Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd v Gooden (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

[2014] QDC 110

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE BAULCH SC

No 140 of 2014

ELDERS RURAL SERVICES AUSTRALIA
PTY LTD and ANOTHER  Applicants

and

ANTONY JOHN GOODEN  Respondent

TOWNSVILLE

10.01 AM, FRIDAY, 28 MARCH 2014

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:   On the 28th of February this year, I gave judgment in this application in Brisbane.  The matter had proceeded before me over six hearing days, and because the respondent was subject to an interim injunction restraining him from entering into employment with his desired employer, it seemed to me to be appropriate that I announce a decision then and deliver reasons at a later date.  I concluded that the restraints relied upon by the applicants were void for uncertainty, wider than was necessary to protect the applicant’s legitimate interests, and unable to be remedied either by reading them down or severing parts of them to leave an enforceable remainder.  It followed that the applicants could not succeed in the claim for an injunction or in respect of the claim for damages which had been added by leave.  Accordingly, I ordered on that day that the originating application filed the 16th of December 2013 and amended by leave be dismissed and that the order of Judge Ryrie made the 15th of January 2014 and varied by me be dissolved.  For completeness insofar as any restraint depended on an undertaking, I order that the respondent be released from any undertaking given during the proceedings. 

These are my reasons for making those orders.  The application concerns an attempt by an employer and a related company to enforce a restraint clause against an employee.  The respondent, Mr Gooden, worked for Elders for more than a quarter of a century before giving notice to terminate his employment in September 2013.  He gave three months notice in accordance with his contract and was required by his employer to work out the period of notice.  In December 2013, the present proceeding was commenced by originating application, and subsequently, Judge Ryrie in the District Court made an interim order and set the matter down for trial in the District Court at Brisbane, commencing Monday the 10th of February 2014.  It was anticipated then that the hearing would be finalised during that week.  As things turned out, it could not be completed in the available time and was resumed on the 26th of February and completed on the 27th of February this year. 

Mr Gooden commenced his employment with the Elders group on 12 January 1987.  He was initially employed as an administrative trainee.  On the 1st of June 1987, he was appointed to a position of salesman, where he remained until he was appointed as a territory sales manager on the 30th of June 1990.  On 15 February 1994, he was appointed a branch manager and remained in that position until appointed an area manager on 6 July 1998.  He became the livestock manager for South Australia and the Northern…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd v Gooden (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QDC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd v Gooden (No 2) [2014] QDC 110 involves an application by Elders Rural Services Australia Limited and another applicant to enforce a restraint clause against Mr Gooden, an employee who had worked for Elders for over 25 years. The dispute concerns the validity and enforceability of a post-employment restraint clause in Mr Gooden's employment contract. The matter was heard in the District Court of Queensland.

The legal issues in this case primarily revolve around the validity of the restraint clause in Mr Gooden's employment contract. The court had to determine whether the clause was void for uncertainty, whether it was reasonable and necessary to protect the employer's legitimate interests, and if it could be read down or severed to make it enforceable. The applicants argued that the clause was clear, reasonable, and necessary to protect their business interests, while Mr Gooden contended that the clause was overly broad, uncertain, and therefore unenforceable.

The court found that the restraint clause was indeed void for uncertainty due to its broad and undefined terms, making it impossible to determine its precise scope and meaning. The clause, which aimed to restrict Mr Gooden from competing with or soliciting employees, clients, or engaging in activities that would harm the employer's business, was found to be overly vague and wide-ranging. The court held that the clause's terms were not sufficiently defined, and its scope could not be determined with any degree of certainty. This finding aligns with the principle that courts should not enforce contracts that are uncertain or leave essential terms to be determined by the court.

Further, the court concluded that even if the clause could be interpreted to some extent, it was still wider than necessary to protect the employer's legitimate interests. The clause extended to a wide range of activities and entities, far beyond what would be necessary to protect the employer's business in the cattle trade, which was the primary area of Mr Gooden's employment. The court held that the clause was not reasonably necessary to protect the employer's interests and was therefore unenforceable.

In summary, the court dismissed the application by Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and the other applicant to enforce the restraint clause against Mr Gooden. The clause was found to be void for uncertainty and wider than necessary to protect the employer's legitimate interests. As a result, the court held that the restraint clause was unenforceable, and the application was dismissed. The court also directed the parties to file written submissions concerning costs and indicated that it would deal with the matter of costs based on those submissions unless there were compelling reasons for an oral hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.