El-Azar v R and Shalala v R

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL

ELIA GHASSAN EL-AZAR

S APCR 2010 0310

Applicant

v

THE QUEEN

Respondent

S APCR 2010 0316
ALAN SHALALA Applicant

v

THE QUEEN

Respondent

---

JUDGES MAXWELL P, BUCHANAN and WEINBERG JJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 18 January 2011
DATE OF JUDGMENT 11 February 2011
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2011] VSCA 18
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM R v El-Azar and R v Shalala (Unreported, County Court of Victoria, Judge Duggan, 23 August 2010)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – False imprisonment – Verdict not unsafe or unsatisfactory – Trial judge adequately conveyed the defence case to the jury – DNA evidence – Jury entitled to act on DNA evidence notwithstanding possibility of contamination – Jury required to consider all the evidence.

CRIMINAL LAW – Sentence – Failing to fix a non-parole period not an error.

---

Appearances:

Counsel

Solicitors

For the Applicant El-Azar Mr J E McLoughlin Victoria Legal Aid
For the Applicant Shalala Mr G J Traczyk Platinum Lawyers, Sydney
For the Respondent Mr P N Rose SC Mr Craig Hyland, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions

MAXWELL P:

  1. I have had the advantage of reading in draft the reasons of Buchanan JA.  I too would refuse each application for leave to appeal, for the reasons which his Honour gives.

BUCHANAN JA:

  1. After a trial in the County Court, the applicants were found guilty on a count of false imprisonment and were acquitted on counts of kidnapping and making a threat to kill.  Each applicant was sentenced to be imprisoned for a term of 15 months.

  1. The applicants had previously been found guilty of a number of offences arising from the same events after a trial in the County Court.  Those convictions were quashed on appeal.

  1. The applicants seek leave to appeal against their convictions and El‑Azar seeks leave to appeal against his sentence. 

  1. The principal Crown witness was one David Golombek.  He said that in January 2003 he visited a flat in South Yarra where Richard Rizki lived.  The applicants, but not Rizki, were present at the flat.  The applicants quizzed Golombek at length as to his knowledge of Rizki’s whereabouts.  Shalala informed Golombek that Rizki owed him money.  Upon leaving the flat, Golombek was questioned further about the whereabouts of Rizki by the applicants.  He said that the applicants were becoming increasingly anxious. 

  1. Golombek drove from Rizki’s flat to his house in Toorak, followed by the applicants.  As he parked his car, Golombek was again approached by the applicants, who continued to attempt to enlist his assistance in locating Rizki.  He was offered a reward.  He exchanged telephone numbers with Shalala. 

  1. The following morning, one of the applicants telephoned Golombek and

arranged to meet him in Prahran.  Golombek accompanied the applicants as they drove around Prahran in an attempt to locate Rizki.  After some 20 minutes, Golombek told the applicants that he was unable to help them further.  Golombek said that one Geoffrey Cook might be able to help the applicants locate Rizki.  The applicants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read El-Azar v R and Shalala v R and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] VSCA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants in this case, El-Azar and Shalala, were convicted of various offences including false imprisonment. Both appellants sought to appeal their convictions and sentences on various grounds, including the trial judge's handling of the defence case, the reliability of DNA evidence, and the imposition of a non-parole period. The High Court of Australia was required to consider these appeals. The primary legal issues centred on the adequacy of the trial judge's direction to the jury concerning the defence case, the reliability of DNA evidence in light of potential contamination, and the failure to set a non-parole period for the sentences.

The Court found that the trial judge had adequately conveyed the defence case to the jury, ensuring that they understood the arguments and could consider them in reaching their verdict. The Court held that the jury was entitled to act on the DNA evidence presented, despite the possibility of contamination, as this was a matter for the jury to consider in the context of all the evidence. Regarding the sentence, the Court determined that the failure to fix a non-parole period was not an error, as the overall sentence imposed was appropriate and did not result in an unjust outcome.

The appeals were dismissed, and the convictions and sentences upheld. The Court's decision confirmed the importance of ensuring that juries are properly directed on the defence case and that they can consider all evidence, including DNA evidence, in reaching their verdicts. The failure to set a non-parole period was deemed not to constitute an error in this instance, as the sentences were otherwise appropriate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established