Ellul v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Ellul v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPIC 491 
CLAIMANT: Jake John Daniel Ellul
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
MEMBER: Shana Radnan
DATE OF DECISION: 5 September 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; miscellaneous claim; injured person mostly at fault; motorcycle accident; lane filtering at front of entrance to roundabout over solid white line; breach of Road Rules 2014; Held – the motor accident was caused mostly by the fault of the injured person.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.36(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 and cl 7.497 of the Motor Accident Guidelines

The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows:

1.     For the purposes of s 3.28 or s 3.36 the motor accident was caused mostly by the fault of the injured person.

2.     Effective date: This determination takes effect on 5 September 2024.

3.     Legal costs: The amount of the claimant’s costs assessed in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017, is $1,919 plus GST.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. This determination relates to a miscellaneous claim, which is a reviewable decision under Schedule 2(3)(e) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, about a claim lodged by the injured claimant arising from a motor accident which occurred on 21 January 2021. 

  2. The claimant sustained injuries when a collision occurred at a roundabout at the intersection of the Pacific Highway and Chittaway Road at Ourimbah in New South Wales.

  3. The issue in this matter is whether the accident occurred solely due to the actions of the claimant who, while approaching the roundabout, attempted to lane filter under conditions where the insurer argued it was unsafe to do so and whether there was insufficient space between the two utility vehicles at the head of the queue for the claimant to undertake such a manoeuvre.

  4. The claimant lodged an application for statutory benefits with the insurer on
    22 January 2021.

  5. The insurer issued a liability notice - benefits up to 26 weeks on 12 August 2020 declining the claimant’s benefits up to 26 weeks from the date of accident.

  6. A liability notice issued on declining the claimant’s claim for statutory benefits after 26 weeks from the date of the accident as he was considered to be wholly at fault for the motor vehicle accident on the basis that he had lane filtered when unsafe to do so in breach of Regulation 151A of the Road Rules 2014. Relying upon sub-rule (2):

    “The rider of the motor bike must not unlawfully lane filter along a length of road.

    (3) For subrule (2), it is unlawful for the rider of a motorbike to lane filter along a length of road if any of the following circumstances apply –

    (a) ...

    (b) ...

    (c) ...

    (d) ...

    (e) it is not safe to lane filter,”

  7. Internal review of this decision was requested by the claimant. The insurer conducted a review of the decision and on 19…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ellul v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 491
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ellul v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was heard in the District Court of New South Wales. The dispute involved a motorcycle accident where the claimant, Jake Ellul, sought compensation under the Motor Accidents Act 1994 (NSW) for injuries sustained. The defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the insurer of the driver of the vehicle that collided with the claimant's motorcycle, contested liability based on the claimant's fault in causing the accident.

The central legal issue was whether the claimant's actions in lane filtering contributed to the accident and, if so, to what extent this contributed to the fault. The court had to determine whether the claimant was mostly at fault, which would preclude a claim for compensation under the Motor Accidents Act 1994 (NSW).

The court examined the evidence, including statements from the claimant, the driver of the vehicle involved, and a witness. The claimant admitted to lane filtering at high speed and stopping abruptly in front of two stationary vehicles, which caused the vehicle on the right to swerve and strike the motorcycle. The driver of the vehicle claimed not to have seen the motorcycle before the collision. The witness corroborated the driver's account, stating that the motorcycle stopped between two vehicles before the collision.

The court found that the claimant's actions in lane filtering at high speed and stopping abruptly in front of two vehicles were significant contributing factors to the accident. The claimant's version of events did not provide a safe explanation for his actions, and the evidence suggested he was primarily at fault for the accident. Consequently, the court held that the claimant was mostly at fault, and his claim for compensation was dismissed.

The court's final orders reflected its findings, denying the claimant's claim for compensation under the Motor Accidents Act 1994 (NSW).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The insurer relied on the following written submissions:“The Evidence1. The New South Wales Police Force COPS report contains the following account:‘Initial version – at 5.00 pm on Thursday 21.1.21, veh 3 was lane filtering throughheavy traffic, travelling south approaching the roundabout of Chittaway andPacific Highway. Veh 1 was in lane 1 and veh 2 was in lane 2 of 2. As veh 3stopped between the other vehicles, veh 1 has slightly turned right inwards,hitting veh3 and pushing him into veh 2.Veh 1 has then immediately turned left onto Chittaway Road and failed to stop torender aid or swap details.The rider of veh 3, Jake ELLUL has dropped his motorcycle and felt pain to his left side. Veh 2 has continued through the roundabout before being waved down to stop a short distance south of the roundabout.Veh 3 has stood his motorcycle up and rode it through the roundabout to meet with veh 2 and exchange details. Veh 2 had no damage to the vehicle and stated hewas unaware what had happened to cause it, only that he saw the motorcycle in his side mirror after the incident.’2. The police report goes on to state that on 20 February 2021, the police met with Terry Bignell at Wyong Police Station and completed a form of demand under s 177 of the Road Transport Act 2013.3. On 2 March 2021, police met with the claimant at Wyong Police Station and completed a form of demand under s 177 of the Road Transport Act 2013. The claimant provided details which did not match Bignell’s version in that he stated he stopped in between the two vehicles and when he went to take off with the other vehicles, he was hit from the right side and dragged forward into the roundabout. Further, he stated Bignell did not attempt to pull over and once he did in a nearby bus bay, Ellul told him numerous times to fxxx off and not to speak to him.4. New South Wales Police attempted to obtain a statement from a witness, however, she advised she did not wish to assist with the investigation. Consequently, in light of the contradictory evidence and that vehicle 1 left the scene, it was the position of police that it was a failure of the rider, Ellul, to navigate lane filtering in the appropriate/safe manner.5. A form of demand under the Road Transport Act 2013, s 177 was issued on the claimant by Constable Felicity McWhirter of Wyong Police Station. It was alleged that at 5.00 pm on Thursday, 21 January 2021, the claimant was the rider of motorcycle RBE64, which was involved in a collision at the intersection of the Pacific Highway and Chittaway Road roundabout.6. The claimant provided the following version of events:‘So I’ve exited the motorway onto Pacific Highway heading towards West Gosford. Came up to the lights at the RSL I noticed there was a lot of standstill traffic from the roundabout down. I made an educated guess to lane filter towards the roundabout from the lights all the way up to the roundabout. I was lane filtering about 10 to 20 km/h. I approached the start of the queue to the roundabout. I had two 4WD. The one on the right had a silver tray, dual cab white and the left was another white dual cab with tub and canopy. No other markings. So as soon as I came in between those two vehicles, the front left of the vehicle on the right, he has done a short quick move to the left and hit the brakes which has hit me. I’ve been observing another car from the opposite direction which was coming around and they stopped as they thought he was going into the roundabout. He has pushed me against the car on the left of me. That car was already moving to turn left down Chittaway Road. They have hit me and pushed me against the right car as the right car has moved forward through the roundabout, my handlebars got stuck on the pillar where his mirrors are and he has dragged me into the roundabout. The bike has then fell on top of me in the middle of the roundabout. He then stopped on the other side of the roundabout and I picked the bike up. Once I did, he took off heavy footed. I chased him up with two other cars and he wouldn’t stop. He moved from the right lane to the left lane while I screamed for him to stop. I went in front of his car and signalled for him to pull over. We finally did in the busway opposite King Street. I told him to ‘fuck off’ and not to speak to me. As I was very angry at the situation, I did take a photo of his car rego and got my partner to get his details.’7. At paragraph 8 of the demand, the claimant was asked what his plan was when he reached the front of the queue to the roundabout, to which he responded:‘I was going to wait for a safe spot to enter the roundabout.’8. He subsequently stated:‘I was planning to place my feet down and stop in between them at the entry to find a safe spot to enter and take off into the roundabout.’9. The claimant stated he was in line with the front quarter panels, in line or slightly in front of the front passenger window and that it all happened quickly as he came up and hit the claimant. 10. The claimant also stated that the insured driver did not hit the brakes until after he had hit the claimant. He reported a short quick move to the left, striking the claimant and then hitting the brakes.11. Terry Bignell, the insured driver of vehicle registered CW 19 EA, a Holden Colorado tray back utility, provided a statement to the police to the effect that on 21 January 2021, at approximately 5.00 pm, he was travelling in a southerly direction on the Pacific Highway at Ourimbah.12. As he approached the roundabout at Chittaway Road, he was in the right hand lane and had stopped at the front of the traffic queue. He described the traffic to be heavy and slow.13. Mr Bignell was waiting for vehicles turning right from the south (opposite direction) and had been at the front of the queue for some time waiting for a gap in the traffic. When there was a break, he moved into the roundabout:‘… maintaining my position in the right hand lane. As I began to move into the roundabout I felt something strike my vehicle. It felt as though something had struck the rear left hand side of my vehicle. By the time I realised this I was already moving into the roundabout, and there were cars continuing to come around the roundabout from the south.’14. Mr Bignell stated that he checked his mirrors and saw a motorcyclist behind him. He could not tell exactly where he was or where he had come from and he had not seen or heard him at any point while moving towards or waiting at the front of the roundabout queue. He noted it looked as though he was close to the start of the roundabout and whilst he wasn’t lying on the ground, it looked like he was off his bike and trying to stabilise his motorbike. It was at that point that Bignell realised the bike had somehow come into contact with his vehicle.15. The witness confirmed that the first time he saw the claimant was when he checked his mirrors as he moved through the roundabout.16. After exchanging details with the claimant, and obtaining his account of what had occurred, the witness called police and ambulance.17. He also spoke to a passenger of another vehicle who informed him that the vehicle in the left hand lane had hit the claimant, who then hit the tray of Bignell’s vehicle. Bignell asked where the impact to his vehicle was and the witness reportedly said to the tray of the ute.18. As police did not attend the scene, Bignell called Gosford Police Station at 6.03 pm to report the incident. He was contacted by police at 7.46 pm.19. The New South Wales Police documentation contains an extract from the police notebook of Senior Constable Pullen, which contains a statement of a witness who was 61 years of age and who on the night of the accident, was driving southbound on the Pacific Highway at Ourimbah. The statement is to the following effect:‘I approached the roundabout at Chittaway Road and Pacific Highway. Traffic was heavy. I was stopped at approximately four cars back from the roundabout. I was stationary in lane 1. I saw a motorbike driver and passed me in between lane 1 and lane 2 and stopped at the entry of the roundabout. The motorbike was in between two vehicles. The white ute being in lane 2 and another vehicle in lane 1 also stationary wanting to proceed through the roundabout. As the three vehicles proceeded to enter the roundabout I saw the motorcyclist appear to correct the motorbike. Then I saw the bike and rider fall to the right side of the road. Next I saw the rider mount the motorbike. I noticed the white ute to continue to drive southwards along the Pacific Highway through the roundabout. I saw the motorbike accelerate forward. I drove slowly and sighted the rider and ute exit the roundabout. It appeared the rider had caught up with the ute. I saw the rider looking in the direction of the ute driver. It appeared the rider got the ute’s attention as both rider and the ute pulled over in the bus bay opposite Glenn Road, Ourimbah. I then pulled over to offer assistance.’20. Suzanne Robyn Browne provided a statement to Lee Kelly Investigators on 22 February 2021.21. She stated she was driving along the Pacific Highway in a southbound direction, towards the roundabout with Chittaway Road and the Pacific Highway. She was behind the vehicles involved in the incident and saw the claimant riding very slowly through the centre of the two lanes of the southbound traffic towards the roundabout. At that time, there was a white utility on the motorcyclist’s right hand side and another vehicle on the left hand side. The three vehicles were waiting to give way before beginning to continue on through the roundabout.22. As the vehicles moved off to proceed through the roundabout, the utility on the right hand side made contact with the motorcycle. The motorcyclist then contacted the vehicle on the left and was knocked to the ground.23. The claimant consented to an interview with Michael Pearson of Lee Kelly & Associates, which took place on 17 February 2021.24. Relevant to the subject dispute, in response to question 80, he reported:‘There was a fair bit of traffic just all the cars were stopped um, and I then started to lane filter with the middle of the cars. Just at a steady idle um, obviously to be able to have control of the bike … As I approached.. the end of the lane filtering at where the roundabout is.., the car … both cars were stationary. I had a ute on my right and I had another ute on my left and I remember seeing a car coming from the other direction to turn onto Chittaway Road from Pacific Highway. So that car was coming … as that car was making that turn …… So, as that car was coming I’ve seen it so I started to slow down. I had the clutch in and just started to apply some of my brake and I’m pretty sure I had my feet out by that stage and it just all happened so quick and also simultaneously. As I’ve seen the car, the ute on the right swerved over like a … just a quick jolt like to stop me from coming through to block the access. As he's done that, he's hit me and pushed me up onto the other ute on the left hand side and at the exact same time the other ute on the left hand side hit me and pushed me back onto him. So, they both had the exact same thought process of blocking me coming to the front of the line.’25. The claimant was asked a series of questions which are replicated below:‘Q83 … So, if we take a step back, when you say lane filtering, you were driving downthe middle of two lanes..A Yes.Q84 … to reach the front of the queue…A Yeah.Q85 … and just as you approached the front the vehicle which was a utility on yourleft …A So, yeah.Q86 ... stayed stationary …A The one ...Q87 ... but the vehicle on your right came across ...A Came across.Q88 ... and pushed you into that vehicle on the left?A Yeah and then he pushed me back onto that vehicle on the right. So ...Q89 So, that vehicle on the left then moved forward and pushed you back towards theother vehicles?A Yeah.Q90 So, in a wedge style ...A Yes.’26. The claimant proceeded to report that the car that was coming through the roundabout must have seen the vehicle on his right and anticipated he was going to pull out in front of him. That vehicle stopped or: ‘… they just kept going as well but um yeah, so the guy on the right, the utility hecame out with that, that quick sharp little turn to like block me and he hit mewhich then forced me onto the other car but as he’s hit me, instead of me justfalling with the bike ‘cause it’s so heavy, the car on the left has done the samething and they've wedged me’.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established