Eliana Constructions and Developing Group Pty Ltd v Sidrak

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S CI 2014 00386

ELIANA CONSTRUCTIONS AND DEVELOPING GROUP PTY LTD Plaintiff
v  
AMGAD SIDRAK Defendant

---

JUDGE:

DIXON J

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

16 JUNE 2014

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

3 SEPTEMBER 2014

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

ELIANA CONSTRUCTIONS AND DEVELOPING GROUP PTY LTD v SIDRAK

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2014] VSC 418

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Appeal under Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic) s 148 – Application by owner for judgment on terms of settlement of a domestic building dispute - Dispute settled by parties returning to varied performance of the building contract with an agreement to engage an expert to perform certain assessment functions – Judgment entered for owner – Whether owner entitled to a money judgment for the expert’s assessed sum – Whether VCAT properly construed the terms of settlement and building contract - Whether ambiguity between terms of settlement and building contract about calculation of final payment on termination – Whether ambiguity affects orders that may be made on expert’s determination – Whether VCAT in error when ambiguity of contract not argued before it – Whether concession made by counsel at VCAT remains binding.

BUILDING CONTRACTS – Expert determination – Assessment of costs to complete and rectify defects – Assessment included value of variations - Whether expert’s report met the contractual description of his function – Whether assessments that did not form part of expert’s function are severable.

BUILDING CONTRACTS – Contract varied by terms of settlement – Contract deemed terminated by expert’s notice assessment that works were not being carried out in a timely proper or workmanlike manner – Terms of settlement provided that contract deemed terminated under cl 43 - Whether ambiguity between terms of settlement and building contract about calculation of final payment on termination – Whether ambiguity affects orders that may be made on expert’s determination – HIA Victorian New Homes Contract (January 2008) cls 44.0, 44.1

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr I Percy Yianoulatos Lawyers
For the Defendant Mr K Oliver David Naidoo & Associates

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction................................................................................................................................... 1

The status of the building contract............................................................................................. 1

Background events....................................................................................................................... 3

The issues....................................................................................................................................... 5

Was the proper construction of the TOS in issue in VCAT?......................................... 9

The ‘assessed amount’...................................................................................................... 11

Entitlement on termination.............................................................................................. 14

The presumed intended use of the expert’s determination........................................ 16

Error in VCAT’s assessment of the final payment on termination............................ 18

Grounds 1 to 3 - Did the Tribunal err in the proper construction and application of clauses 28 and 29 of the TOS?.......................................................................................................................... 23

The reasoning of VCAT.................................................................................................... 23

The builder’s contentions on appeal.............................................................................. 24

The owner’s submissions................................................................................................. 27

Resolution of grounds 1 – 3............................................................................................. 30

Grounds 4 & 5 - Was it within the Expert’s discretion to obtain and rely upon independent expert reports and certifications without the consent of the parties or on prior notice to them and at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eliana Constructions and Developing Group Pty Ltd v Sidrak and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] VSC 418
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this case were Eliana Constructions and Developing Group Pty Ltd and Sidrak. The dispute involved a domestic building contract, where the owner sought judgment on the terms of a settlement agreement. The settlement provided for the parties to return to the varied performance of the building contract, with an agreement to engage an expert to perform certain assessment functions. The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) entered a judgment for the owner, but the appellant questioned whether the owner was entitled to a money judgment for the expert's assessed sum and whether VCAT properly construed the terms of settlement and building contract. The appellant also argued that there was ambiguity between the terms of settlement and building contract about the calculation of final payment on termination, and that VCAT was in error when the ambiguity of the contract was not argued before it. Additionally, the appellant questioned whether the assessments that did not form part of the expert's function were severable.

The court was required to decide whether the owner was entitled to a money judgment for the expert's assessed sum, whether VCAT properly construed the terms of settlement and building contract, whether there was ambiguity between the terms of settlement and building contract about the calculation of final payment on termination, whether the ambiguity affected the orders that may be made on the expert's determination, and whether VCAT was in error when the ambiguity of the contract was not argued before it. The court also needed to determine whether the assessments that did not form part of the expert's function were severable.

The court found that the appeal was allowed and the orders of VCAT were set aside. The court held that there was ambiguity between the terms of settlement and building contract about the calculation of final payment on termination, and that the ambiguity affected the orders that may be made on the expert's determination. The court also held that VCAT was not in error when the ambiguity of the contract was not argued before it, as the ambiguity was not raised by the parties. However, the court found that the assessments that did not form part of the expert's function were severable, and that the expert's report met the contractual description of his function. The court held that the concession made by counsel at VCAT remained binding.

The final orders of the court were that leave to appeal was granted, the appeal was allowed, and paragraph 2 of the order of VCAT made on 20 December 2013 was set aside. As a consequence, paragraph 3 of that order was also set aside. The court proposed remitting the proceeding to VCAT for hearing and determination in accordance with the reasons and for resolution of the outstanding issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal is granted and the appeal is allowed.

Paragraph 2 of the order of VCAT made 20 December 2013 is set aside.

As a matter of consequence rather than error, paragraph 3 of that order will also be set aside.

In the circumstances, I would propose remitting the proceeding to VCAT for hearing and determination in accordance with my reasons and for resolution of the outstanding issue of costs.