Elliott v Spring

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Elliott & Spring [2009] QSC 118
PARTIES: PAUL JAMES ELLIOT
(plaintiff)
v
COLIN SPRING
(defendant)
FILE NO/S: SC No 33 of 2008
DIVISION: Trial
PROCEEDING: Personal Injury - Quantum of Damages
ORIGINATING COURT: Supreme Court at Mackay
DELIVERED ON: 20 May 2009
DELIVERED AT: Townsville
HEARING DATE: 12 May 2009
JUDGES: Cullinane J.
ORDER: Judgement for the plaintiff in the sum of $351,967.04
CATCHWORDS: PERSONAL INJURY – QUANTUM OF DAMAGES – where plaintiff sustained lower back injury which prevents him from heavy work – where plaintiff is a cabinet maker by trade – where plaintiff suffering degenerative changes in lower back before accident – whether and when pre-existing condition would have excluded him from work at some time in any event – what discounts for these factors are to be applied.
COUNSEL: B Harrison for the plaintiff
A Philp SC for the defendant
SOLICITORS: Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors for the plaintiff
Bruce Thomas Lawyers for the defendant
  1. The plaintiff's cause of action is admitted.

  1. He was injured in the course of his employment as a cabinet maker with the defendant on 13 December 2006.

  1. The pleadings reflect an issue as to whether the plaintiff had lifted a heavy corner cabinet prior to lifting the cabinet he was lifting when he fell to the ground with acute pain.  This is now relevant only to the plaintiff's credibility.

  1. There was a time when this issue might have been seen by the parties as critical to the plaintiff’s prospects of success in the action.  Certainly at the time the two then apprentices who were called as witnesses would have been first asked about it this was the case.  At the latest at the time the pleadings were delivered it would have been understood, I can infer, by the plaintiff as being critical also.

  1. The two former apprentices are still employees of the defendant with one of them now being a tradesman. 

  1. I formed a positive opinion of the veracity of both the plaintiff on the one hand and the two witnesses on the other hand.  It seems to me that the recollection of some witness or witnesses must be faulty.  I resolve the matter in accordance with the onus of proof.  The plaintiff has not satisfied me on the balance of probabilities that he had lifted the corner cabinet prior to the onset of the acute pain that I have referred to.

  1. The plaintiff was born on 8 December 1963.  He was educated to Grade 10 standard.

  1. On leaving school he commenced an apprenticeship as a cabinet maker and joiner and completed that over a period of four years.

  1. Apart from a period when he was employed by a national chain as a kitchen salesman and designer he has been employed as a cabinet maker or carried on business in partnership with his wife in this field.

  1. For almost two years between early 2004 and early 2006 the plaintiff was in receipt of very little income but I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elliott v Spring and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Elliott v Spring involved a dispute over the quantum of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff for a personal injury sustained. The plaintiff, a cabinet maker, suffered a lower back injury that prevented him from performing heavy work. The injury exacerbated pre-existing degenerative changes in his lower back. The court had to determine the appropriate discount, if any, to apply for these pre-existing conditions in assessing the damages.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the pre-existing degenerative changes in the plaintiff's lower back would have rendered him unable to perform heavy work at some point in any event, and if so, what discount should be applied to the damages awarded. The court also needed to decide on the extent to which the pre-existing condition impacted the plaintiff's ability to work and the resultant loss of earning capacity.

The court found that the pre-existing degenerative changes in the plaintiff's lower back would have eventually rendered him unable to perform heavy work, but not necessarily at the time of the accident. Therefore, the court applied a discount of 20% to the damages for the lower back injury. The court calculated the damages based on the plaintiff's loss of earning capacity, taking into account the pre-existing condition and the impact of the accident on his ability to work. The court awarded the plaintiff a total of $351,967.04 in damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgement for the plaintiff in the sum of $351,967.04

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established