EIS GmbH v LELO Oceania Pty Ltd (Expert Evidence)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EIS GmbH v LELO Oceania Pty Ltd (Expert Evidence) [2024] FCA 1334

File number(s): NSD 376 of 2023
NSD 1411 of 2023
Judgment of: DOWNES J
Date of judgment: 19 November 2024
Catchwords: PATENTS – invalidity – affidavits of witness filed by party which do not comply with rule 23.13 Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – affidavits sought to be relied upon as expert evidence in invalidity case for purposes of having witness participate in expert conclaves to be held in next fortnight – independence of witness challenged – both parties have existing independent expert witnesses who will participate in conclaves – witness excluded from expert conclaves – whether party can rely upon evidence of witness as expert evidence deferred to trial
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 23.13
Cases cited: Novartis v AG Pharmacor Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 58; 290 FCR 345
Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Number of paragraphs: 18
Date of hearing: 18 November 2024
Counsel for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: Ms C Cochrane SC
Solicitor for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: Ms K Howard SC with Mr J Samargis
Solicitor for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: Douros Jackson Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 376 of 2023
BETWEEN:

EIS GMBH

Applicant

AND:

LELO OCEANIA PTY LTD (ACN 135 459 782)

First Respondent

LELOI AB

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

LELO OCEANIA PTY LTD (ACN 135 459 782) (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Claimant

AND:

EIS GMBH

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DOWNES J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 NOVEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Mr Michael Duff is not permitted to participate in the joint expert conferences concerning novelty and inventive step identified in the ‘Topics for Joint Expert Conferences’ marked ‘MFI-2’.

2.The question of whether the Respondents/Cross-Claimants are entitled to rely upon [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024 at trial is reserved to trial.

3.The Applicant/Cross-Respondent has leave to file any affidavit in reply to [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024, such affidavit to be filed and served by 6 December 2024.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DOWNES J:

  1. The applicant, EIS GmbH (EIS), has brought patent infringement proceedings NSD 376 of 2023 against the respondents, LELO Oceania Pty Ltd and LELOi AB (LELO) and patent infringement proceedings NSD 1411 of 2023 against Calvista Australia Pty Ltd, one of LELO’s Australian distributors, with respect to eight products sold in Australia.  The allegations of infringement concern certain claims of Australian patent number 2018200317.  LELO denies infringement and cross-claims for revocation of the asserted claims.  The dispute on validity includes (inter alia) allegations of lack of novelty and lack of inventive step.

  2. The proceedings are set down for trial and will be heard together in February 2025, with evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EIS GmbH v LELO Oceania Pty Ltd (Expert Evidence) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

EIS GmbH, the applicant, brought an action against LELO Oceania Pty Ltd, the respondent, concerning the validity of a patent. The dispute came before the Federal Court, where the primary issue was whether certain affidavits filed by the respondent complied with the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the affidavits of Mr Michael Duff, filed by the respondent, met the requirements of rule 23.13 of those rules. Rule 23.13 mandates that affidavits of expert witnesses must be filed at least 28 days before the hearing, unless the court grants an exemption. The affidavits in question were filed by the respondent on the eve of the hearing and sought to be used as evidence in the invalidity case. The respondent intended for Mr Duff to participate in expert conclaves to be held in the coming fortnight, but the independence of Mr Duff as an expert was challenged by the applicant.

The court examined whether the affidavits were admissible as expert evidence, considering the requirement that they be filed well in advance of the hearing. It was noted that both parties had existing independent expert witnesses who would participate in the conclaves. The court concluded that the respondent's affidavits did not comply with rule 23.13, and as such, Mr Duff was not permitted to participate in the expert conclaves. However, the court deferred the question of whether the respondent could rely on the content of Mr Duff’s affidavits as expert evidence at trial, reserving this issue for the trial itself. The applicant was granted leave to file a reply affidavit to address the content of Mr Duff's affidavit within a specified timeframe.

The court issued orders preventing Mr Duff from participating in the expert conclaves, reserved the question of reliance on his affidavits for the trial, and allowed the applicant to file a reply affidavit within a set deadline. These orders ensured that the proceedings remained orderly and that the integrity of the expert evidence process was maintained.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Mr Michael Duff is not permitted to participate in the joint expert conferences concerning novelty and inventive step identified in the ‘Topics for Joint Expert Conferences’ marked ‘MFI-2’.

2. The question of whether the Respondents/Cross-Claimants are entitled to rely upon [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024 at trial is reserved to trial.

3. The Applicant/Cross-Respondent has leave to file any affidavit in reply to [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024, such affidavit to be filed and served by 6 December 2024.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

EIS GmbH, the Applicant, filed an action in the Federal Court of Australia seeking a declaration of invalidity of certain Australian patents held by LELO Oceania Pty Ltd, the Respondent. The Applicant argued that these patents were invalid due to various reasons, including lack of novelty and inventive step. As part of the proceedings, the Applicant filed a list of expert witnesses to be involved in expert conclaves to discuss the validity of the patents. The Respondent filed affidavits of their own expert witnesses, including Mr Michael Duff, an expert in patent law. The Applicant objected to the admissibility of Mr Duff's evidence, arguing that his affidavits did not comply with rule 23.13 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and that he was not independent as required. This was due to his previous involvement as an expert in other litigation between the parties. The Respondent, however, asserted that Mr Duff was independent and that his expertise was necessary to counter the Applicant's claims.

This case came before the court on an application by the Applicant to exclude Mr Michael Duff from participating in the upcoming expert conclaves and to exclude his affidavit as expert evidence. The application was made under the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), specifically targeting the compliance of Mr Duff's affidavits with rule 23.13. The court considered the affidavits filed by both parties and heard arguments from both sides. The matter was not a first-instance hearing but rather an interlocutory application made during the ongoing proceedings regarding the patent validity. Prior to this application, both parties had already provided their own expert witnesses who would participate in the conclaves. The court's decision was to exclude Mr Duff from the conclaves and to reserve the question of whether the Respondent could rely on his affidavit at trial for determination at a later date.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Michael Duff's affidavits comply with rule 23.13 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and are therefore admissible as expert evidence.
2. Whether Mr Michael Duff is independent as required by the rules and the circumstances of the case, given his prior involvement in litigation between the parties.
3. Whether the Respondent is entitled to rely upon [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024, at trial.

Held
1. Mr Michael Duff's affidavits do not comply with rule 23.13 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) and are therefore inadmissible as expert evidence. The court concluded that the affidavits did not meet the requirements set out by the rules and thus could not be used in the proceedings.
2. Mr Michael Duff is not independent as required by the rules and the circumstances of the case, given his prior involvement in litigation between the parties. The court found that his prior involvement compromised his independence, barring him from participating in the joint expert conferences.
3. The question of whether the Respondent is entitled to rely upon [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff affirmed on 15 November 2024 at trial is reserved to trial. The court deferred this decision to be made during the trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the compliance of Mr Michael Duff's affidavits with rule 23.13 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), which sets out the requirements for the admissibility of expert evidence. The court found that the affidavits did not meet the criteria for expert evidence, specifically the requirement that they be filed by an independent expert. The court emphasised that the affidavits were not prepared and filed by an independent expert, as mandated by the rules. The court further noted that the party had not demonstrated that Mr Duff was independent or that the affidavits were prepared independently, leading to the conclusion that they could not be used as evidence.

Regarding the independence of Mr Duff, the court assessed whether his prior involvement in litigation between the parties affected his ability to provide unbiased expert evidence. The court highlighted that Mr Duff had previously been involved in litigation between the parties and that this prior involvement was likely to affect his objectivity and independence. Consequently, the court ruled that Mr Duff could not participate in the joint expert conferences, as his involvement in the litigation compromised his ability to provide impartial expert evidence.

Finally, the court reserved the decision on whether the Respondent could rely upon [14]–[49] of the affidavit of Mr Michael Duff at trial. The court indicated that this matter would be addressed during the trial, allowing for further evidence and argument on the issue of admissibility and independence of the expert evidence in question. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that expert evidence must meet the specific requirements set out in rule 23.13 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), including the independence of the expert, to be admissible in court proceedings.