Elias (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Elias (Migration) [2021] AATA 3583 (30 August 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANTS:  Mr Michael ELIAS
Mrs Nawal IBRAHIM

CASE NUMBER:  1804923

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          CLF2017/23496

MEMBER:Mireya Hyland

DATE:30 August 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decisions not to grant the applicants Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visas.

Statement made on 30 August 2021 at 5:21pm

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 65,351

Migration Regulations 1994, r 1.03, Schedule 2, cls 836.212, 836.213, 836.227

CASES
Chaddha v MIMA [2002] FCA 92
Farook v MIBP [2014] FCCA 1000
Palanisamy v MIBP [2013] FCCA 1779

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse to grant the applicants, Michael Elias and his wife, Nawal Ibrahim, Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. Mr Elias and Mrs Ibrahim applied for the visas on 21 March 2017 on the basis that Mr Elias was the carer of their sponsor, Hind KABALAN (aka Hind Koblan FAKHR), Mr Elias’ mother. At the time Class BU contained three subclasses: Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative); Subclass 836 (Carer); and Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative). In the present case, Mr Elias is seeking to satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 836 (Carer) visa. Mrs Ibrahim claims to be his wife and is seeking to satisfy the secondary criteria as a member of his family unit. The criteria for a Subclass 836 visa are set out in Part 836 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). The delegate refused to grant the visas on 15 February 2018 on the basis that cl.836.227 was not met because the sponsorship mentioned in cl.836.213 was not approved by the Minister or still in force. A copy of that decision was provided to the Tribunal by Mr Elias with his review application.

  3. Mr Elias and Mrs Ibrahim are represented in relation to the review by their solicitor. On 26 May 2021, the Tribunal wrote to them by letter addressed to Mr Elias through his authorised recipient, their solicitor, advising that it had considered all the material before it relating to their application but was unable to make a favourable decision on that information alone. The Tribunal invited Mr Elias and Mrs Ibrahim to give oral evidence and present arguments at a hearing on 29 June 2021 at the Tribunal’s Sydney Registry. On 9 June 2021, Mr Elias advised the Tribunal that they would attend the hearing to give oral evidence. However, on 23 June 2021, it was necessary to cancel that hearing due to the closure of the Tribunal’s Sydney Registry as part of a general lockdown of the Greater Sydney area caused by an outbreak of the novel corona virus, SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19). On 24 June 2021, the Tribunal was advised in writing that Mr Elias and Mrs Ibrahim did not wish…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elias (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 3583
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa, specifically a Subclass 836 (Carer visa), by Mr Elias, who claimed to be the carer of his mother, Ms Fakhr. The dispute arose because Ms Fakhr, the proposed sponsor, had passed away after the application was lodged but before a decision was made. The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Elias met the criteria for the visa, particularly the requirement that the sponsorship must be in force at the time of the decision.

The Tribunal considered clauses 836.212, 836.213, and 836.227 of the Migration Regulations 1994. While Mr Elias met the initial criteria of claiming to be a carer and being sponsored by his mother at the time of application, clause 836.227 stipulated that the sponsorship must still be in force at the time of the decision. Regulation 1.20(1) defines a sponsor as a person who undertakes certain obligations. As Ms Fakhr was deceased, she could no longer undertake these obligations, meaning the sponsorship was no longer in force. The Tribunal also considered applications for Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) and Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visas, finding that Mr Elias had not made a valid application for the former due to insufficient application fees, and did not meet the criteria for the latter as he was not dependent on his deceased mother.

The Tribunal applied the principle that a sponsorship must remain valid and operative at the time of decision, as established by the regulations. It relied on previous case law, including *Farook v MIBP* [2014] FCCA 1000, *Palanisamy v MIBP* [2013] FCCA 1779, and *Chaddha v MIMA* [2002] FCA 92, to confirm that where an applicant pays a lower fee for a visa subclass, it is clear they only applied for that specific subclass. Consequently, Mr Elias did not meet the requirements for the Subclass 836 visa due to the cessation of sponsorship, nor for the other subclasses considered.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions not to grant Mr Elias the visas. However, acknowledging the strong compassionate circumstances, including that Mr Elias and his relatives were in Australia while no relatives remained in Lebanon, the Tribunal referred the matter for the Minister's consideration regarding potential intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue in this case is whether Mr Elias is sponsored by his mother, Ms Fakhr, as her carer. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed, however it will refer the matter for the Minister’s consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Clause 836.212 is met if, at the time of application, an applicant claims to be the carer of an Australian relative. Clause 836.213 requires that the applicant is sponsored by that Australian relative, or the spouse or de facto partner of the Australian relative. Clause 836.227 states that, at the time of this decision, the sponsorship mentioned in cl.836.213 must have been approved by the Minister and still be in force. At the time of application, on 21 March 2017, Mr Elias claimed to be Ms Fakhr’s carer and she was his sponsor. Therefore, cl.836.212 and cl.836.213 are met. However, according to the delegate’s decision, on 24 January 2018, Mr Elias provided the Department with a death certificate recording that Ms Fakhr had passed away on 25 May 2017. Clause 836.227 requires that the sponsorship referred to in cl.836.213 must still be in force at the time of decision. Regulation 1.20(1) states that the sponsor of an applicant for a visa is a person who undertakes the obligations stated in subregulation (2) in relation to that applicant. At the time of this decision Ms Fakhr, who is deceased, cannot undertake those obligations and, therefore, her sponsorship is not still in force. Mr Elias does not meet cl.836.227 of the Regulations. For the reasons above, Mr Elias does not meet the criteria for a Subclass 836 visa. In respect of the other visa subclasses, there is no material which would permit a finding that Mr Elias meets prescribed criteria for an Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visa. The Tribunal finds that Mr Elias is not entitled to the grant of a Subclass 835 (Remaining Relative) visa because he did not make a valid visa application for that subclass. Item 1123B(2)(ii) in Schedule 1 to the Regulations requires that to make a valid application a fee of AUD3,870 must be paid at the time of application. Mr Elias only paid a fee of AUD1,595, being the fee for a Subclass 836 set out in Item 1123B(2)(i) of Schedule 1. In Farook v MIBP [2014] FCCA 1000 at [16]-[24] the Court found that, where the same application form was used for two different subclasses and the application fee for one subclass was lower than the other, if the applicant only paid the lower application fee it was clear beyond any doubt that the applicant had only applied for that subclass of visa and had unquestionably never applied for the subclass of visa with the higher application fee: see also Palanisamy v MIBP [2013] FCCA 1779 and Chaddha v MIMA [2002] FCA 92 at [27]-[28]. In these circumstances there was no error in only assessing the applicant against the subclass with the lower fee. As such, Mr Elias cannot be assessed against the criteria for a Subclass 835 visa. The Tribunal also finds that he is not entitled to the grant of a Subclass 838 (Aged Dependent Relative) visa since he is not dependent upon Ms Fakhr, who is deceased, as required by the definition of ‘aged dependent relative’ in r.1.03. Therefore, cl.838.221 is not met.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is for the Minister to determine whether the compassionate circumstances surrounding this case are in the public interest such that the Minister may exercise the power to substitute a decision that is more favourable to Michael Elias and Nawal Ibrahim.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decisions not to grant the applicants Other Family (Residence) (Class BU) visas.Mireya HylandMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.