El Mir v MICMSMA.

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

El Mir v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (No 2) [2021] FCCA 1093

File number(s): SYG 1349 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE DRIVER
Date of judgment: 21 June 2021
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Review of Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision – refusal of a medical treatment visa – Tribunal finding the applicant failed to meet a particular criterion – whether the applicant should have been assessed against alternative criteria considered – jurisdictional error established.   
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 65, 359

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Australian Retailers Association v Reserve Bank of Australia (2005) 148 FCR 446

El Mir v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2020] FCCA 1416

Kaur v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCCA 515

Number of paragraphs: 30
Date of hearing: 20 May 2021
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms U Okereke-Fisher
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr G Johnson
Solicitor for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

SYG 1349 of 2019
BETWEEN:

EL MIR HALMI EL MIR

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE DRIVER

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JUNE 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.A writ of certiorari shall issue removing the record of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision made on 11 February 2019 into this Court for the purpose of quashing it.

2.A writ of mandamus shall issue requiring the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to redetermine according to law the review before it.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE DRIVER:

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant, Mr El Mir, seeks judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) made on 11 February 2019.  The Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister (delegate) not to grant Mr El Mir a medical treatment visa. 

  2. I dealt with the background to this matter in an interlocutory judgment delivered on 19 June 2020.[1] 

    THE CURRENT PROCEEDINGS

  3. In my interlocutory judgment at [10]-[14] I dealt with the procedural history of the matter, various iterations of the grounds of review and the material before me. I found that the grounds of review advanced at that time were fairly arguable and made an order under rule 44.12(1)(b) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) requiring the Minister to show cause why relief should not be granted in respect of those grounds.

  4. The grounds of review are:

    Ground One

    The Tribunal failed to assess the Applicant’s application in accordance with law in that the Tribunal proceeded on the erroneous assumption that the Applicant was required to satisfy the requirement of cl 602.212(6) solely, in circumstances where it was open to the Tribunal to assess the Applicant under the other criteria under cl 602.212 including cl 602.212(2) and thereafter, cl 602.215.

    Particulars

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read El Mir v MICMSMA. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1093
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr El Mir against a decision of the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) which affirmed the refusal of his application for a medical treatment visa. The dispute centred on whether the MRT had made jurisdictional error in its assessment of Mr El Mir's eligibility for the visa.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the MRT had erred in its identification of the relevant criteria under clause 602.212 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), and whether the MRT had made findings unsupported by evidence or based on erroneous assumptions. Specifically, the court considered whether the MRT had failed to assess Mr El Mir against alternative applicable criteria within clause 602.212, and whether this failure undermined its subsequent finding regarding clause 602.215, which concerned the genuine temporary stay requirement.

Driver J found that the MRT had made a jurisdictional error by failing to properly consider the application of clause 602.212(2) before assessing clause 602.215. The court reasoned that an assessment under clause 602.212(2) was a necessary precursor to the consideration of clause 602.215, and that the Tribunal's omission in this regard meant it was not fully informed when making its decision. While the court also considered the ground relating to findings unsupported by evidence, it found that Mr El Mir himself had provided evidence of receiving medical treatment in Lebanon, thus negating the argument that there was no evidence for the Tribunal's findings on this point.

Ultimately, the court concluded that the error made by the MRT in its assessment of clause 602.212(2) went to jurisdiction, and therefore upheld Mr El Mir's appeal. The court found that Mr El Mir had established jurisdictional error and granted him the relief sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

If the Tribunal had considered the application of clause 602.212(2), it would have been better informed for the purposes of its consideration of clause 602.215. In my view, it is more than possible that if the Tribunal had undertaken the analysis required by clause 602.212(2) it might have come to a different conclusion under clause 602.215. I accordingly find that the error made by the Tribunal does go to jurisdiction and Ground 1 is hence made out.Ground 2 – did the Tribunal make findings unsupported by evidence or based on erroneous assumptions? I dealt with the issues in relation to this ground in my interlocutory judgment at [41]-[61]. For the purposes of the final hearing, counsel for Mr El Mir accepted that it was open to the Tribunal to consider whether his ongoing medical condition, the subject matter of the proposed visa, could be treated in Lebanon. To that extent, the consideration was not irrelevant. It is argued on behalf of Mr El Mir, however, that the availability of medical treatment in Lebanon was not on its own a reason to conclude an absence of a genuine intention. Mr El Mir contends that the Tribunal fell into error at [30] of its reasons.[6] [6] CB 77 Given that Ground 1 has been established, it is not strictly necessary to consider the second ground and I only do so in case I am wrong about the first ground. I prefer the Minister’s submissions in relation to the second ground. In relation to the second ground, as I stated at [56] of my earlier judgment, the point advanced by Mr El Mir essentially is that the Tribunal erred in considering clause 602.215 because there was no evidence before it to demonstrate the availability, cost and convenience of treatment in Lebanon for Mr El Mir’s claimed injuries. It is to be recalled, however, that it was Mr El Mir himself who gave evidence to the Tribunal that, rather than just being treated with painkillers, as he had in Australia following his motorbike accident that required hospitalisation and prior to his departing for Lebanon thereafter, in Lebanon Mr El Mir had received treatment in the nature of “medication, injections and x-rays”.[7] When questioned as to why he returned to Australia if he was being treated in Lebanon, Mr El Mir responded that it was to undergo cataract surgery. There was a delay in this surgery connected apparently to the delay in an insurance claim, because (Mr El Mir told the Tribunal) “the doctor is trying to claim the cataract surgery as part of the accident”.[8][7] CB 76 [22][8] [22] It has been said that the “no evidence” rule is not met in circumstances where there is at least some (or a “skerrick”) of evidence for the finding.[9] As Mr El Mir himself gave evidence to the Tribunal that he had received treatment for his conditions that resulted from the motorbike accident, his “no evidence” argument cannot succeed. It was unnecessary for the Tribunal to investigate the matter further, or to exercise its discretion under s 359 to get more information about the range and extent of medical treatment available to him in Lebanon.[9] Australian Retailers Association v Reserve Bank of Australia (2005) 148 FCR 446 at [575]; Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321 at 355-356

Decision

Reasons for decision

To that extent it was a matter for the Tribunal (and not for this Court) to determine whether on the evidence before it (and on a proper understanding of the law) Mr El Mir met the requirements of clause 602.215.CONCLUSION I conclude that Mr El Mir has established that the Tribunal decision is affected by jurisdictional error. He should receive the relief he seeks. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the purposes of the final hearing of this matter on 20 May 2021, I have before me the same material as was before me in the interlocutory proceeding. I also received a further affidavit by Mr El Mir filed on 18 May 2021 for the limited purpose of any potential question of futility and to bring up to date the medical history of Mr El Mir. CONSIDERATIONGround 1 – did the Tribunal err in identifying the relevant criterion in clause 602.212 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (Regulations)? I dealt with the arguments in relation to this ground at some length in my interlocutory judgment at [15]-[40]. For the purposes of the final hearing, counsel for Mr El Mir essentially put the following propositions:(a)clause 602.212(6) did not apply to Mr El Mir;(b)the Tribunal failed to assess Mr El Mir against other applicable alternative criteria in clause 602.212(2), (7) or (8);(c)the Tribunal’s failure to assess Mr El Mir under clause 602.212(2) undermined its later finding in relation to clause 602.215; and(d)the error goes to jurisdiction. The Minister relevantly argues as follows. Section 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) provides for the matters about which the Minister (or his delegate, but which also extends to the Tribunal on review) must be satisfied in order to grant a visa. One of the relevant matters is that “the other criteria for it prescribed by this Act or the regulations have been satisfied”.[2] Clause 602 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations sets out the criteria to be satisfied for the grant of the medical treatment visa. Clause 602.2 itself provides that (subject to an inapplicable exception) “All applicants must satisfy the primary criteria” and that “All criteria must be satisfied at the time a decision is made on the application”. [2] section 65(1)(a)(ii) The Tribunal in the present case concluded, by reference to one of a number of separate and independent criteria for the grant of the visa (relevantly appearing in clause 602 of the Regulations), that Mr El Mir did not meet the requirements of clause 602.215. Shortly stated, that criterion required the Tribunal to consider whether Mr El Mir genuinely intended to stay temporarily in Australia for the purpose for which the visa is granted. The Tribunal was not required to address each and every criteria in clause 602 in order to determine which of those criteria Mr El Mir met. The Tribunal was entitled to identify a criterion that it considered Mr El Mir might not meet, and to consider and address the relevant considerations under that criterion, and to make its decision accordingly. It was open to the Tribunal to find, for the reasons it gave, that Mr El Mir did not meet the requirements of clause 602.215. Mr El Mir’s sole basis of challenge to the Tribunal’s determination with respect to clause 602.215 is the argument advanced in the second ground (addressed below). The Minister submits, with respect to a concern that arose before the Court at the show cause hearing as to the reason why the Tribunal considered clause 602.212(6) to be the “relevant criteria”,[3] that is because clause 602.215 did not apply if, and only if, clause 602.212(6) was met. That is, the Tribunal was required by clause 602.215(2) to first consider whether Mr El Mir met clause 602.212(6), and if he did not (and there could be no argument in this case that he did not) then the Tribunal was required to consider whether Mr El Mir genuinely intended to stay in Australia temporarily for the purpose for which the visa was granted. Having found that clause 602.212(6) was not met, the Tribunal did not need to consider whether the other criteria in clause 602.212 were met. Thus it is said to be misleading to suggest that the Tribunal selected or focussed upon clause 602.212(6) as the “relevant criteria”. It considered that criterion in order to determine whether it needed to consider clause 602.215. [3] see the interlocutory judgment at [37]