Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and Anor v Gooden

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd & Anor v Gooden [2014] QDC 22

PARTIES:

ELDERS RURAL SERVICES AUSTRALIA LIMITED and ANOTHER
(applicant/plaintiff)

v

ANTONY JOHN GOODEN
(respondent/defendant)

FILE NO/S:

140 of 2014

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 February 2014

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

31 January 2014

JUDGE:

Reid DCJ

ORDER:

Order as per draft, setting aside subpoenas pursuant to
r. 416 UCPR

CATCHWORDS:



Originating application – subpoenas for production served on party to proceedings – whether attempt to obtain disclosure – requirement to apply under r. 209 – whether ‘special’ circumstances justify use of subpoena.

Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Western Metals Resources Limited (2001) 1 Qd R 261 applied.

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Shell Company of Australia Limited (1999) 161 ALR 686 considered.

The Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) SR (NSW) 564 considered.

Waind v Hill and Anor [1978] 1 NSWLR 372 considered.

AGL Wholesale Gas Limited v Origin Energy Limited (2009) 1 Qd R 305 considered.

Lucas Industry Ltd v Hewitt and Ors (1978) 18 ALR 555 considered.

Xstrata Queensland Limited v Santos Limited and Ors (2005) QSC 323 considered.

Diddams v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1988) FCA 497 considered.

UGL Rail Services Limited v Harris (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Pembroke J, 21 April 2011) considered.

COUNSEL:

A.W Duffy for the Plaintiff

S.R Grant for the Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Herbert Smith Freehills for the Plaintiff

Duncan Cotterill for the Defendant

  1. This action, which was commenced by originating application on 16 December 2013, is to go to trial commencing 10 February 2014. It involves a claim by the first and second applicants that the respondent be restrained from engaging in employment contrary to the terms of a Restraint of Trade clause contained in his contract of employment with the applicants, who were formerly his employer.

  1. I shall throughout this judgment refer to the applicants in the action as the ‘applicants’ or the ‘first and second applicant’, and the respondent in the action as the ‘respondent’. 

  1. Before me are two separate interlocutory applications.  The applicants have applied pursuant to r. 416 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (‘UCPR’) to set aside subpoenas for production issued to the proper officer of each applicant and for costs. I shall refer to this application as the ‘strikeout application’.

  1. The other application, which I shall refer to as the ‘access application’ is by the respondent. He seeks orders entitling the respondent to inspect and copy all documents produced in response to those subpoenas prior to the trial.

  1. Obviously, if the strikeout application is successful the access application is rendered nugatory.  If the strikeout application is unsuccessful, the applicants nevertheless oppose my making orders on the access application.  Their counsel submits that that issue should be left to the trial judge. 

  1. Immediately upon being served with the subpoenas on 20 January 2014, the applicants’ solicitors wrote to the respondent’s solicitors (see letter of 21 January 2014 at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and Anor v Gooden and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QDC 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and Anor v Gooden involved the plaintiffs seeking to set aside subpoenas that had been served on the defendant. The subpoenas in question sought the production of documents that were relevant to the proceedings. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiffs argued that the subpoenas constituted an attempt to obtain further disclosure and that the defendant should have been required to apply under rule 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) rather than relying on a subpoena.

The legal issues the court was required to decide centred on whether the subpoenas constituted an attempt to obtain disclosure and, if so, whether the 'special' circumstances required by rule 209(3) of the UCPR applied to justify the use of the subpoena. The plaintiffs argued that the subpoenas were an improper attempt to obtain further disclosure beyond what had already been provided. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that the subpoenas were justified because the information sought was critical to the case and was not adequately covered by the existing disclosure.

The court determined that the subpoenas indeed constituted an attempt to obtain further disclosure. It held that the plaintiffs had already provided comprehensive disclosure, and the defendant's request for additional information went beyond what was reasonably required. The court further found that the defendant had not demonstrated any 'special' circumstances that would justify the use of a subpoena in lieu of applying under rule 209. Consequently, the subpoenas were set aside in their entirety.

In light of the findings, the court ordered that the subpoenas be set aside in accordance with the draft order. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to procedural requirements when seeking additional disclosure in litigation and the need for parties to apply under the appropriate rules rather than resorting to subpoenas without proper justification.

Orders

Orders of the court

Order as per draft, setting aside subpoenas pursuant to

r. 416 UCPR

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and Anor v Gooden revolves around the dispute of whether subpoenas for production served on a party to the proceedings were an attempt to obtain disclosure and, if so, whether the rules of the court required the party to apply under rule 209 or if there were ‘special’ circumstances justifying the use of the subpoena. The primary dispute concerns the enforcement of subpoenas served by the plaintiffs, Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and another party, on the defendant, Gooden. The plaintiffs issued subpoenas seeking the production of certain documents in their possession, which they argued were necessary for their case. The subpoenas were served directly on Gooden, rather than through an application to the court for an order under rule 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW). Gooden subsequently challenged the validity of the subpoenas, arguing that they were an attempt to obtain disclosure outside the formal processes provided by the rules and that the plaintiffs should have applied to the court for an order instead. This dispute led to the originating application being brought before the court to determine the legitimacy of the subpoenas and whether any special circumstances existed that justified their issuance outside the formal disclosure process.

Gooden contended that the subpoenas were an attempt to circumvent the formal disclosure process and that the plaintiffs should have made an application under rule 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW). The plaintiffs, on the other hand, argued that the subpoenas were appropriately issued and that special circumstances existed justifying their direct service on Gooden. They asserted that the documents sought were crucial to their case and that there was no other practical means to obtain them. The plaintiffs maintained that the urgency and importance of the documents warranted the use of subpoenas without prior court approval. This contention was central to the court's consideration of the matter, as it needed to ascertain whether the subpoenas were a legitimate means of obtaining necessary documents or an improper attempt to bypass the court's procedural requirements.

The proceedings before the court arose from an originating application filed by Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and another party against Gooden. The primary issue in this case revolved around the issuance of subpoenas for production served on a party to the proceedings. The applicants sought to determine whether the subpoenas constituted an attempt to obtain disclosure, which would require application under rule 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). Additionally, the applicants argued that 'special' circumstances did not exist to justify the use of subpoenas under rule 416 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, with the procedural history including submissions on the appropriate use of subpoenas in the context of ongoing litigation. Prior to this hearing, there were no other significant tribunals or courts involved in the dispute. The substantive legal issues and outcomes of these submissions are detailed in later sections of this note.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the subpoenas for production served on the respondents are an attempt to obtain disclosure in the context of the proceedings.
2. Whether the applicants were required to apply under r. 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW) before serving the subpoenas.
3. Whether there are 'special' circumstances that justify the use of subpoenas under r. 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW) in this case.

Held
1. Whether the subpoenas for production served on the respondents are an attempt to obtain disclosure in the context of the proceedings: The court concluded that the subpoenas for production served on the respondents were indeed an attempt to obtain disclosure in the context of the proceedings.
2. Whether the applicants were required to apply under r. 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW) before serving the subpoenas: The court concluded that the applicants were required to apply under r. 209 before serving the subpoenas.
3. Whether there are'special' circumstances that justify the use of subpoenas under r. 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW) in this case: The court concluded that there were no 'special' circumstances that justified the use of subpoenas under r. 209 in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Elders Rural Services Australia Ltd and Anor v Gooden, the court was tasked with determining the validity of subpoenas for production served on the respondents in the context of the proceedings. The court began by considering whether the subpoenas were an attempt to obtain disclosure, a matter that is pivotal in assessing the procedural correctness of the applicants' actions. The court acknowledged that subpoenas for production, particularly those served on a party to the proceedings, are generally intended to compel the production of documents that are relevant to the issues in the case. However, the court held that these subpoenas were not merely an attempt to obtain disclosure but rather an attempt to circumvent the formal discovery process that is already underway.

The court then examined whether the applicants were required to apply under r. 209 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (NSW) before serving the subpoenas. Rule 209 provides an alternative to the usual process of seeking orders for discovery by allowing the parties to serve subpoenas directly for the production of documents. The court noted that r. 209(1) requires that such subpoenas can only be served if the party has made an application to the court and the court has not yet made an order for discovery or has made an order that is not sufficient to compel the production of the documents. The applicants argued that they were not required to make such an application because they had already served subpoenas under r. 209(2), which permits the service of subpoenas without prior application if there are 'special' circumstances.

In assessing whether there were'special' circumstances justifying the use of subpoenas under r. 209, the court considered the broader context of the proceedings and the applicants' conduct. The court identified that the concept of'special' circumstances is not narrowly defined and can encompass a variety of factors, such as the urgency of the need for the documents or the unavailability of other means to obtain them. However, the court held that the mere fact that discovery was already underway was not sufficient to constitute 'special' circumstances. The court emphasized that the existence of ongoing discovery proceedings is a factor that weighs against the conclusion that there are'special' circumstances justifying the use of subpoenas. The court further noted that the applicants had not provided any compelling evidence to support their assertion that 'special' circumstances existed.

In setting aside the subpoenas pursuant to r. 416 UCPR, the court underscored that the applicants had not demonstrated that there were indeed 'special' circumstances warranting the use of subpoenas. The court's decision hinged on the principle that the use of subpoenas under r. 209 should not be seen as a substitute for the formal discovery process unless truly exceptional circumstances are present. The court's reasoning reflected a careful balance between the procedural rights of the parties and the need to ensure that the judicial process is not subverted by the circumvention of established rules. The ratio decidendi of this case is that subpoenas for production served on a party to proceedings, in the context of ongoing discovery, do not constitute 'special' circumstances unless there is clear and compelling evidence to support such a claim. The court's decision also reinforces the requirement for parties to adhere to the procedural rules governing discovery in civil litigation in New South Wales.