El-Wasfi v NSW; Kassas v NSW (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: El-Wasfi v State of New South Wales; Kassas v State of New South Wales (No 2) [2018] NSWCA 27
Hearing dates: On the papers
Decision date: 27 February 2018
Before: Leeming JA, Simpson JA, Payne JA
Decision:

1. In Mr El-Wasfi’s appeal (2016/295735), appellant to pay the respondent’s costs.
2. In the appeal brought by Messrs Kassas, Pound and Ashley Saad (2017/293409), the appellants to pay the State’s costs.
3. In proceedings 2007/265173 and 2008/20521, the plaintiffs to pay the defendant’s costs on an ordinary basis until 15 January 2014, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Catchwords: COSTS - offer of compromise - whether unreasonable to reject “walk-away” offer - effect of general order as to costs of proceedings upon interlocutory costs orders.
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42
Cases Cited: El-Wasfi v State of New South Wales; Kassas v State of New South Wales [2017] NSWCA 332
Fred Saad & Ors v State of New South Wales; Ashley Saad v State of New South Wales (No 2) [2016] NSWSC 1482
Showtime Touring Group Pty Ltd v Mosley Touring Inc [2013] NSWCA 53; 296 ALR 597
Bull Nominees Pty Ltd Trading As Grassy Car Hire v Dr G R McElwee (1997) 7 Tas R 339; [1997] TASSC 148
Saad v State of New South Wales (No 3) [2014] NSWSC 214
Walter v Bewicke (1904) 90 LT 409
Category:Costs
Parties:

Proceeding 2016/295735
James El-Wasfi (Appellant)
State of New South Wales (Respondent)

  Proceeding 2017/293409
Sam Kassas (First Appellant)
Andrew Pound (Second Appellant)
Ashley Saad (Third Appellant)
State of New South Wales (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
D Villa (State of New South Wales)

  Solicitors:
Magiotta Solicitors (Appellants)
Crown Solicitor’s Office (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2016/295735; 2017/293409
Publication restriction: Nil
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court
Jurisdiction:
Common Law
Citation:
Fred Saad & Ors v State of New South Wales; Ashley Saad v State of New South Wales [2016] NSWSC 1247
Date of Decision:
12 September 2016
Before:
R S Hulme AJ
File Number(s):
2007/265173; 2008/20521

Judgment

  1. THE COURT: Late last year, this Court dismissed the appeals brought by Messrs El-Wasfi, Kassas, Pound and Ashley Saad and allowed the State’s cross-appeal: El-Wasfi v State of New South Wales; Kassas v State of New South Wales [2017] NSWCA 332. The result was that both proceedings brought against the State at first instance were dismissed. At the parties’ request, the parties were granted leave to be heard separately as to costs.

  2. The Court directed the filing of agreed orders as to costs, or in default of agreement, written submissions as to costs not exceeding five pages, by 8 February 2018. The State supplied submissions in support of the orders for which it contended on 8 February 2018. No submissions were received from the other parties, and all counsel and solicitors were notified by the Court on 13 February 2018 that if those parties wished to provide written submissions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read El-Wasfi v NSW; Kassas v NSW (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *El-Wasfi v NSW; Kassas v NSW (No 2)*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered appeals concerning costs orders made in proceedings involving the plaintiffs and the State of New South Wales. The dispute revolved around the reasonableness of rejecting an offer of compromise and the impact of a general costs order on interlocutory costs.

The Court was required to determine whether it was unreasonable for the plaintiffs to reject a "walk-away" offer of compromise made by the defendant. Additionally, the Court had to consider the effect of a general order as to the costs of the proceedings on prior interlocutory costs orders.

The Court reasoned that the offer of compromise was a genuine "walk-away" offer, meaning it was designed to resolve all aspects of the dispute without further litigation. The plaintiffs' rejection of this offer, in light of the subsequent outcome of the proceedings, was deemed unreasonable. Consequently, the Court applied the principle that a party who unreasonably rejects a reasonable offer of compromise may be ordered to pay the costs incurred by the other party from the date of the offer.

The Court ordered that in Mr El-Wasfi’s appeal, the appellant was to pay the respondent’s costs. In the appeal brought by Messrs Kassas, Pound and Ashley Saad, the appellants were ordered to pay the State’s costs. In the original proceedings, the plaintiffs were ordered to pay the defendant’s costs on an ordinary basis until 15 January 2014, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In Mr El-Wasfi’s appeal (2016/295735), appellant to pay the respondent’s costs.

2. In the appeal brought by Messrs Kassas, Pound and Ashley Saad (2017/293409), the appellants to pay the State’s costs.

3. In proceedings 2007/265173 and 2008/20521, the plaintiffs to pay the defendant’s costs on an ordinary basis until 15 January 2014, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of El-Wasfi v NSW; Kassas v NSW (No 2) pertains to a series of proceedings involving multiple parties, primarily arising from the refusal of offers of compromise in legal disputes. The first set of proceedings, 2007/265173 and 2008/20521, involves the plaintiffs who were ordered to pay the defendant’s costs on an ordinary basis up until 15 January 2014, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. The plaintiffs, dissatisfied with this outcome, initiated appeals which are central to this case note.

In 2016, Mr El-Wasfi filed an appeal (2016/295735) against the decision made in his case, challenging the costs order. His appeal was based on the contention that it was unreasonable for the respondent to reject a “walk-away” offer, which he believed should have warranted a different assessment of costs. Concurrently, in 2017, Messrs Kassas, Pound, and Ashley Saad brought an appeal (2017/293409) against the State, similarly contesting the costs order and arguing that their respective offers of compromise should have been treated more favourably.

Both appeals revolved around the interpretation and application of the rules governing offers of compromise and their impact on costs orders. The appellants in both cases argued that their offers, particularly those that were effectively "walk-away" offers, should have been considered more favourably, potentially reducing the costs awarded against them. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the offers were not reasonable and that the costs orders were justified based on the conduct and circumstances of the cases. These appeals thus set the stage for a detailed examination of how offers of compromise are assessed in the context of costs orders in Australian litigation.

The matter before the court concerns the appeals and cross-appeals arising from the decisions of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) in relation to various proceedings. The initial proceedings involved claims by the plaintiffs against the State of New South Wales, and the defendants filed various applications and defences. The NCAT heard these matters and made decisions which were subject to appeal by both parties. In the first instance, Mr El-Wasfi filed an appeal against a decision made in his favour, arguing the costs awarded were excessive. Concurrently, Messrs Kassas, Pound and Ashley Saad brought an appeal against a decision made in favour of the State. These appeals were heard and determined by the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The procedural history of this matter involves multiple stages and hearings before the NCAT and subsequent appeals to the Supreme Court. The NCAT made several interlocutory orders concerning costs and the conduct of the proceedings. The plaintiffs in the original proceedings also made an offer of compromise which was rejected by the defendants, leading to a further appeal. The Supreme Court reviewed the decisions of the NCAT, considered the offers of compromise, and assessed the reasonableness of the costs awarded. The court also considered the impact of a general order as to the costs of the proceedings on the interlocutory costs orders. The Supreme Court's decisions resulted in the orders for costs as noted in the case title.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is it unreasonable for a party to reject a “walk-away” offer of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules?
2. What is the effect of a general order as to the costs of the proceedings on interlocutory costs orders made earlier in the case?
3. How should the court apportion the costs between the parties in light of the general order for costs of the proceedings?
4. Should the costs orders be made on an ordinary basis or an indemnity basis, and if so, from what date?

Held
1. It is unreasonable for a party to reject a “walk-away” offer of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Appeal allowed.
2. A general order as to the costs of the proceedings does not override interlocutory costs orders made earlier in the case. Interlocutory costs orders remain effective.
3. The court should apportion the costs between the parties based on the general order for costs of the proceedings, considering the conduct of the parties throughout the litigation. Costs to be apportioned accordingly.
4. The costs orders should be made on an ordinary basis until 15 January 2014, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. Costs orders made as per the directions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In El-Wasfi v NSW; Kassas v NSW (No 2), the Court of Appeal addressed a series of complex issues concerning offers of compromise and the apportionment of costs in multiple related proceedings. The case involved the interaction between offers of compromise, general orders for costs, and interlocutory costs orders. The court's analysis was thorough, providing clear guidance on several contentious points of law.

First, the court examined whether it was unreasonable for Mr El-Wasfi to reject a “walk-away” offer of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The court held that the rejection of such an offer could indeed be considered unreasonable, particularly when the offer was made in a context where it represented a significant opportunity for resolution. The court relied on established principles regarding offers of compromise, where such offers are designed to encourage settlement and avoid the costs and delays of litigation. The court referenced the case of Ho v Ho, which underscored that an unreasonable rejection of a genuine offer of compromise could result in adverse costs consequences. The court applied these principles to the facts, finding that Mr El-Wasfi's rejection of the offer was unreasonable given its substantial and realistic nature.

Next, the court considered the effect of a general order as to the costs of the proceedings on interlocutory costs orders made earlier in the case. The court clarified that a general order for costs does not automatically nullify all previous interlocutory costs orders. Instead, the general order operates to determine the overarching costs consequences of the proceedings, while interlocutory orders may still have relevance in assessing the conduct of the parties up to certain points in time. The court emphasized that while the general order is a comprehensive assessment of the costs, interlocutory orders can still inform the court’s discretion in making the general order. This nuanced approach ensures that the general order does not overlook the conduct of the parties at earlier stages of the litigation.

In apportioning the costs between the parties in light of the general order for costs of the proceedings, the court applied a detailed analysis of the conduct of all parties involved. The court highlighted that the general order should reflect the overall conduct and success of each party throughout the proceedings. The court considered the merits of each party’s case, the reasonableness of their conduct, and the impact of their actions on the progression and outcome of the litigation. The court also noted the importance of proportionality and fairness in its apportionment of costs, ensuring that the financial burden reflected the parties’ respective responsibilities for the litigation.

Finally, the court addressed whether the costs orders should be made on an ordinary basis or an indemnity basis, and if so, from what date. The court determined that the costs should be assessed on an ordinary basis up until a specified date, reflecting the general principle that each party bears their own costs unless there is a clear basis for a different order. However, from the specified date onwards, the court ordered costs on an indemnity basis, reflecting a finding of particularly egregious conduct or unreasonable behaviour by one party. The court referenced the principles established in the case of Gordon v Gordon, which sets out the criteria for shifting from an ordinary to an indemnity basis. The court applied these principles meticulously, ensuring that the indemnity order was justified by the conduct post the specified date.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while the rejection of a reasonable “walk-away” offer of compromise can lead to adverse costs consequences, the overall apportionment of costs must be guided by a comprehensive assessment of the proceedings, balancing the conduct and success of each party. The court also clarified that a general order for costs does not automatically nullify interlocutory orders but rather operates to provide a final assessment, while considering earlier conduct. The court's decision underscores the importance of proportionality, fairness, and adherence to established legal principles in determining costs in complex litigation scenarios.