Embrey v Bartter Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Embrey v Bartter Enterprises Pty Ltd [2003] QDC 285

PARTIES:

MARK EMBREY
Plaintiff
v
BARTTER ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
ACN 000 451 374 FORMERLY KNOWN
AS STEGGLES LIMITED
ACN 002 759 462

FILE NO:

D 663/02

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT NOUD DCJ

DELIVERED THIS ELEVENTHDAY OF JULY 2003 

  1. This is an action for damages for personal injuries.  Quantum is the only issue.

  1. The plaintiff, born on 26 September 1978, was injured on 22 November 1999. He was then a process worker, he is now a farm hand.  He was 21 years of age at the time of the 1999 accident  and is now 24.  The accident occurred at his place of work.  A bar fell on his left shoulder.  He agreed with his counsel that it was like being struck with a crow bar.  The left clavicle was fractured and the plaintiff received treatment at hospital.  It is submitted on the plaintiff’s behalf that the fractured clavicle and probably other injuries suffered at the same time have had long term consequences.  Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that the plaintiff’s damages are in excess of $100,000 (counsel’s Schedule Ex 11), whereas counsel for the defendant submitted that the damages are about $5,000 (p.5 of the defendant’s counsel’s submissions, Ex 12).

  1. The reason for this difference is that the plaintiff, post accident, has continued to experience pain.  Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that this is due to the accident on 22 November 1999, whereas counsel for the defendant contended that the pain can be explained on other grounds or that the plaintiff has not proved that his continuing symptoms are accident related.  Counsel for the defendant did not contend that the plaintiff was other than genuine in relation to his continuing problems.  I agree with that approach.

  1. The plaintiff gave evidence and called Dr Pentis, an orthopaedic surgeon.  Dr Pentis’ evidence supports the  plaintiff’s contention that his on-going pain is caused by the accident.  The defendant called Dr Duke, an orthopaedic surgeon, specialising in surgery of the hand, upper limb and shoulder;  Dr Livingstone, an orthopaedic surgeon and Dr Andrew, a general practitioner.  Dr Duke and Dr Livingstone gave evidence that the plaintiff’s injury was limited to the fractured clavicle.  Their evidence was that the injury would have cleared up within a few months.  It is common ground, however, that the plaintiff has a noticeable protrusion at the point of the fracture.  Dr Pentis described it as “unsightly” (Ex 1 p 3). 

  1. Dr Andrew gave evidence of a pre-accident neck injury suffered by the plaintiff.  He also gave evidence about a post-accident examination which he conducted of the plaintiff.  His evidence may explain the plaintiff’s continuing symptoms as not having been caused by the accident.  I shall return to his evidence.

  1. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that the outcome of the case should not be determined simply by the number of expert witnesses called by the defendant as compared with the number of experts called by the plaintiff.  I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Embrey v Bartter Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] QDC 285
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiff, Mark Embrey, sought damages for personal injuries sustained during his employment as a process worker. The defendant, Bartter Enterprises Pty Ltd, formerly known as Steggles Limited, was held liable for the accident that occurred on 22 November 1999. The plaintiff sustained a fractured left clavicle and experienced ongoing pain post-accident, which the parties disputed as being related to the incident. The court was required to determine the appropriate quantum of damages, with the plaintiff arguing for an amount in excess of $100,000 and the defendant contending the damages were approximately $5,000.

The court carefully considered the medical evidence presented by both parties. The plaintiff's orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Pentis, supported the plaintiff's claim of ongoing pain due to the accident, whereas the defendant's experts, Dr Duke, Dr Livingstone, and Dr Andrew, opined that the injury was limited to the fractured clavicle and would have cleared up within a few months. The court found that while the plaintiff had indeed suffered a fractured clavicle, the evidence did not support the plaintiff's claim of long-term soft tissue injuries or that the ongoing pain was caused by the accident. The court was not convinced by the plaintiff's expert's evidence and accepted the defendant's experts' opinions that the plaintiff's symptoms could be attributed to a pre-existing neck injury.

The court awarded damages for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities, adjusting the defendant's submission to account for the protrusion at the fracture site, resulting in a total of $6,000. Additionally, the court awarded $2,580 for the period of lost income, and other minor damages totaling $1,348.88. After deducting the WorkCover refund, the total judgment in favor of the plaintiff was $6,328.25. The court directed the parties to discuss the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established