EIY20 v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EIY20 v State of Western Australia [2022] FCA 1410

File number: WAD 220 of 2020
Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 25 November 2022
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application to strike out pleadings pursuant to r 16.21(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) - matter related to EIX20 v State of Western Australia [2022] FCA 1357 - applicable principles - applicant detained in Banksia Hill Detention Centre - allegations against the respondent include direct and indirect discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), negligence, unlawful assault and battery and unlawful imprisonment - whether claims are properly articulated - requirement that material facts be stated - particular paragraphs struck out - leave granted to re-plead
Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PH

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) s 22

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 16.21

Young Offenders Act 1994 (WA)

Cases cited: EIX20 v State of Western Australia [2022] FCA 1357
Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 40
Date of hearing: 16 March 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr GM Watson SC with Ms D Tang and Dr KL Fallah
Solicitor for the Applicant: The National Justice Project Ltd
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms C Thatcher SC
Solicitor for the Respondent: State Solicitor's Office

ORDERS

WAD 220 of 2020
BETWEEN:

EIY20

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BANKS-SMITH J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 NOVEMBER 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant has leave to file and serve the further amended statement of claim (FASC), and the FASC is taken to have been filed on 8 March 2022.

2.The respondent has leave to file and serve its amended interlocutory application seeking to strike out paragraphs of the FASC, and the interlocutory application is taken to have been filed on 29 March 2022.

3.The respondent's application for the striking out of paragraphs 4, 6, 13, 14(a), 14(b), 14(c), 15(b), 15(c), 15(d), 15(e), 16, 21, 23(a), 24(a), 33, 34, 52 insofar as it refers to 'food', 53, 58, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66 and 67 of the FASC is allowed and those paragraphs are struck out.

4.The applicant has leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim.

5.The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on a date to be fixed.

6.The question of the costs of the application be reserved to the case management hearing.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BANKS-SMITH J:

Introduction

  1. This proceeding relates to the treatment of a young man whilst he was detained at Banksia Hill Detention Centre for some 1,215 days during various times between 2014 and June 2018.

  2. I recently published reasons in a related matter, EIX20 v State of Western Australia [2022] FCA 1357. The applicant in this case has similarly brought…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EIY20 v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1410
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of EIY20 v State of Western Australia, the applicant, who was detained in Banksia Hill Detention Centre, brought forth allegations against the respondent, the State of Western Australia, including direct and indirect discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), negligence, unlawful assault and battery, and unlawful imprisonment. The applicant filed a further amended statement of claim (FASC), to which the respondent filed an interlocutory application seeking to strike out certain paragraphs. The court was required to determine whether the FASC was properly articulated and if the material facts were adequately stated.

The court found that certain paragraphs in the FASC were ambiguous and confusing, particularly paragraphs 4 and 6. Paragraph 4, which introduced the terms "disadvantages, disabilities and propensities," was deemed too broad and undefined, leading to ambiguity when these terms were used elsewhere in the pleading. Paragraph 6, which purported to define "learning disabilities," was found to be circular and unhelpful, as it did not provide any material facts to clarify the term. Consequently, the court ordered that these paragraphs be struck out and allowed the applicant to re-plead, with the aim of providing clarity and specificity in the allegations.

The court also struck out other paragraphs that were similarly vague or redundant, ensuring that the allegations were properly articulated and that the respondent had a clear understanding of the case it needed to address. The court granted the applicant leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim, with the condition that it must properly appraise the State of the case that has to be met. The proceeding was listed for a case management hearing to discuss the timing of the filing and other procedural directions to progress the case to trial. The question of costs was reserved for the case management hearing.

The court's final orders included allowing the applicant to file and serve the FASC and the respondent's interlocutory application, striking out specified paragraphs of the FASC, granting the applicant leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim, listing the proceeding for a case management hearing, and reserving the question of costs for the case management hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant has leave to file and serve the further amended statement of claim (FASC), and the FASC is taken to have been filed on 8 March 2022.

2. The respondent has leave to file and serve its amended interlocutory application seeking to strike out paragraphs of the FASC, and the interlocutory application is taken to have been filed on 29 March 2022.

3. The respondent's application for the striking out of paragraphs 4, 6, 13, 14(a), 14(b), 14(c), 15(b), 15(c), 15(d), 15(e), 16, 21, 23(a), 24(a), 33, 34, 52 insofar as it refers to 'food', 53, 58, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66 and 67 of the FASC is allowed and those paragraphs are struck out.

4. The applicant has leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim.

5. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on a date to be fixed.

6. The question of the costs of the application be reserved to the case management hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the following sections I address paragraphs of the FASC that are similar to those impugned in EIX20. I cross-refer to and adopt the identified paragraphs from the reasons from EIX20 with respect to the corresponding paragraphs in EIY20, without setting them out again.Factual background - impugned paragraphs Paragraphs 4-12 plead under the heading 'Factual Background' the following matters that reveal a number of issues relevant to the strike out application more broadly:The Applicant's disabilities and the disadvantages in his childhood4.The Applicant had disadvantages in his childhood and had disabilities which manifested themselves in several ways (the Applicant's disadvantages, disabilities and propensities).5.The Applicant was raised in a complicated and dysfunctional family.6.From an early age the Applicant manifested a resistance to learning and learning disabilities (learning disabilities).7.From an early age the Applicant misused drugs and alcohol.8.From an early age, and during the period he was detained by the Respondent, the Applicant manifested impulsivity, a tendency to react quickly to provocation including an assertion of control by authority figures.9.From an early age and during the period he was detained by the Respondent, the Applicant manifested a resentment of and resistance to authority and towards persons in the position of authority.10.From an early age and during the period he was detained by the Respondent, the Applicant manifested the propensity to become violent in resistance to authority and persons in authority.11.During the period he was detained by the Respondent, the Applicant developed psychological vulnerabilities:a.From 2016 the Applicant manifested a propensity toward self-harm;b.From 2016 the Applicant manifested symptoms of anxiety;c.From 2017 the Applicant was diagnosed to suffer from Major Depressive Disorder;12.Each of the psychological vulnerabilities would have presented before formal diagnosis. Of these paragraphs, the State seeks orders striking out paras 4 and 6.Paragraphs 4 and 6 The issues raised are the same as those addressed in EIX20 at [41]‑[45]. That is, the phrase 'disadvantages, disabilities and propensities' is not defined or limited, and introduces confusion and ambiguity when those words, or some of them, are used elsewhere in the pleading (for example where they are imported into paras 13 and 15(b) as conditions about which the respondent allegedly had knowledge). The paragraph should be struck out under r 16.21(1)(c) and (d) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), with liberty to re-plead. Although para 6 purports to provide a definition of 'learning disabilities', the definition is circular and does not assist in circumstances where no material facts are pleaded to provide content for those terms. It has the same issues addressed in EIX20 at [45] as to whether or not the learning disabilities are pleaded as a distinct disability or a manifestation of other recognised disabilities. It would only take relatively minor revisions to clarify the position. As it currently stands the pleading is ambiguous and should be struck out under r 16.21(1)(c).Paragraphs 13, 14(a)-(c), 15(b)-(e)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Paragraphs 66 and 67 are in corresponding terms to the pleading of unlawful imprisonment in EIX20 and are addressed by the reasons in EIX20 at [120]‑[128]. They should be struck out under r 16.21(1)(d).Conclusion As in EIX20, this is a proceeding of significance to both parties. It should not proceed to trial with uncertainty on the part of either party as to what is alleged. There will be orders relevantly striking out paras 4, 6, 13, 14(a), 14(b), 14(c), 15(b), 15(c), 15(d), 15(e), 16, 21, 23(a), 24(a), 33, 34, 52 insofar as it refers to 'food', 53, 58, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66 and 67 of the FASC. In light of the determinations I have made, it has not been necessary to consider whether those paragraphs should be struck out other than under r 16.21(1)(c) and r 16.21(1)(d). The applicant has leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim. Any such amended pleading must properly appraise the State of the case that has to be met. I will hear the parties as to the timing of such filing. I will also hear the parties as to other procedural directions to progress the proceeding to trial, having regard to contemporary case management techniques. A further case management hearing will be convened as soon as convenient, and concurrently with the case management hearing proposed in EIX20. I will hear the parties as to the costs of this application at the same case management hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.