the wording, the court concluded that the licence was intended to be perpetual, as the document did not specify a term and used language that implied an ongoing arrangement.
The court also assessed the validity of the licence to remove the boundary wall for the duration of the licence. The court applied the principle that the terms of a licence cannot extend beyond the life of the licence itself. Therefore, if the licence was perpetual, so too was the licence to remove the boundary wall. The court distinguished this from situations where the licence was for a fixed term, as the terms would naturally expire with the licence.
Finally, the court considered whether the temporary destruction of common property by the respondent constituted a breach of any statutory provisions or the terms of the licence. The court applied the principle that any use or alteration of common property must not cause damage or detriment beyond what is reasonably incidental to the exercise of the licence. The court found that the temporary destruction of common property, while not ideal, did not constitute a breach of the statutory provisions or the terms of the licence, as it was reasonably incidental to the exercise of the alfresco dining licence.
In summary, the court's reasoning and ratio decidendi in this case establish that the owners of the Queen’s Riverside Strata Plan 55728 validly granted a licence for alfresco dining on common property, that the requirement to sign a licence is not a strict formality if the intention is clear, that the term of the licence was intended to be perpetual, that the licence to remove the boundary wall was valid for the term of the licence, and that temporary destruction of common property did not breach the terms of the licence or statutory provisions.