Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins (No 2) [2023] FCA 1612

File number: QUD 138 of 2021
Judgment of: THOMAS J
Date of judgment: 15 December 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where orders were made for the production of devices – where respondent deposes to providing all devices in possession – where there is conflicting evidence – witnesses cross-examined in interlocutory hearing – not sufficient doubt to make orders sought – application dismissed  
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins [2021] FCA 484

Wu v Avin Operations Pty Ltd (No 3) [2006] FCA 1321

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 105
Date of last submission/s: 24 March 2022
Date of hearing: 17 March 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Denton
Solicitor for the Applicant: EMA Legal
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr G Sheahan
Solicitor for the Respondent: van de Graaff Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 138 of 2021
BETWEEN:

ELTRAK INTERNATIONAL AND STAFF PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

BRETT JOHN COLLINS

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

THOMAS J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 DECEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application filed on 14 October 2021 be dismissed.

2.Costs be reserved.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THOMAS J:

  1. Mr Brett Collins is a former employee of Eltrak International & Staff Pty. Ltd., which traded as Vater Hardware and conducted the business of Vater Corporation (Aust.) Pty. Limited (Eltrak). In their evidence, many of the parties use Eltrak and Vater interchangeably.

  2. Eltrak claims that Mr Collins failed to return Eltrak’s confidential information upon his departure from Eltrak. Mr Collins’ last day working for Eltrak was on 23 March 2021 and he now provides consultancy work for a company called Oxworks.

  3. A number of electronic devices and email addresses were relevant to the interlocutory hearing, as follows:

    (a)Mr Collins’ wife’s TPG email address;

    (b)Mr Collins’ iCloud email address (iCloud1 email);

    (c)Mr Collins’ other iCloud email address (iCloud2 email);

    (d)the first work mobile phone given to Mr Collins by Eltrak;

    (e)the replacement work mobile phone given to Mr Collins after the first work mobile phone was returned (the iPhone 6);

    (f)Mr Collins’ personal mobile phone;

    (g)the HP computer given to Mr Collins by Eltrak (HP Laptop);

    (h)Mr Collins’ wife’s computer;

    (i)USB Device 1 – serial number 00000000000F5B;

    (j)USB Device 2 – serial number 070187F6E2CC7E16; and

    (k)USB Device 3 – serial number 00018131100420145744.

  4. Evidence was led from Mr Mark Gare, who provided details of his qualifications, including that he holds a Bachelor of Applied Science in Computer Studies, a Master of Business Administration and a Certificate III in Investigative Services and a South Australian Investigation Agents License.

  5. It is clear from the material that Mr Gare has a connection with Eltrak and has been involved with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1612
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins, the Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the respondent, Mr Collins, had complied with previous search orders and whether further orders should be made for the production of additional devices. Eltrak, the applicant, had executed search orders on Mr Collins' home, seizing various items, and subsequently sought further disclosure from Mr Collins. The court was faced with conflicting evidence regarding Mr Collins' possession of additional devices and whether he had complied with the initial search orders.

The legal issues before the court included whether there was sufficient doubt about Mr Collins' compliance with the discovery orders to warrant further production orders, and whether Mr Collins' explanations for accessing certain files were credible. The court also had to consider whether Mr Collins' evidence, which was not challenged by an independent expert, was sufficient to resist the applicant's claims. Additionally, the court needed to assess the utility of the application given that Mr Collins had sworn under oath that he had complied with the orders.

The court found that Mr Collins had provided explanations for his actions and had deposed to not copying any confidential information. The two witnesses who gave evidence did not explore how files interacted within Eltrak's environment. The court could not conclude that the analysis of the "Recent Files" demonstrated that Mr Collins had copied Eltrak's confidential information. The court held that there was not enough doubt on the evidence that Mr Collins had complied with the discovery orders. The court also noted that Mr Collins had sworn on oath to having complied with the orders, and it was not surprising that requests had fallen on deaf ears if he had indeed complied. The court concluded that if it became clear at a later stage that Mr Collins had not provided all the documents, there would be remedies available. The interlocutory application was dismissed, and costs were reserved.

The court's decision underscored the importance of clear and credible evidence in legal proceedings and the weight given to sworn statements. The court also highlighted the potential for further action if additional evidence emerged, ensuring that the rights of both parties were protected while avoiding unnecessary court interventions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed on 14 October 2021 be dismissed.

2. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is clear from the material that Mr Gare has a connection with Eltrak and has been involved with other similar matters in the past when he has advised Eltrak and protected its interests. Mr Gare is not an independent expert but more likely a witness as to fact. Unless admitted, his evidence regarding the operation of computer systems and access to files will likely, as the matter progresses, require analysis and opinion from an independent expert.BACKGROUND After obtaining search orders of Mr Collins’ home (Eltrak International and Staff Pty Ltd v Collins [2021] FCA 484) on 5 May 2021, the search orders were executed on 7 May 2021 and various items were taken into the custody of the search party, which consisted of an independent lawyer (Ms Louise Nixon), Eltrak’s lawyer (Mr John Love), an independent computer expert (Mr Michael Tarnawsky) and Eltrak’s computer expert (Mr Gare). Eltrak subsequently filed an originating application, statement of claim and accompanying interlocutory application. The interlocutory application sought to restrain Mr Collins from disclosing or using Eltrak’s confidential information. Mr Collins gave an undertaking to the Court that he would not disclose or use Eltrak’s confidential information. Pursuant to timetabling orders, Mr Collins had the opportunity to claim that certain electronic material captured by the search parameters were the subject of legal professional privilege or privilege against self-incrimination. Eltrak alleged non-compliance with the 5 May 2021 orders and filed an interlocutory application on 14 October 2021 seeking disclosure and production of further devices asserted to be in the possession of Mr Collins as follows: INTERLOCUTORY ORDERS SOUGHTIn this order:(a)‘cloud storage facility’ means any online data storage facility, including email accounts, iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive and Microsoft OneDrive.(b)‘electronic device’ means any device capable of electronically storing information, including a computer, tablet device, hard drive, portable storage device, disk or smartphone.(c)‘Independent Computer Expert’ means Michael Tarnawsky.(d)“Independent Solicitor” means Ms Louise Nixon of Turks Legal.(e)“Search Parameters” means the parameters set out at Annexure A to the orders of 13 May 2021.1.[Eltrak] has leave to uplift and remove from the Court registry item 6 referred to in paragraphs 145 – 148 of the Independent Solicitor’s Report dated 12 May 2021, such item having been provided to the registry on 12 May 2021.2.On or before 26 October 2021, [Mr Collins] must produce to the Independent Computer Expert for the purpose of making a digital copy of the information stored therein:(a)any electronic device in his possession, custody or control not already produced to the Independent Computer Expert (for the avoidance of doubt, this includes any mobile phone or iPad that [Mr Collins] claims belong to his children);(b)any cloud storage facility not already produced to the Independent Computer Expert (for the avoidance of doubt, this includes the cloud storage device linked to his primary work mobile phone during his employment with [Eltrak] and the full history of his TPG account from at least August 2015);(c)the FlashDisk storage device (serial number 00000000000F5B) inserted into the HP Laptop used by [Mr Collins] between January to February 2021;(d)subject to order 1, the two USB storage devices (serial numbers 070187F6E2CC7E16 and 00018131100420145744) inserted into the HP Laptop used by [Mr Collins] on 23 March 2021. 3.If [Mr Collins] claims that he is no longer in possession, custody or control of any of the items in order 2, on or before 26 October 2021, [Mr Collins] must file and serve an affidavit deposing to: (a) when the item was last in his control;(b) what use he made of the item in the period between January 2021 to the time it was last in his control; (c)if he provided the item to someone else, why he did so and the identity of that person; (d) if he discarded the item, why he did so and the place where it was discarded; (e)if he destroyed the item, why he did so and the method used to destroy the item; (f)if he no longer has an active account with a cloud storage facility, why he stopped using that account and the date which he stopped using it.4.On or before 5 November 2021, the Independent Computer Expert shall apply the search parameters to all items produced pursuant to order 2 and provide the electronic material captured in an enumerated form to the Independent Solicitor.5. Upon the electronic material being provided to the Independent Solicitor pursuant to order 4, the Independent Solicitor shall inform [Mr Collins’] solicitors that [Mr Collins] and/or his solicitors may review the material.6.On or before 19 November 2021, [Mr Collins’] solicitors shall inform the Independent Solicitor in an enumerated table of any thing which Mr Collins claims to be the subject of legal professional privilege or the privilege against self-incrimination, including the basis for such objection and in respect of which the respondent objects to inspection by [Eltrak] or its solicitors (Objection Notice 3).7.On or before 23 November 2021, the Independent Solicitor shall provide the applicant’s solicitors with:(a)a copy of the Objection Notice 3; and(b)any electronic material provided by the Independent Computer Expert that is not the subject of Objection Notice 3.8.On or before 30 November 2021, [Eltrak’s] solicitors are to provide a response to the objections contained in Objection Notice 3.9.The matter be listed for a further case management hearing on the next available date after 30 November 2021.10.Costs be otherwise reserved.11. The parties have liberty to apply.(bold and italics in original)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Collins has provided explanations for why he may have accessed most of the folders in question and deposed that he did not copy any of the folders. Additionally, the two witnesses did not explore how files interacted in Eltrak’s environment. I can not reach the conclusion on the evidence, that an analysis of the “Recent Files” demonstrated that Mr Collins copied Eltrak’s confidential information.CONCLUSION Mr Collins has repeatedly denied that there are any devices which have not been provided. Eltrak is, through this application, asking me to go behind the evidence of Mr Collins and order the further production of devices and documents. I am not satisfied that there is sufficient doubt on the evidence relied upon by Eltrak that Mr Collins has not complied with the discovery orders made on 19 October 2021. Nor is there sufficient evidence to go behind Mr Collins’ evidence. Mr Collins has provided explanations for the events which have transpired. Eltrak is relying upon circumstantial evidence to assert Mr Collins’ non-compliance. At the time of the hearing of this application, I asked counsel for Eltrak what the utility for this application was. Eltrak’s counsel responded that it was that Eltrak wanted a “firm order from the court compelling this to happen because any requests that have been made by [Eltrak] have fall[en] on deaf ears”. The “flip side” to this point made by Eltrak is that Mr Collins swears on oath that he has complied with the order. That is on the record. If he has complied with the orders, it is not surprising that it would appear that requests have “fallen on deaf ears”. If, during a final hearing, or as more evidence comes to light, it becomes clear that Mr Collins has not provided all the documents in breach of the orders of the Court, there are remedies for that. No doubt Mr Collins’ lawyers have made him aware of his duties and the consequences for ignoring an order of the Court. I will order that the interlocutory application filed on 14 October 2021 be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established