En-Tzu Tseng v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

En-Tzu Tseng v Brisbane City Council [2022] QCA 222

PARTIES:

EN-TZU TSENG
(applicant)
v
BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 328 of 2021
DC No 3358 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Criminal)

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2021] QDC 327 (Sheridan DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

11 November 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

14 October 2022

JUDGES:

McMurdo and Dalton JJA and Boddice J

ORDER:

Application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

MAGISTRATES – JURISDICTION – COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS – DUPLICITY, AMBIGUITY AND UNCERTAINTY – where pursuant to s 7 of the Natural Assets Local Law 2003 (“NALL”) the applicant was convicted of 62 charges of causing or permitting interference with a protected tree – where the applicant submits that the charges were duplicitous – whether the charges were duplicitous

LOCAL GOVERNMENT – LEGAL RELATIONSHIPS AND PROCEEDINGS – PARTICULAR POWERS AND FUNCTIONS – where the Council issued a contravention notice to the applicant under s 35 of the NALL – where the notice required the applicant to remedy the contravention by replacement planting or paying a rehabilitation cost order – whether there was a lack of legislative basis for the calculation of the rehabilitation cost order

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – where, at the hearing before the magistrate, the Council tendered a certificate under s 95 of the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld) which certified that the vegetation on the applicant’s property was protected under the NALL – where the applicant submits that the evidence contained in the certificate was inadmissible – whether the magistrate erred in relying upon the certificate

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – ADMISSIONS – where the applicant voluntarily gave an interview to a Council officer admitting that she permitted the trees to be felled – whether the magistrate erred in relying upon the admissions contained in the interview – whether there was sufficient evidence before the magistrate as to the applicant’s responsibility for the felling of the trees

Natural Assets Local Law 2003, s 7, s 35, s 39

Cohen v Macefield P/L & Ors[2010] QCA 95, distinguished

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on her own behalf
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on her own behalf
City Legal Solicitors for the respondent

  1. McMURDO JA:  I agree with the orders proposed by Dalton JA, and with her Honour’s reasons save in one respect, which is that I express no opinion about the matters discussed at paragraph [14] of her judgment.

  2. DALTON JA: Ms Tseng seeks leave under s 118 of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld) to appeal from a judgment of the District Court dismissing an appeal under s 222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld) against a decision of a magistrate to convict Ms Tseng of 64 charges against the Natural Assets Local Law 2003 (NALL).[1]

    [1]Subordinate legislation made by the Brisbane City Council under the City…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read En-Tzu Tseng v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCA 222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of En-Tzu Tseng v Brisbane City Council involved a dispute between the applicant and the Brisbane City Council. The applicant was convicted of 62 charges of causing or permitting interference with a protected tree under section 7 of the Natural Assets Local Law 2003. The applicant contested the conviction on various grounds, including that the charges were duplicitous, that there was a lack of legislative basis for the calculation of the rehabilitation cost order, and that the magistrate erred in relying on certain evidence. The applicant also sought to appeal the decision to dismiss her application for leave to appeal.

The legal issues before the court included whether the charges were duplicitous, whether there was a legislative basis for the calculation of the rehabilitation cost order, and whether the magistrate erred in relying on the certificate under section 95 of the Evidence Act 1977 and on admissions made by the applicant during an interview with a council officer. The court had to consider the admissibility of the evidence and whether there was sufficient evidence to connect the applicant to the offending.

The court found that there was no merit in the applicant's arguments that the charges were duplicitous or that there was a lack of legislative basis for the calculation of the rehabilitation cost order. The court also found that the magistrate was correct to rely on the certificate and on the admissions made by the applicant during the interview. The court held that the interview was given voluntarily and that there was sufficient evidence before the magistrate as to the applicant's responsibility for the felling of the trees.

The court dismissed the application for leave to appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for leave to appeal is dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is no merit in this proposed ground of appeal.E. Insufficient evidence to connect the applicant to the offending The applicant voluntarily gave an interview to a Council officer who attended the property after the trees had been felled. In this interview the applicant admitted having a friend (who she would not name) fell the trees. She wishes to appeal on the ground that the magistrate should not have acted on this admission because it was not on oath; because she did not have a lawyer with her at the time she made it, and because the Council officer did not warn her about the legal consequences of making what she calls “unprofessional comments” on the felled vegetation. She also wishes to argue on appeal that during the interview comments she made were at cross‑purposes to questions asked by the Council officer. Variations of this argument were made to the magistrate, and to Judge Sheridan. Both rejected them. The magistrate saw and heard the witnesses and listened to the tape‑recorded admission which the Council relied upon as containing admissions. The magistrate thought that admissions were clearly made on interview, and looking at the parts of the interview which have been relied upon below, I think that is clear. I also think it is clear that the interview was given voluntarily after the applicant was warned of her right to silence and told that any information which she provided might be used as evidence in court. The magistrate was right to rely upon the admissions made, and Judge Sheridan was right to reject the appeal before her on this ground. Lastly as to this point, the applicant says (as is the case) that during the interview she and the Council officer did not walk around the entire property and discuss every felled tree. She was not asked, in relation to every felled tree, whether or not she was responsible for its destruction. The Council officer’s evidence was that he attended the property soon after the felling of the trees and he explained how he identified those which were the subject of charges. In my view there was sufficient evidence before the magistrate as to the applicant’s responsibility for all 62 fellings. The Council officer was professionally qualified, which qualifications no doubt assisted him in this task. There is no merit in these points.F. Statements in permits The applicant relies upon the fact that her permit applications to remove trees were prepared by her alone without any professional assistance. The submission seems to be directed at the fact that the information she put in these applications should not be used as some sort of admission that there were native trees on her land. She links this to arguments advanced in support of ground C above, that Council had not inspected her land and concluded that it did contain native vegetation before including her land in the areas covered by the overlays. These matters are beside the point. Council relied upon the evidence of its officers in identifying native trees felled after the event. There is no merit in the point and no reason for it to be advanced on an appeal.G. Mango trees

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established