Elizabeth Cogger v New Horizons Enterprises Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read
[2022] FWC 1267

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Elizabeth Cogger
v

New Horizons Enterprises Limited

(U2021/10778)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAUNDERS

NEWCASTLE, 24 MAY 2022

Application for relief from unfair dismissal – public health order requiring vaccination against COVID-19 – valid reason for dismissal – dismissal not harsh, unjust or unreasonable – application dismissed.

Introduction

  1. Ms Elizabeth Cogger was employed by New Horizons Enterprises Limited (New Horizons) for approximately three years in various roles. Ms Cogger was dismissed on 18 November 2021 for two reasons, the first of which was that she was not able to lawfully perform the duties of her current role in circumstances where a public health order prohibited her from providing disability services without having had at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine. The second reason pertains to a failure on Ms Cogger’s part to comply with a lawful and reasonable direction to complete a handover of clients and return IT equipment as directed by New Horizons. Ms Cogger contends that her dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable. New Horizons denies those allegations.

  1. I heard Ms Cogger’s unfair dismissal case against New Horizons on 5 April 2022. Ms Cogger gave evidence in support of her case but was not required for cross examination. New Horizons adduced evidence from Mr Ray Miles, Acting General Manager (People Excellence), and was cross examined by Ms Cogger’s representative, Mr Smith.

Relevant facts

  1. New Horizons is a not for profit organisation that provides support services to vulnerable persons with a disability, mental health concerns, or aged care needs.

  1. At the time of her dismissal, Ms Cogger was employed full time in the role of Support Coordinator. It is uncontested that Ms Cogger’s role involved providing support services under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). Ms Cogger’s responsibilities included coordinating the delivery of services to clients of New Horizons and supporting their staff and clients in achieving the set program outcomes.[1] Mr Miles gave evidence, which I accept, that Ms Cogger, in her role as a Support Coordinator, was “required to meet with New Horizons’ customers, and potential customers, face-to-face. This face-to-face service usually requires Support Coordinators to travel to the customer’s residence, whether that be a private residence, group home, age care facility, or in a hospital setting.”[2] Supporting this evidence is the fact that an essential requirement for the role of Support Coordinator is a “valid NSW Drivers C class licence, with ability to drive vehicles in licence class, including large cars & vans”,[3] together with the fact that a Support Coordinator is paid a car allowance.[4] Mr Miles explained in his oral evidence that Support Coordinators such as Ms Cogger worked from home as a temporary measure during the COVID-19 pandemic, but this was not an ongoing situation; Ms Cogger was required from time to time to meet in person with clients as part of her role.

  1. On 20 August 2021, New Horizons distributed an email to all employees which provided…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elizabeth Cogger v New Horizons Enterprises Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWC 1267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Elizabeth Cogger v New Horizons Enterprises Limited [2022] FWC 1267, the applicant, Ms Elizabeth Cogger, applied to the Fair Work Commission for relief from an alleged unfair dismissal by the respondent, New Horizons Enterprises Limited. Ms Cogger was dismissed on 18 November 2021 for two reasons, the first of which was that she was not able to lawfully perform the duties of her role in circumstances where a public health order prohibited her from providing disability services without having had at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine. The second reason was that Ms Cogger failed to comply with a lawful and reasonable direction to complete a handover of clients and return IT equipment as directed by New Horizons. The Fair Work Commission dismissed Ms Cogger's application for relief from unfair dismissal. The Commission found that New Horizons had a valid reason for Ms Cogger's dismissal, and that the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The Commission held that Ms Cogger was unable to fulfil the requirements of her role as a Support Coordinator from 9am on 25 October 2021 because she did not meet the requirements of the Public Health Orders. There were no alternative duties available for Ms Cogger to undertake. As at 18 November 2021, there was nothing to suggest that the Public Health Orders would or were likely to be varied or rescinded such that Ms Cogger would be permitted to work in the disability sector at any time in the foreseeable future. Ms Cogger had months prior to her dismissal to consider whether she would be vaccinated against COVID-19. She gave no indication to New Horizons that she had any plan or intention to be vaccinated against COVID-19 at any time in the foreseeable future; the indications that were given by Ms Cogger were quite contrary to this. Moreover, if New Horizons had permitted Ms Cogger to continue to provide disability services at any time after 9am on 25 October 2021, it would have been in breach of the Public Health Orders and exposed to financial penalties. There was in effect a new regulatory requirement that attached to Ms Cogger’s employment. Ms Cogger was able to decide for herself whether or not to take the necessary steps to meet this requirement. She decided not to do so. For all these reasons, New Horizons had a sound, defensible and well founded reason to terminate Ms Cogger’s employment. The Commission also found that New Horizons had a valid reason for the dismissal in relation to Ms Cogger's failure to comply with lawful and reasonable directions to complete a handover of clients and return IT equipment. The Commission was satisfied that both directions were lawful and reasonable in the circumstances. Ms Cogger's refusal to comply with the direction to complete a handover document and return the IT equipment constituted serious breaches of her contractual obligation to comply with lawful and reasonable directions issued to her. The failure to provide a handover document was particularly serious in circumstances where some of the clients Ms Cogger provided services to were vulnerable and New Horizons reasonably required the handover information in order to continue to service those clients. The Commission found that New Horizons had procedural fairness to Ms Cogger prior to making a decision to bring her employment to an end. The Commission dismissed Ms Cogger's application for relief from unfair dismissal.