Electrical Licensing Committee v Whatalec Pty Ltd; Electrical Licensing Committee v Brindley

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Electrical Licensing Committee v Whatalec Pty Ltd; Electrical Licensing Committee v Brindley [2021] QSC 159

PARTIES:

In BS 2573 of 2021:

ELECTRICAL LICENSING COMMITTEE
(applicant)

v
WHATALEC PTY LTD
ACN 147 142 210
(respondent)

In BS 2575 of 2021:

ELECTRICAL LICENSING COMMITTEE
(applicant)

v
MICHAEL PAUL BRINDLEY
(respondent)

FILE NOS:

BS 2573 of 2021
BS 2575 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

DELIVERED ON:

25 June 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 May 2021

JUDGE:

Holmes CJ

ORDERS:

1. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Whatalec Pty Ltd on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.

2. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Michael Paul Brindley on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT – REVIEW OF PARTICULAR DECISIONS – where the applicant made a decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(a) of the Electrical Safety Act 2002 (“the Act”), that a ground existed for taking disciplinary action against each of the respondents – where the applicant made a further decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(b) of the Act, to take disciplinary action against each of the respondents – where the respondents sought review of the applicant’s decision in each case – where the applicant now applies under s 13 and/or s 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 for the dismissal of the respondents’ applications for statutory orders of review – where s 172 of the Act provides for external review by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“QCAT review”) of a “disciplinary decision” as defined in s 167 of the Act – where the applicant contends that the QCAT review process would encompass, as well as review of the decision to take disciplinary action, consideration of the grounds on which it was made, so that the applications for statutory orders of review should be dismissed – where the respondents contend that the right of review under s 172 of the Act is confined to the decisions as to whether, and what, disciplinary action should be taken and excludes the decision as to whether grounds existed for taking that action – whether QCAT review is available for both the s121(a) decisions that grounds exist and the s 121(b) decisions as to whether and what action should be taken, so that the respondents’ applications for statutory orders of review should be dismissed

STATUTE – ACTS OF PARLIAMENT – INTERPRETATION – GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION – PARTICULAR WORDS AND PHRASES – GENERALLY – where the applicant made a decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(a) of the Electrical Safety Act 2002 (“the Act”), that a ground existed for taking disciplinary action against each of the respondents – where the applicant made a further decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(b) of the Act, to take disciplinary action against each of the respondents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Electrical Licensing Committee v Whatalec Pty Ltd; Electrica... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Electrical Licensing Committee applied for dismissal of applications for statutory orders of review brought by Whatalec Pty Ltd and Michael Paul Brindley against decisions made by the Committee under the Electrical Safety Act 2002. The Committee had decided that grounds existed for taking disciplinary action against each respondent (a decision under s 121(1)(a) of the Act) and that disciplinary action should be taken against them (a decision under s 121(1)(b) of the Act). The respondents sought review of the Committee’s decisions, but the Committee argued that review of the decisions was not available because the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) could review the decisions instead. The issue for the court was whether QCAT review was available for both the s 121(1)(a) decisions that grounds exist and the s 121(1)(b) decisions as to whether and what action should be taken, so that the respondents’ applications for statutory orders of review should be dismissed.

The court found that the definition of “disciplinary decision” in the Electrical Safety Act limited review to decisions about whether disciplinary action should be taken and its details if it were. The decision as to whether the ground exists for taking disciplinary action was not a “disciplinary decision” reviewable by QCAT. In the circumstances of this case, both respondents received an information notice from the Committee which advised them that there was no right of review in relation to the s 121(1)(a) decision, but that they could seek review of the s 121(1)(b) decisions that disciplinary action would be taken and what that action would be. The court concluded that the respondents’ applications for statutory orders of review should be dismissed.

1. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Whatalec Pty Ltd on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.
2. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Michael Paul Brindley on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Whatalec Pty Ltd on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.

2. That the application for a statutory order of review filed by the applicant Michael Paul Brindley on 8 March 2021 be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the Judicial Review Act 1991.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Electrical Licensing Committee (the Committee) made a decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(a) of the Electrical Safety Act 2002, that a ground existed for taking disciplinary action against Whatalec Pty Ltd and Michael Paul Brindley. The Committee subsequently made a further decision, pursuant to s 121(1)(b) of the Act, to take disciplinary action against each respondent. Both respondents then sought review of the Committee's decisions. The Committee now applies under s 13 and/or s 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 for the dismissal of the respondents' applications for statutory orders of review. The respondents contend that the right of review under s 172 of the Electrical Safety Act 2002 is confined to the decisions as to whether, and what, disciplinary action should be taken, excluding the decision as to whether grounds existed for taking that action.

The case involves an application by the Electrical Licensing Committee to dismiss the respondents' applications for statutory orders of review under s 13 and/or s 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991. The respondents had sought review of the Committee's decisions under s 121(1)(a) and s 121(1)(b) of the Electrical Safety Act 2002. Section 172 of the Electrical Safety Act 2002 provides for external review by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) of a "disciplinary decision" as defined in s 167 of the Act. The Committee contends that QCAT review would encompass consideration of the grounds on which the disciplinary action was taken, leading to the argument that the respondents' applications for statutory orders of review should be dismissed. The respondents argue that QCAT review is only available for decisions about whether and what disciplinary action should be taken, and not for decisions about whether grounds exist for taking such action.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 172 of the Act permits a person whose interests are affected by a “disciplinary decision” to seek review of it by QCAT. “Disciplinary decision” is defined in s 167:disciplinary decision means a decision of the licensing committee about— (a)whether to take disciplinary action against the holder of an electrical licence; or The approach of both parties was to read that definition as matching, and limited to, the decisions identified in s 121(b): whether disciplinary action was to be taken and its details if it were. That reading has the effect that the earlier decision as to whether the ground exists for taking disciplinary action is not a “disciplinary decision” reviewable by QCAT. Indeed, in this case, both respondents received an information notice (as required by s 121(c)) from the Committee which advised them that there was no right of review in relation to the s 121(1)(a) decision, but that they could seek review of the s 121(1)(b) decisions that disciplinary action would be taken and what that action would be. The Judicial Review Act The provisions of the Judicial Review Act under which the Committee sought dismissal of the applications for statutory orders of review were s 13 and s 48. Section 13 is as follows: 13 When application for statutory order of review must be dismissed Despite section 10, but without limiting section 48, if—(a)an application under section 20 to 22 or 43 is made to the court in relation to a reviewable matter; and (b)provision is made by a law, other than this Act, under which the applicant is entitled to seek a review of the matter by another court or a tribunal, authority or person; the court must dismiss the application if it is satisfied, having regard to the interests of justice, that it should do so.A “reviewable matter” is defined in s 3 of the Judicial Review Act as meaning:“(a) a decision; or(b) conduct, including conduct engaged in for the purpose of making a decision; or(c) a failure to make a decision or to perform a duty according to law.” Section 48(1), expressed in broader terms, sets out an additional power:48 Power of the court to stay or dismiss applications in certain circumstances (1)The court may stay or dismiss an application under section 20, 21, 22 or 43 or a claim for relief in such an application, if the court considers that— (a) it would be inappropriate— (i)for proceedings in relation to the application or claim to be continued; or (ii) to grant the application or claim; or (b) no reasonable basis for the application or claim is disclosed; or (c) the application or claim is frivolous or vexatious; or (d) the application or claim is an abuse of the process of the court.The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act The Electrical Safety Act is an “enabling Act” for the purposes of s 6 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act; it confers review jurisdiction on QCAT. Section 9 of the latter Act gives QCAT power to do “all things necessary or convenient” for exercising the jurisdiction conferred by an enabling Act, and s 19(c) provides that in the exercise of its review jurisdiction, the tribunal “…has all the functions of the decision-maker for the reviewable decision being reviewed”.Section 20 provides that review is “by way of a fresh hearing on the merits”, with its purpose being “to produce the correct and preferable decision”. The contentions as to the scope of review

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the scope of QCAT review under s 172 of the Electrical Safety Act 2002, focusing on the definition of "disciplinary decision" in s 167. The definition in s 167 was interpreted to pertain to decisions about whether to take disciplinary action and what disciplinary action to take, aligning with the decisions identified in s 121(b). This interpretation led to the conclusion that the earlier decision as to whether grounds exist for taking disciplinary action is not a "disciplinary decision" subject to QCAT review. The court further considered the provisions of the Judicial Review Act 1991, specifically s 13 and s 48, which allow for the dismissal of applications for statutory orders of review if an alternative review is available by another court or tribunal. Given that the respondents had already been notified of their right to review only the s 121(b) decisions, the court found no basis to entertain the respondents' applications for statutory orders of review. The binding legal principle established is that QCAT review under s 172 is limited to decisions about whether and what disciplinary action should be taken, excluding decisions on whether grounds exist for such action.