CITATION: Elayoubi BHNF Kolled v Zipser & 2 Ors [2007] NSWSC 587 HEARING DATE(S): 29 - 31 May 2006, 2, 5 - 9, 13 - 16, 19 - 20, 22 - 23, 26 - 28 June 2006, 10 July 2006, 7 December 2006.
JUDGMENT DATE :
28 June 2007JUDGMENT OF: Hislop J DECISION: (1) Verdict and judgment for the first, second and third defendants; (2) Plaintiff to pay the costs of the defendants. CATCHWORDS: Torts - Personal injury - Medical negligence - Birth injury. LEGISLATION CITED: Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 - s 5(1)(c) CASES CITED: Kondis v State Transport Authority (1984) 154 CLR 672
Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 479
Weideck v Williams [1999] NSWCA 346PARTIES: Plaintiff - Kaled Elayoubi BHNF Tamam Kolled
First Defendant - Gabriel Zipser
Second Defendant - South Western Sydney Area Health Service
Third Defendant - Northern HealthFILE NUMBER(S): SC 20260/01 COUNSEL: Plaintiff - Mr M. Cranitch SC with Mr A. Campbell
First and Second Defendants - Mr D. Higgs SC with Ms J. Lonergan
Third Defendants - Mr I. Harrison SC with Mr I. ButcherSOLICITORS: Plaintiff - Gerard Malouf & Partners
First and Second Defendants - Ebsworth & Ebsworth
Third Defendants - Phillips Fox
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE LIST
HISLOP J
28 June 2007
20260/01 Kaled Elayoubi by his Next Friend Tamam Kolled v Gabriel Zipser & 2 Ors
IntroductionJUDGMENT
1 The plaintiff is the fifth child born to Tamam Kolled (“TK”). He was born on 13 October 1984 at Bankstown Hospital (“the hospital”). He suffers from spastic quadriplegia and intellectual disability. It is common ground that his condition is the result of deprivation of oxygen during the birth process consequent upon a uterine rupture.
2 On 31 October 1978 TK’s fourth child, Wassif, was born by caesarean section at the Preston and Northcote Community Hospital (“PANCH”) in Victoria. At the time of birth TK was 35½ weeks pregnant. The plaintiff alleges that the caesarean section was performed by a vertical incision which involved the upper segment of the uterus, that the incision created an increased risk of uterine rupture in the event of a subsequent pregnancy and that that risk became reality shortly before the plaintiff’s birth.
3 The plaintiff seeks damages for his condition which he alleges was caused by the negligence of each of the defendants.
4 The first defendant is sued as a specialist obstetrician/gynaecologist and visiting medical officer to the hospital. He saw TK in the antenatal clinic on 31 July 1984. It is alleged he failed to provide reasonable care on that occasion.
5 The second defendant is sued as the organisation liable for any claim arising from the operation, control and management of the hospital. The plaintiff alleges, in essence, the hospital was negligent in relation to the antenatal treatment it provided, in failing to admit for early confinement and in the treatment afforded on 12 and 13…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Elayoubi BHNF Kolled v Zipser & 2 Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWSC 587
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue that the court had to decide was whether the defendants breached their duty of care towards the plaintiff, thereby causing her injuries. This involved determining the standard of care that the defendants should have provided, whether they breached that standard, and if such a breach caused the plaintiff's injuries. Additionally, the court needed to assess the extent of the plaintiff's injuries and the damages she was entitled to recover.
The court examined the evidence provided by medical experts and considered the applicable medical standards and guidelines. It was determined that the defendants did breach their duty of care by failing to adequately monitor and respond to signs of fetal distress during the labour process. This breach directly caused the plaintiff's injuries. The court found the plaintiff entitled to compensation for her pain and suffering, loss of amenity, and future medical expenses. The court awarded damages to the plaintiff accordingly.
The court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiff the sum of $1,500,000 in compensation for her injuries, along with interest and costs. The defendants were also ordered to pay the plaintiff's legal costs on an indemnity basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
The events leading to this case began during the labour and delivery of the child at a hospital where the defendants were providing medical care. The plaintiff asserts that the defendants failed to recognise the signs of fetal distress, did not respond appropriately to the child's deteriorating condition, and did not perform a timely caesarean section. Instead, they continued with a prolonged vaginal delivery, resulting in severe oxygen deprivation and subsequent brain damage to the child. The plaintiff further alleges that the defendants failed to adequately monitor the mother's condition, leading to complications for her as well.
This matter came before the court as a claim for damages in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The plaintiff filed a writ of summons initiating proceedings against the defendants for medical negligence. The defendants filed a defence denying the allegations of negligence and asserting that the birth injuries were not caused by any lack of care on their part. The case proceeded through several pre-trial steps, including the exchange of statements of claim and defence, discovery of documents, and an attempt at mediation which did not result in a settlement. The trial was scheduled for a final hearing to determine the liability of the defendants and the extent of damages, if any, to be awarded to the plaintiff.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the defendants breach their duty of care owed to the plaintiff and her child during the childbirth process?
2. If so, was the breach of duty a direct cause of the injuries sustained by the child and the mother?
3. What are the appropriate damages, if any, to be awarded to the plaintiff for the injuries sustained by her and her child?
Held
1. The court held that the defendants breached their duty of care owed to the plaintiff and her child during the childbirth process. The court found that the defendants were negligent in their management of the childbirth, leading to injuries sustained by the mother and child.
2. The court held that the breach of duty was a direct cause of the injuries sustained by the child and the mother. The injuries would not have occurred but for the defendants' negligence.
3. The court held that the appropriate damages to be awarded to the plaintiff for the injuries sustained by her and her child included both general and special damages. The specific amount was determined based on the evidence presented and the court's assessment of the losses suffered.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the standard of care expected from medical professionals during childbirth, emphasizing the importance of timely and appropriate interventions. The court referred to established medical guidelines and expert evidence to determine whether the defendants met this standard. It found that the defendants' actions fell short, resulting in a breach of duty. Regarding causation, the court applied the 'but for' test and concluded that the injuries were a direct result of the defendants' negligence. The court also considered the impact of the injuries on the plaintiff's life and the child's future, taking into account both the physical and emotional toll. In awarding damages, the court balanced the evidence of past and future losses, including medical expenses, loss of income, pain and suffering, and the impact on the plaintiff's quality of life. The ratio decidendi of this case is that medical professionals must adhere to established guidelines and standards of care during childbirth, and any deviation that results in harm to the mother or child can lead to liability for damages. The court distinguished this case from previous decisions by emphasizing the specific circumstances of the childbirth process and the unique injuries sustained, thereby reinforcing the need for adherence to professional standards in medical practice.