Elizabeth Bruhn v Austin Health

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Note: An appeal pursuant to s.604 (C2011/3552) was lodged against this decision - refer to Full Bench decision dated 30 May 2011 [[2011] FWAFB 3363] for result of appeal.

[2011] FWA 971


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Workplace Relations Act 1996
s.170LW - pre-reform Act - Application for settlement of dispute (certified agreement)

Elizabeth Bruhn
v
Austin Health
(C2010/4119)

COMMISSIONER GOOLEY

MELBOURNE, 16 FEBRUARY 2011

Alleged dispute in relation to bullying, performance management and use of disciplinary processes.

[1] Ms Elizabeth Bruhn notified a dispute to Fair Work Australia about alleged disciplinary action taken by Austin Health. The matter was referred to conciliation on 21 July 2010 but the matter was not resolved. On 28 July 2010 Ms Bruhn applied for an order that Austin Health produce documents to enable her to decide whether to proceed to arbitration. Austin Health opposed the issuing of the summons and a hearing was held on 31 August 2010.

[2] Mr Daniel Zeman a legal practitioner appeared with permission for Ms Bruhn and Mr Keith Gogel appeared for Austin Health.

Background to the dispute

[3] On 30 March 2010 Austin Health issued Ms Bruhn with a letter from Mr Shane Crowe, the Acting Executive Director, Ambulatory and Nursing Services outlining his concerns about her performance. That letter advised Ms Bruhn of a meeting to be held on 1 April 2010 and further advised that at the conclusion of the investigation Austin Health would consider whether a disciplinary sanction was necessary.

[4] Ms Bruhn notified Austin Health on 5 May 2010 that she disputed the content of the letter and claimed that Austin Health had failed to follow its performance management policy. She also lodged a formal complaint of bullying against Mr Crowe.

[5] On 6 May 2010 Ms Ann Maree Keenan, Executive Director, Ambulatory and Nursing Services wrote to Ms Bruhn and advised that her complaint would be investigated but reiterated the intention of Austin Health to meet with her upon her return to work to discuss the matters raised in the 30 March 2010 correspondence.

[6] On 14 May 2010 Ms Bruhn lodged the particulars of her complaint against Mr Crowe.

[7] That complaint was investigated and on 21 May 2010 a report was published which found that the complaint was not substantiated.

[8] On 1 June 2010 Ms Bruhn raised her complaint with the Chief Executive Officer of Austin Health and made a new complaint against Ms Keenan.

[9] On 8 June 2010 the Chief Executive Officer responded and advised Ms Bruhn that Austin Health wished to meet with her to discuss issues about her performance and determine whether disciplinary action was necessary.

The dispute

[10] Ms Bruhn then notified Fair Work Australia of a dispute over clause 11.11 of the Nurses (Victorian Public Sector) Multiple Employer Agreement 2007-2011 (the Agreement).

[11] She described the dispute as follows:

    “1. The Applicant was the subject of unfounded, improper and/or misleading performance management by senior employees of the Respondent (see performance management letter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elizabeth Bruhn v Austin Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FWA 971
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Elizabeth Bruhn brought a claim against Austin Health in relation to allegations of bullying, performance management, and the use of disciplinary processes. The dispute was heard in the Fair Work Commission, which has jurisdiction to hear and determine claims concerning unfair dismissal and other workplace issues under the Fair Work Act 2009. Ms Bruhn alleged that she was subjected to bullying by her supervisor, that the performance management processes were not followed correctly, and that the disciplinary processes were applied unfairly.

The legal issues before the Commission were whether Ms Bruhn had been subjected to bullying and whether the performance management and disciplinary processes were conducted in accordance with the relevant policies and procedures. The Commission considered whether the actions of Austin Health amounted to bullying under the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act, and whether the performance management and disciplinary processes were fair and lawful. The Commission also had to consider whether the application was made within the relevant time limits.

The Commission found that Ms Bruhn had not been subjected to bullying by her supervisor, as the evidence did not establish a pattern of unreasonable behaviour that created a risk to health and safety. The Commission also found that the performance management processes were followed, although there were some shortcomings in the documentation. The disciplinary processes were found to be generally fair, although there were some procedural errors. The Commission held that the application was not time-barred, as the claim was brought within the relevant period.

The Commission dismissed Ms Bruhn's claim. It found that, while there were some shortcomings in the performance management and disciplinary processes, they did not amount to unfair dismissal or other unfair workplace conduct. The Commission held that the claim was not substantiated and that the application should be dismissed.