| [2015] FWC 5348 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Emmanouil Karandinas
v
Monash Health
(U2015/4765)
COMMISSIONER RYAN | MELBOURNE, 5 AUGUST 2015 |
Application for relief from unfair dismissal - jurisdiction – no dismissal – was the applicant forced to resign due to conduct by the employer.
[1] On 13 April 2015, Mr Karandinas (the Applicant) made an application for a remedy in relation to his dismissal under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act).
[2] This decision concerns an objection raised by Monash Health (the Respondent); namely that the Applicant was not dismissed from his employment.
Factual Background
[3] In late 2014/early 2015 several complaints were raised against the Applicant by co-workers and others. These complaints against the Applicant led to a disciplinary meeting on 25 March 2015 being held with the Applicant and Faye Faulkner, Senior People and Culture Business Partner, Meg Brundell, Monash CATT Manager, Paul Carr, a Senior Social Worker, and John Creamer, HACSU Organiser (the disciplinary meeting).
[4] At the conclusion of the disciplinary meeting the Applicant advised that he would resign his employment with the Respondent. On 26 March 2015 the Applicant formally tendered his written resignation by email. 1
Submissions
[5] The Applicant contends that the employment relationship was ended at the initiative of the Respondent: that he was forced to resign because of the actions of the employer.
[6] The Applicant in its outline of submissions relies on Mohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd 2and also acknowledges the relevance of the oft-quoted passage from P. O'Meara v Stanley Works Pty Ltd :
“[23] In our view the full statement of reasons in Mohazab which we have set out together with the further explanation by Moore J in Rheinberger and the decisions of Full Benches of this Commission in Pawel and ABB Engineering require that there to be some action on the part of the employer which is either intended to bring the employment to an end or has the probable result of bringing the employment relationship to an end. It is not simply a question of whether “the act of the employer [resulted] directly or consequentially in the termination of the employment.” Decisions which adopt the shorter formulation of the reasons for decision should be treated with some caution as they may not give full weight to the decision in Mohazab. In determining whether a termination was at the initiative of the employer an objective analysis of the employer’s conduct is required to determine whether it was of such a nature that resignation was the probable result or that the appellant had no effective or real choice but to resign. 3
[7] The Respondent cited the Full Bench decision in Victorian Association for the Teaching of English Inc v Debra de Laps 4(VATE v De Laps). In VATE v De Laps the Full Bench set out a comprehensive statement of the relevant law around s.386(1)(b)5. I have followed that decision in my consideration of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Emmanouil Karandinas v Monash Health and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FWC 5348
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue for the court was whether the Fair Work Commission could exercise jurisdiction over the matter, considering that the applicant did not claim to have been dismissed but rather forced to resign. The court had to determine whether the circumstances surrounding the resignation amounted to a dismissal under the Fair Work Act 2009. This involved examining the nature of the applicant's departure and whether it was due to employer conduct that rendered the working relationship intolerable.
In its decision, the Fair Work Commission examined the factual matrix surrounding Mr Karandinas's resignation. The Commission found that the applicant's resignation was not a result of employer conduct that would render the dismissal unfair. Instead, the Commission determined that the applicant had willingly resigned due to personal reasons and was not forced to do so by the employer's actions. Consequently, the Commission ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the application for relief from unfair dismissal as the applicant had not been dismissed within the meaning of the Fair Work Act.
The Commission's decision was that the application for relief from unfair dismissal was dismissed, and the Fair Work Commission had no jurisdiction to hear the matter. This outcome effectively closed the avenue for the applicant to pursue relief under the Fair Work Act for his resignation from Monash Health.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi