Background
Background to the litigation
The matter proceeded to a final hearing on agreed facts, although the parties reserved their right to refer to evidence filed by them in so far as that evidence was not inconsistent with the agreed facts. The claims pursued by the unions are not identical but it was common ground that any differences in their formulation were not material to the resolution of the issues between the parties.The agreed facts1. The unions are organisations registered under the Act and are parties to the Metal Engineering and Associated Industries Award 1998 (“the Award”), an award of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission (“the Commission”), and the Email National Manufacturing Agreement 1999 (“the Agreement”), an agreement certified by the Commission.2. Electrolux is a manufacturing company producing white goods for the domestic and international markets under the brand names Westinghouse, Simpson, Chef, and Kelvinator. It has manufacturing facilities in a number of locations and is a respondent bound by the Award and a party to the Agreement. The unions have members employed in various classifications at Electrolux’s manufacturing facilities.3. The Agreement had a nominal expiry date of 30 June 2001, but continues to operate pursuant to the Act.4. The unions issued notices initiating bargaining periods pursuant to s 170MI of the Act. In accordance with s 170MJ(c) the notices stated that the matters that were proposed to be dealt with by the certified agreement included shop stewards access rights, employee entitlements and bargaining agents’ fees. Those claims were expressed as follows:·[r]ight of entry and Shop Stewards rights including the provision such as reasonable access for Shop Stewards to email, internet, facsimile, photocopying facilities and confidential interviews with new employees;…·[m]onthly payments to a trust fund approved by the AMWU – AWU - CEPU for:(a) the protection of workers’ entitlements; and(b) allowing for benefits to be portable across your…industry…;·[a] provision that ensures that in the event of a transmission of business…[the employer or the successor thereto]…pay into a trust fund approved by the AMWU – AWU – CEPU enough money to cover all affected employees’ accrued entitlements;…·payment of a bargaining agent’s fee.”5. Between April and September 2001 the parties conducted negotiations for a new certified agreement. The negotiations concerned the following union claims:“(a)Whether negotiations and any agreement would be national in nature, that is to say covering all of Electrolux’s operations in South Australia and New South Wales, or whether negotiations would be conducted and agreements entered on a site by site basis;(b)The Unions’ need for a common expiry date on any agreement or agreements;(c)The closure of the Brunswick Chef site and the possible outsourcing by Electrolux of part of its operations ‘off shore’;(d)The Unions’ claims for arrangements to protect employee entitlements, particularly in the context of insolvency, including the claim for Electrolux to become party to the Manusafe Scheme and claims for alternatives;(e)The claim by Unions that there should be no Australian Workplace Agreements;(f)Superannuation and the Union’s claim for paid meetings for Fund Managers to explain the proposal for transfer from the Email Superannuation Fund to the Electrolux Superannuation Fund, or Superannuation Fund of Australia;(g)The claim by the company that if claims being pursued were granted this would force the company to go out of business;(h)Redundancy and redundancy payments;(i)Consultative arrangements at workplaces;(j)Bargaining fees and the Unions’ claim that the employer should advise new employees that an Agents’ fee of $500.00 is payable to the Union by non-Union members to the Unions to reflect the service obtained by those non-members from the Unions in negotiating agreements, and that those employees should pay the amount and that the employer should provide a direct debit facility for the payments;(k)The contract labour arrangements;(l)Workers’ compensation makeup payments;(m)Provision for shop stewards and delegates;(n)Right of entry and Shop Stewards’ rights including the provisions such as reasonable access for Shop Stewards to email, internet, facsimile, photocopying facilities and confidential interviews with new employees;(o)Arrangements for salary sacrifice;(p)Wage increases;(q)Inclusion of ‘spare parts and detailing distribution’ as part of the subject of negotiation;(r)Parity of payments as between sites and classifications in South Australia;(s)The withdrawal of all Federal Court applications which had been initiated by Electrolux;(t)Improvements in leave and allowances already provided for in the Agreement, and set out in the model agreement;(u)The use of casuals;(v)Training and classifications;(w)Occupational health and safety;(x)Facilities, protective clothing and equipment;(y)Dispute settlement procedures;(z)Income protection.”6. During the negotiations officials of the unions produced a draft proposed national agreement to be used as the basis for further negotiations (“the proposed agreement”). The proposed agreement set out in detail the unions’ claims referred to in paras 4 and 5(d), (j) and (n) above for employee entitlements, a bargaining agent’s fee and shop stewards access to Electrolux’s facilities.(a) Employee entitlements“10.0 WAGES10.1.Employees who are bound by this agreement shall be paid a minimum wage increase of 6% per annum throughout the life of this agreement.Any existing over award payments will continue to be paid unless specifically stated otherwise by this agreement.10.2.In addition to 10.1, Electrolux Home Products agrees, to provide for the protection and portability of employees long service entitlements, by contributing the equivalent of 1.5% of an employee’s weekly wage into Manusafe. Payment of long service leave entitlements during the life of this agreement, will be in accordance with clause 13 of this agreement.10.3.In addition to the wage increases prescribed in 10.1 and 10.2, Electrolux Home Products agrees to pay $50.00 per week per employee into Manusafe towards an employee’s severance fund, subject to sub clause 10.3.1, which will be payable to each employee from the fund, upon termination of employment for any reason,.10.3.1.Electrolux Home Products employer will pay the severance pay contribution per week on a pro rata daily basis. A minimum of four hours worked in one day will constitute one day for the purpose of this sub clause.10.3.2.Payment from the Severance fund to an employee will be in accordance with clause 14, of this agreement.”11.0 MANUSAFE BENEFIT TRUST FUND11.1It is agreed that Electrolux Home Products will sign Schedule A (Deed of Adherence) of the Manusafe trust deed which is attached at Appendix 2 of this agreement and upon signing this agreement, and if the trustees approve the application, the company will become bound by the terms and conditions of the Manusafe trust deed.11.2Nothing in this sub clause will affect an employees rights to the various leave entitlements that he/she is entitled to under this agreement or the relevant award.11.3The total contribution to the fund per month for each employee covered by this agreement will be paid in accordance with the amounts specified in Appendix 1 to this agreement.11.4Contributions must continue while the employee is absent on paid annual leave, sick leave, long service leave, public holidays, jury service, bereavement leave or other paid leave. An employer need not make contributions in respect of any absence from work without pay.11.5If Electrolux Home Products is declared bankrupt or goes into liquidation the employee will be entitled to:11.5.1receive a cash payment from the Manusafe fund, in accordance with the Manusafe Trust Deed, of all entitlements that have accrued in the employee’s individual fund account; or11.5.2leave the accrued entitlements in the employee’s individual Manusafe account and take them with him/her to the next employer.12.0MANUSAFE AND TRANSMISSION OF BUSINESS12.1It is agreed that in the event that a transmission of business is to occur as defined in clause 4.4.2 of the Award and in order to protect employees accrued entitlements in the event of the transmittee being declared bankrupt or going into liquidation or voluntary administration, that the transmittor will pay employees accrued entitlements into Manusafe, prior to the transmission occurring.…13.0LONG SERVICE LEAVE AND MANUSAFE13.1The employer will be liable to pay any long service leave entitlement that has accrued up to the date of certification of this agreement and which actualises during the life of this agreement.13.2The contributions that are paid into Manusafe in accordance with clause 10.2, may be recovered by the employer from Manusafe, in the event that the entitlement accrued under the duration of this agreement, actualises during the life of this agreement. Under these circumstances the employer will pay the entitlement when it is taken and will be reimbursed from the individual employee’s Manusafe long service leave account.13.3Where an entitlement to long service leave does not actualise during the life of this agreement and an employee leaves before the qualifying period of five years, the contributions that have accrued up to the date of termination of employment with Electrolux Home Products employer, will remain in Manusafe and the employee will take the accrued funds with him/her to the next employer. The employee may access the accrued entitlement after five years from the date of choosing to leave the accrued entitlement in Manusafe.14.0SEVERANCE PAY AND MANUSAFE14.1Electrolux Home Products agrees to pay $50.00 per week, per employee covered by this agreement into the Manusafe Fund, towards providing for Severance benefits upon termination of employer with Electrolux Home Products. The severance entitlement will be include that provided for in clause 16.2 of this agreement.14.2When an employee leaves his/her employment leaves his/her employment, for any reason, with Electrolux Home Products employer, the employee will be entitled to access the funds accrued in Manusafe on his/her behalf or leave the funds in Manusafe and take it with him/her to the next employer.…15.0LONG SERVICE LEAVE15.1Long service leave shall accumulate at the rate of 13 weeks for every ten years of service and pro-rata thereafter. Long service leave shall be available after five years service on a pro-rata basis.15.2The terms of the Metal, Engineering and Associated Industries Award 1998 – Part IV shall apply, except for the quantum and accumulation rate of leave as prescribed herein.15.3Pro-rata Long Service Leave payments will be paid after 5 years.”The Manusafe Trust Deed provided for the trustee of the fund to maintain member’s accounts showing the amount paid in respect of the member’s entitlements. Under the Deed each employer is to pay a specified amount by way of contribution to the employee member’s entitlements. The Deed provided that:“Subject always to the terms of any relevant Industrial Agreement and any applicable law, if the Trustee in its absolute discretion considers that a Member is entitled to Employee Entitlements, the Trustee may pay the Benefit (or appropriate portion thereof) directly to the Member or the Member’s Beneficiary.”The Deed provided for the forfeiture of amounts credited to a member’s account in certain circumstances, such as bankruptcy or mental disability.The Deed provided for the Trustee to have power to re-imburse to an employer the amount paid by the employer directly to an employee in respect of the employee’s entitlements. It also provided that:“The Trustee may in its absolute discretion decide how and when to exercise its powers.”The trustee of the Manusafe Benefit Trust Deed was to be a company which had 50 ordinary shares divided into 25 A class shares known as union member shares and 25 B class shares known as employer shares. Each class of shares was to carry the same rights and privileges and was to rank pari passu in all respects.(b) Bargaining agent’s fee“46.0 BARGAINING AGENTS’ FEE46.1The company shall advise all employees prior to commencing work for the company that a ‘Bargaining Agents’ fee of $500.00 per annum is payable to the union.46.2The relevant employee to which this clause shall apply shall pay the ‘Bargaining Agents fee’ to the union in advance on a pro rata basis for any time which the employee is employed by the company. By arrangement with the union this can be done in quarterly instalments throughout the year.46.3The employer will, at the request of the employee to whom this clause applies, provide a direct debit facility to pay the bargaining agents fee to the union.”Notwithstanding the form in which the claim is expressed in the proposed agreement, the agreed facts and the evidence filed by the parties revealed that the bargaining agent’s fee was being claimed by the unions to be payable only by employees who were not union members to reflect the service obtained by those non-members from the unions in negotiating agreements under the Act.(c) Shop stewards accessClause 23 of the proposed agreement provided for employees who were appointed as shop stewards to be entitled to have adequate facilities in relation to matters affecting employees whom they represent. Clause 23.3 made provision for shop stewards to have access to a number of facilities at Electrolux’s workplaces to discharge their duties and responsibilities. The right of access challenged by Electrolux was set out in cl 23.3.7:“23.3.7The right of a shop steward and particularly a convenor or secretary of a combined union shop committee to have easy access to:· A telephone;· A word-processor, typewriter, or secretarial support;· Access to personal computers (PC), CD ROM and E-mail and the Internet at the workplace, and for employer-sponsored access to email and the Internet at home (such as through leasing arrangements) with the privacy of such access to be guaranteed and include the right to create a website;· A lockable cabinet to keep union records, circulars, receipt books etc.;· A photocopier and facsimile machine;· A meeting room (as opposed to a meal room);· Lockable notice boards displayed in prominent positions under the control of the shop steward which are solely for authorised union notices;Plus any other reasonable facilities as required for shop stewards to discharge their responsibilities and duties.”7. In September 2001, during the bargaining period and after the unions had authorised industrial action under the Act, the unions issued separate notices to Electrolux that they intended to organise and engage in industrial action that was “protected action” under s 170ML of the Act. Electrolux and the unions were in dispute over a significant number of the unions’ claims which had been the subject of negotiations, including the claims for employee entitlements, the bargaining agent’s fee and shop stewards access rights.8. The unions propounded their claims for employee entitlements by claiming that Electrolux agree to participate in the Manusafe scheme. The unions, however, were prepared to negotiate about an alternative scheme providing substantially the same benefits and using substantially the same mechanisms as those provided for by Manusafe. The unions’ negotiating position was that Manusafe was not non-negotiable and that alternative forms would be considered which protected employee entitlements. Electrolux had made it clear in the course of negotiations that it would not negotiate about Manusafe or any other similar scheme, and would not negotiate about the bargaining agent’s fee in any form.
Decision
Reasons for decision
My decision in the present case is on the basis that the claim in question relates to a substantive, discrete, and significant matter that does not pertain to the employment relationship. While I entertain some doubt as to whether a proper characterisation of an agreement for the purposes of s 170LI involves questions of degree, I leave for another case the question of whether a claim in respect of a matter that does not pertain to the employment relationship, but is not of significance, may be included in a certified agreement.Conclusion The industrial action taken in September 2001 by the unions, pursuant to the notices issued under s 170MO, was action for the purpose of supporting or advancing claims made in respect of a proposed agreement that was not an agreement about matters that pertained to the relationship between Electrolux and its employees, as such. Consequently, the industrial action was not protected action under the Act. Electrolux is entitled to declaratory relief that gives effect to my conclusions. I propose to give directions for the parties to file submissions about the form of that declaratory relief and about whether, in all the circumstances, any other relief is appropriate or necessary.