El Cheikh and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

El Cheikh and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 4544 (7 November 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6368

Re:Kamel El Cheikh

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr Rob Reitano, Member

Date:7 November 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision of the delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs dated 25 October 2018 is set aside. The matter is remitted to the Respondent with a direction that the Applicant meets the criteria in s 21(3)(d)(iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) as he had a permanent or enduring mental capacity at the time he made his application for Australian citizenship that meant that he was not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time.

..........................[SGD]..............................................

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – conferral of Australian citizenship – permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity – not capable of understanding the nature of the application – not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship – major depressive disorder – panic disorder – fibromyalgia – persistent disability – decision set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) s 21

CASES

Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Rob Reitano, Member

7 November 2019

  1. Mr Kamel El Cheikh suffers from major depressive illness, persistent depressive disorder, panic disorder and fibromyalgia. He says the incapacity caused by those illnesses meant that on 24 October 2017, when he made his application for Australian citizenship, he was not capable of understanding the nature of that application and was not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship. He seeks a review of the delegate’s decision dated 25 October 2018 that found to the contrary.

  2. I have decided to set aside the decision under review on the basis that Mr El Cheikh qualifies under s 21(3)(d)(iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Citizenship Act) to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test and what follows are my reasons for doing so.

    BACKGROUND

  3. Mr El Cheikh was born in Lebanon. He is 38 years of age. He is a citizen of Lebanon. He first arrived in Australia in February 2005. He lives with his wife (even though they are separated) and his three young children.

  4. He applied for Australian citizenship on 24 October 2017. In doing so he sought to be exempted from the requirement to sit the Australian Citizenship Test because he said he had a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity. He said at the time he lodged his citizenship application that he was not capable of understanding the nature of his application or was not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship because of that incapacity.

  5. Mr El Cheikh suffers from major depressive illness, persistent depressive disorder, panic…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read El Cheikh and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4544
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by Mr El Cheikh, a Lebanese national who arrived in Australia in 2005. Mr El Cheikh sought an exemption from the Australian Citizenship Test, asserting a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity that rendered him unable to understand the nature of his application or demonstrate adequate knowledge of Australia and its citizenship requirements. He suffers from major depressive disorder, persistent depressive disorder, panic disorder, and fibromyalgia, conditions diagnosed around August 2014. The Minister for Home Affairs contended that Mr El Cheikh's incapacity did not causally link to his ability to understand the application or demonstrate the requisite knowledge.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr El Cheikh possessed a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity that prevented him from understanding the nature of his citizenship application or from demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and the responsibilities and privileges of citizenship, as stipulated by section 21(3)(d) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007*. The Tribunal also considered whether there was a causal connection between his diagnosed conditions and these specific incapacities.

The Tribunal found that the medical evidence, including reports from a Clinical Psychologist and a Consultant Rheumatologist, supported Mr El Cheikh's claims. The psychologist noted that his depressive symptoms had worsened, significantly decreasing his cognitive functioning and ability to perform mentally straining tasks, and described his condition as enduring and unlikely to change. The rheumatologist confirmed severe fibromyalgia and depression, leading to significant cognitive and memory impairment that would make learning information difficult and the citizenship test challenging. Based on this evidence, the Tribunal concluded that Mr El Cheikh's mental incapacity meant he was not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and the responsibilities and privileges of citizenship at the time he made his application.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and remitted the matter to the Minister with a direction that Mr El Cheikh qualified for an exemption from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test under section 21(3)(d)(iii) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007*.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have decided to set aside the decision under review on the basis that Mr El Cheikh qualifies under s 21(3)(d)(iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Citizenship Act) to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test and what follows are my reasons for doing so.BACKGROUND Mr El Cheikh was born in Lebanon. He is 38 years of age. He is a citizen of Lebanon. He first arrived in Australia in February 2005. He lives with his wife (even though they are separated) and his three young children. He applied for Australian citizenship on 24 October 2017. In doing so he sought to be exempted from the requirement to sit the Australian Citizenship Test because he said he had a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity. He said at the time he lodged his citizenship application that he was not capable of understanding the nature of his application or was not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship because of that incapacity. Mr El Cheikh suffers from major depressive illness, persistent depressive disorder, panic disorder and fibromyalgia. He was diagnosed with those conditions in about August 2014. Mr El Cheikh wants to be an Australian citizen because his wife and children are Australian citizens and he wants to share that with them. He says many of his friends were ‘Aussies’ and ‘he wanted to be like them’ even though he felt like he was one of them already. He says he loves Australia, that he lives here, and he regards Australia as home. Another reason he wants to be an Australian citizen is so that he does not have to apply to remain a resident every five years. Mr El Cheikh has attempted the Australian Citizenship Test many times on a free application he had on his phone and has failed it many times. He claimed he had ‘not even got close to fifty per cent’. He said he had never formally sat the Australian Citizenship Test. He says he knows if he sits the Australian Citizenship Test he will fail it. Mr El Cheikh was honest and frank when giving his evidence. I have no hesitation in accepting his evidence as truthful.LEGISLATION Sub-section 21(3) of the Citizenship Act provides the eligibility criteria a person must meet to become an Australian citizen if they have a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity. It provides:3 A person is eligible to become an Australian citizen if the Minister is satisfied that the person: (a)is aged 18 or over at the time the person made the application; and (b)is a permanent resident: (i) at the time the person made the application; and (ii) at the time of the Minister's decision on the application; and (c)satisfies the general residence requirement (see section 22) or the special residence requirement (see section 22A or 22B), or satisfies the defence service requirement (see section 23), at the time the person made the application; and (d)has a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity, at the time the person made the application, that means the person: (i) is not capable of understanding the nature of the application at that time; or (ii) is not capable of demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language at that time; or (iii) is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time; and (e)is likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia if the application were to be approved; and (f)is of good character at the time of the Minister's decision on the application. ISSUES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Minister contends that Mr El Cheikh’s mental incapacity does not mean that he is not capable of understanding the nature of the application at the time he made his application and nor does it mean that Mr El Cheikh is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time. The Ministers contention is that there is no causal connection between any permanent or enduring mental incapacity and the relevant states of awareness and knowledge to which ss 21(3)(d)(i) and (iii) direct attention[2].[2] Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499 at [2].MEDICAL EVIDENCE The medical evidence was directed to these issues. It is necessary to refer to some of the more salient aspects of it. Ms Wajma Ebrahimi, Clinical Psychologist, said in a report dated 16 July 2018: In his recent assessment Mr El Cheikh reported that his symptoms of depression have worsened over the past few years which include low mood, loss of appetite, poor memory, lack of concentration, lack of energy and motivation, difficulty sleeping and sleep disturbances, feelings of hopelessness and loneliness, excessive worrying, and feelings of worthlessness. Based on these reported symptoms Mr El Cheikh meet (sic) criteria for Major Depressive Disorder, Recurrent (severe; DSM-5)I am writing in regards (sic) to Mr El Cheikh’s application for the Disability Support Pension. In particular, Mr El Cheikh’s psychological condition is an enduring mental health issue within the chronic and severe range. Given this longevity of the condition and poor treatment prognosis this is unlikely to change in the near future.Mr El Cheikh reported that his depressive illness has significantly decreased his cognitive functioning and his ability to effectively perform mentally straining tasks. It has also been noted that Mr El Cheikh has had these mental issues over the past few years which has significantly impacted his overall functioning.[3] (emphasis added)[3] Exhibit 2, Report of Ms Wajma Ebrahami dated 16 July 2018. Doctor Andrew Jordan, Consultant Rheumatologist, said in a report dated 21 November 2018:I have diagnosed and been treating Kamel for fibromyalgia and chronic pain. This condition results in significant cognitive and memory impairment. This will make it difficult to retain and learn information and make it likely he will find the Citizenship test very difficult.…Kamel has seen me since December 2017. He has severe fibromyalgia and depression. He has been treated with Endep, Palexia, Cymbalta, Lyrica, Gabapentin, NSAIDS and paracetamol. He either develops side effects or the medications are not effective. His current medications are Lexapro, Inderal and Panadeine Forte. He has not adequate control of his symptoms on any medication and I do not think adjusting medications will make a difference. I believe his condition is permanent, fully assessed and fully treated. He has had a wide range of investigations in the past and these have all essentially been normal, as is expected for fibromyalgia. He has multi system problems but the pain and depression limit his function the most. I do not think he has the capacity to work eight hours per week for at least the next two years.[4] (emphasis added)[4] Exhibit 10, Report of Dr Andrew Jordan 21 November 2018.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr El Cheikh’s mental incapacity means that he is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time he made his application.CONCLUSION The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Respondent with a Direction that Mr El Cheikh qualifies under s 21(3)(d)(iii) of the Citizenship Act to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established