QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
CITATION: | Elmes v Carpentaria Shire Council (No. 2) [2017] QIRC 039 |
PARTIES: | Elmes, Neville James v Carpentaria Shire Council |
CASE NO: | TD/2015/96 |
PROCEEDING: | Application for determination of remuneration lost by reason of the dismissal |
DELIVERED ON: | 8 May 2017 |
HEARING DATES: | Application on the papers |
MEMBER: | Deputy President O'Connor |
ORDERS: | (i) The applicant be paid the amounts set out in both Schedules A and B of the applicant's submission dated 14 March 2017, including: 25% of wages and entitlement from 25 November 2015 to 28 April 2016; (i) a payment in lieu of 50% of his accrued leave in accordance with clause 5.3(b) of the Carpentaria Shire Council - Certified Agreement 2011.(ii) (ii) The $21,930 gross earned by the applicant being an "Adjustment for work performed by the Applicant with Gulf Concrete Pty Ltd" be set off against the amount ultimately payable by the respondent. |
| CATCHWORDS: | INDUSTRIAL LAW – APPLICATION FOR REINSTATEMENT – APPLICANT REINSTATED – APPLICATION FOR DETERMINATION OF REMUNERATION LOST BY REASON OF THE DISMISSAL – where employer had obligation to provide suitable duties for the applicant – where the employer did not provide suitable duties |
| CASES: | Industrial Relations Act 1999, s74, s 274A, sch 5 Carpentaria Shire Council Certified Agreement 2011 Blackadder v Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 539 Elmes v Carpentaria Shire Council [2016] QIRC 118 |
Reasons for Decision
Introduction
On 26 August 2015 an application for reinstatement under s 74 of the Industrial Relations Act 1999 (the "IR Act") was filed by Neville James Elmes ("the applicant") seeking the following orders:
"(A) Reinstatement in his former position (or nearly as is possible) without prejudice to the employee's former conditions of employment and remuneration lost between the date the dismissal took effect 19/08/2015 and the date of reinstatement; or
(B) Re-employment in another position that the employer has available and that the Commission considers suitable.
(C) However, if the Commission considers re-instatement or re-employment would be impractical, the Applicant seeks that the Commission make an order that the employer pay the employee an amount of compensation the Commission considers appropriate.
(D) Other orders sought."
The application for reinstatement was heard in Cairns on 20, 21 and 22 June 2016.
On 11 November 2016, the Commission made the following orders:
(i)The application is granted;
(ii) Pursuant to s 274A of the Industrial Relations Act 1999, I declare that the purported termination of the applicant on 19 August 2015 was invalid;
(iii) That the applicant be reinstated to his former position with the respondent;
(iv) The reinstatement is to be on the basis that the applicant's continuity of service is maintained; and
(v) The respondent is to pay the applicant the remuneration lost by reason of dismissal to be agreed or failing agreement to be the subject of a further…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elmes v Carpentaria Shire Council (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] QIRC 39
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with interpreting the concept of "remuneration" under the Industrial Relations Act 1999 and determining whether it included benefits such as part-payment of personal leave. The court examined relevant definitions and previous judicial interpretations, noting that "reinstatement" should restore the employee to their former position with at least equal or comparable conditions. The court found that the employer's obligation to provide suitable duties meant that the applicant's position should be restored to what it was immediately before the dismissal, including the entitlement to 50% part-payment of personal leave.
Upon reviewing the arguments and the applicable legal principles, the court concluded that the applicant was entitled to the amounts specified in the submission dated 14 March 2017. This included 25% of wages and entitlements from 25 November 2015 to 28 April 2016, a payment in lieu of 50% of accrued leave, and an adjustment for work performed with Gulf Concrete Pty Ltd. The court ordered that the respondent pay the specified amounts, with a set-off for the $21,930 gross earned by the applicant from the alternative employment.
Orders
Orders of the court
(i) The applicant be paid the amounts set out in both Schedules A and B of the applicant's submission dated 14 March 2017, including:
25% of wages and entitlement from 25 November 2015 to 28 April 2016; (i)
a payment in lieu of 50% of his accrued leave in accordance with clause 5.3(b) of the Carpentaria Shire Council - Certified Agreement 2011.(ii)
(ii) The $21,930 gross earned by the applicant being an "Adjustment for work performed by the Applicant with Gulf Concrete Pty Ltd" be set off against the amount ultimately payable by the respondent.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The definition of remuneration under the Industrial Relations Act 1999 is, relevantly:"remuneration—(a) for a provision relating to work of equal or comparablevalue, includes—(i) the wage or salary payable to an employee; and(ii) amounts payable or other benefits made availableto an employee under a contract of service; and…."[15][15] Industrial Relations Act 1999 sch 5 (definition of 'remuneration'). Wages, as defined by the Industrial Relations Act 1999 is, insofar as it is relevant, in the following terms:"wages means—(a) an amount payable to an employee for—…(iii) leave the employee is entitled to; or(iv) termination of employment; or.…" [16][16] Ibid (definition of 'wages'). In my view, "remuneration" in the present circumstances would include a payment made to an employee of amounts arising out of a benefit contained within the Enterprise Agreement or under a contract of service. The submissions of the respondent place too narrower a view on the meaning of reinstatement. In Carey v President of the Industrial Court Queensland & Anor McPherson JA wrote:"Reverting to the issue of reinstatement, s78(2) authorises reinstatement of the employee "to the employee’s former position", which is to be "on conditions at least as favourable as the conditions on which the employee was employed immediately before the dismissal". The provision does not in terms authorise reinstatement on conditions more favourable than those that prevailed before dismissal. This inevitably raises the questions concerning the meaning of the expression "position" or "former position". These words are not defined in the Act; but in my view it is plain that its meaning or effect can be gathered only from reference to the terms and conditions on which the employee was engaged before dismissal. After all, it was the employment or engagement that created or gave rise to "the position", and it is to that position that the appellant seeks reinstatement."[17] [17] Carey v President of the Industrial Court Queensland & Anor [2004] QCA 62, [17]. In Blackadder v Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd McHugh J wrote:"To construe the power "to reinstate" as confined to restoring contractual or other legal rights fails to give full effect to the term "reinstate". To reinstate means to put back in place. In this context, it means that the employment situation, as it existed immediately before the termination, must be restored. It requires restoration of the terms and conditions of the employment in the broadest sense of those terms."[18] [18] Blackadder v Ramsey Butchering Services Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 539, 544-5 [14]. Immediately prior to the dismissal, the applicant was entitlement to a 50% part-payment of personal leave in lieu of taking personal leave on termination of his employment. I do not why his position should not be restored to that which applied immediately before the dismissal.Conclusion For the reasons advanced above, the applicant is entitled to the amounts set out in both Schedules A and B of the applicant's submission dated 14 March 2017, including: