EMP144 v The Republic of Nauru

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER AND NETTLE JJ

EMP144  APPELLANT

AND

THE REPUBLIC OF NAURU  RESPONDENT

EMP144 v The Republic of Nauru

[2018] HCA 21

16 May 2018
M151/2017

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Nauru

Representation

J W K Burnside QC with M L L Albert for the appellant (instructed by Allens)

A Aleksov for the respondent (instructed by Republic of Nauru)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Migration – Refugees – Appeal as of right from Supreme Court of Nauru – Where Secretary of Department of Justice and Border Control of Nauru ("Secretary") determined appellant not refugee under Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nr) – Where Secretary determined Nauru did not owe appellant complementary protection under Refugees Convention Act – Where Refugee Status Review Tribunal ("Tribunal") affirmed Secretary's determinations on basis appellant could reasonably relocate within country of origin – Where Supreme Court of Nauru affirmed Tribunal's decision – Whether appellant's ability reasonably to relocate within country of origin relevant to claim for complementary protection – Whether Tribunal failed to raise issue of whether appellant could reasonably relocate – Whether Tribunal failed to take into account factors relevant to appellant's ability reasonably to relocate – Whether Tribunal misunderstood country information.

Words and phrases – "complementary protection", "country information", "internal relocation", "reasonable internal relocation", "refugee", "well-founded fear of persecution".

Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (1984), Art 3.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966), Arts 6, 7.
Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976 (Cth), s 5.
Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nr), ss 4, 22(b), 34(4), 40(1), 43.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER AND NETTLE JJ. This is an appeal as of right, pursuant to s 5 of the Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976 (Cth), from a judgment of the Supreme Court of Nauru (Khan J). The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal brought under s 43 of the Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nr) ("the Refugees Act") against a decision of the Refugee Status Review Tribunal ("the Tribunal").  The Tribunal had affirmed a decision of the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Border Control, made pursuant to s 6 of the Refugees Act, to reject the appellant's application to be recognised as a refugee in accordance with the Act or as a person to whom the Republic of Nauru ("Nauru") owes complementary protection under the Act.

    The facts

  2. Before the Tribunal, the appellant presented as a 34 year old man from the village of Pakhu in the Myagdi district of Nepal.  He said that Pakhu was isolated and not serviced by a road on which cars could be driven, and that his family owned a small farm there.  He had attended boarding school in the town of Beni[1], which was a day's walk from Pakhu, and about once a month he would walk back to his home…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EMP144 v The Republic of Nauru and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal as of right to the High Court of Australia from a judgment of the Supreme Court of Nauru. The appellant, who sought refugee status or complementary protection under Nauru's Refugees Convention Act 2012, had his application rejected by the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Border Control, a decision affirmed by the Refugee Status Review Tribunal and subsequently by the Supreme Court of Nauru. The core of the dispute concerned whether the appellant qualified for protection, with the Tribunal finding that while he had suffered persecution, he could reasonably relocate within his country of origin, Nepal.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of the appellant's claim for complementary protection by applying an internal relocation test, whether the Tribunal failed to consider relevant factors regarding the appellant's ability to relocate, and whether procedural fairness was afforded to the appellant in relation to the issue of internal relocation. Specifically, the appellant argued that the Tribunal overlooked his concerns about safety, access to education and employment, lack of professional skills, and ongoing fears for his family's safety, and that he was not given an opportunity to respond to the relocation issue.

The High Court, comprising Kiefel CJ, Gageler and Nettle JJ, dismissed the appeal. Their Honours reasoned that the Tribunal's approach of considering internal relocation was appropriate in assessing claims for complementary protection. They found that the Tribunal had not failed to take into account all relevant matters, including the appellant's circumstances, and that procedural fairness had been observed. The Supreme Court of Nauru's affirmation of the Tribunal's decision was upheld. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

KIEFEL This is an appeal as of right, pursuant to s 5 of the Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976 (Cth), from a judgment of the Supreme Court of Nauru (Khan J). The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal brought under s 43 of the Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nr) ("the Refugees Act") against a decision of the Refugee Status Review Tribunal ("the Tribunal"). The Tribunal had affirmed a decision of the Secretary of the Department of Justice and Border Control, made pursuant to s 6 of the Refugees Act, to reject the appellant's application to be recognised as a refugee in accordance with the Act or as a person to whom the Republic of Nauru ("Nauru") owes complementary protection under the Act.The facts Before the Tribunal, the appellant presented as a 34 year old man from the village of Pakhu in the Myagdi district of Nepal. He said that Pakhu was isolated and not serviced by a road on which cars could be driven, and that his family owned a small farm there. He had attended boarding school in the town of Beni[1], which was a day's walk from Pakhu, and about once a month he would walk back to his home in Pakhu.[1]The Tribunal referred to Beni as "Benni" in their reasons. The appellant's father, uncle and older brother were all members of the pro-Royalist political group called the Rastriya Prajatantra Party of Nepal, otherwise known as the National Democratic Party of Nepal ("the RPP(N)"[2]). In 2003, however, the Myagdi district was taken over by members of the Nepal Communist Party-Maoist ("the NCP-M"). The following year the appellant's older brother disappeared and had not been seen since. The appellant's family believed the Maoists were responsible for his disappearance or, perhaps, death. Further, the appellant's father was attacked and assaulted for refusing to co‑operate with the Maoists, and so departed for India where he had since remained. The appellant had visited him there.[2]The Tribunal sometimes referred to the RPP(N) as "the RRP(N)" in their reasons. In 2006, the appellant married a woman from the next village, and in December 2006 they had a son. In 2008, a road was put through the area where the appellant and his family resided (although it did not reach Pakhu, which remained about an hour's walk from the road). A local person bought a jeep for use, in effect, as a taxi. The appellant learned to drive and became the taxi driver, although he never drove for more than about five hours from Beni. His wife and mother tended the crops on the family farm in Pakhu while the appellant worked as a taxi driver. In 2008, the appellant joined the RPP(N), at which time his Uncle Rudra was still active at the local level. In 2010, the appellant stopped working as the taxi driver in order to tend to his farm and devote himself more actively to politics by increasing his level of activity within the RPP(N). He worked in the RPP(N) office in Beni when he could, and he became the vice-president of the local branch.The appellant's case before the Tribunal

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER AND NETTLE JJ
The Tribunal accepted that the appellant had suffered serious harm amounting to persecution at the hands of particular local Maoist groups (namely, the NCP-M and its youth group, the Youth Communist League ("the YCL")) because of his political opinion, and that such harm might re-occur in the future if he were to return to the area where he had suffered the harm (namely, Pakhu and Beni). But the Tribunal concluded that, because it was localised harm which was the work of a particular branch of the NCP-M and the YCL situated in Beni, the appellant could reasonably be expected to establish himself elsewhere in Nepal and live a normal life without undue hardship. Consequently, he did not qualify as a refugee or for complementary protection.The Supreme Court's decision In dismissing the appellant's appeal to the Supreme Court, Khan J held that the Tribunal had not erred in applying a reasonable internal relocation test to the appellant's claim for complementary protection[4]; that the Tribunal had not failed to take into account all matters relevant to the appellant's claim for complementary protection, including whether it was reasonably practicable for him to relocate within Nepal[5]; and that the Tribunal had not failed to afford the appellant procedural fairness in their decision making process[6].[4]See EMP144 v The Republic [2017] NRSC 73 at [61]-[62].[5]See EMP144 v The Republic [2017] NRSC 73 at [46], [59].[6]See EMP144 v The Republic [2017] NRSC 73 at [54], [75].Grounds of appeal The appellant's grounds of appeal to this Court are as follows:"1.The Supreme Court of Nauru erred by failing to conclude that the Refugee Status Review Tribunal ('the Tribunal') erred by failing to consider integers of the objection to relocation raised by the Appellant, namely that:a.his family and he would 'face substantial prejudice in accessing education, employment and essential services' and would be unsafe;b.he lived in hiding when he lived elsewhere to ensure he did not publically express his political views; andc.he does 'not have any tertiary or professional education' and no professional skills; andd.he holds ongoing fears for the safety of his wife and young son;and thereby erred by denying the Appellant natural justice in breach of s 22 and/or was in breach of s 34(4) of the Refugees Convention Act 2012 (Nauru) ('the Act').2.The Supreme Court of Nauru erred by failing to conclude that the Tribunal acted in breach of s 22(b) and/or s 40(1) of the Act by failing to provide the Appellant with an opportunity to respond to the issue of whether it was reasonably practicable for him to relocate.3.The Supreme Court of Nauru erred by failing to conclude that the Tribunal erred by failing to consider integers of the Appellant's claims to complementary protection including that there was a reasonable possibility that he would be subject to arbitrary deprivation of life and/or torture and/or degrading treatment.4.The Supreme Court of Nauru erred by failing to conclude that the Tribunal erred by importing a relocation test in its analysis of the Appellant's 'complementary protection assessment' in breach of s 4(2) of the Act.5.The Supreme Court of Nauru erred by failing to conclude that the Tribunal erred by failing to:a.deal with evidence or other material provided by the Appellant in breach of s 34(4)(d) of the Act;b.alternatively, act in accordance with s 22(b) and/or s 40(1) of the Act in the conduct of the hearing about Nepali citizenship law relevant to the denial of the Appellant's son's Nepali citizenship application." (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER AND NETTLE JJ