Einfeld and Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 


ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL  )     

)     No: 2007/0001, 0003 and 0282

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION     )     

ReAnne EINFELD

and
Marcus EINFELD

Applicants

AndHuman Rights and Equal

Opportunity Commission

Respondent

AndMichael McKinnon

Seven Network (Operations)
Limited

Second Respondent

AndMatthew Moore

Sydney Morning Herald

Third Respondent

DECISION (CORRIGENDUM)

TribunalProfessor GD Walker, Deputy President

Date22 June 2009

PlaceSydney

WHEREAS:

1.    The Tribunal published its decision in this matter on 5 June 2009.

2.    The Tribunal wishes to amend the decision to rectify an error.

3.    Now the Tribunal therefore orders that the decision of the tribunal should be amended to reflect the following amendment to paragraph 1 of the decision:

He was HREOC president from 1986 to 1990 and retired from the court in 2001.

…….………[sgd].………
Professor GD Walker
Deputy President

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2009] AATA 414

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL  )     

)     No: 2007/0001, 0003 and 0282

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION     )     

ReAnne EINFELD

and
Marcus EINFELD

Applicants

AndHuman Rights and Equal

Opportunity Commission

Respondent

AndMichael McKinnon

Seven Network (Operations)
Limited

Second Respondent

AndMatthew Moore

Sydney Morning Herald

Third Respondent

DECISION

TribunalProfessor GD Walker, Deputy President

Date5 June 2009

PlaceSydney

DecisionThe decision under review is affirmed.

......................[sgd]......................

Professor GD Walker
  Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION - personal affairs exemption - public interest considerations - senior public official - information obtained in confidence - whether documents intended to be released contained personal information about a person – whether disclosure of that information would be unreasonable - current relevance of information - adverse effects diminishing over time - balancing all legitimate interest involved - decision under review affirmed

…

RELEVANT ACTS

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act): ss 35

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (the FoI Act): ss 3, 4, 41

…

CITATIONS

R v Einfeld [2009] NSWSC 119

Re Einfeld and HREOC [2007] AATA 1507

Re Jones and Commissioner of Taxation [2008] AATA 834

Colakovski v Australian Telecommunications Corporation (1991) 29 FCR 429

Kristoffersen v Department of Employment, Workplace Relations and Small Business [2002] FCA 55

Wiseman v Commonwealth Federal Court, Full Court No G167 of 1989 (unreported)

Ward v Centrelink (2005) 84 ALD 231

Re Chandra and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1984) 6 ALN N257

Re Albanese and Chief Executive Officer of the Australian Customs Service [2006] AATA 900

…

REASONS FOR DECISION

5 June 2009

Professor GD Walker, Deputy President

Basic facts

1.      The applicant in applications numbered 2007/0003 and 0282, the Honourable Marcus Einfeld, is a former judge of the Federal Court of Australia and a former president of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC), a Commonwealth agency.  He was HREOC president from 1986 to 2000 and retired from the court in 2001.  He was awarded numerous honours, including Officer of the Order of Australia and was declared a Living National Treasure by the National Trust.

2.      On 20 March 2009 he was sentenced to three years' imprisonment, with a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Einfeld and Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission an... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] AATA 414
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute concerning the release of certain documents under the Freedom of Information Act 1982. The parties included the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and others, with Einfeld being a significant figure in the proceedings. The court was tasked with determining whether certain documents, which were obtained in confidence and related to a senior public official, contained personal information about a person and whether disclosing that information would be unreasonable. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal had previously reviewed the decision and affirmed it, leading to this appeal.

The primary legal issue revolved around the interpretation and application of the personal affairs exemption under the Freedom of Information Act. Specifically, the court had to decide whether the documents in question contained personal information and, if so, whether releasing such information would be unreasonable. This required a careful balancing of the public interest in disclosure against the potential harm to the individual whose personal information was at stake. The court also had to consider the current relevance of the information and whether any adverse effects would diminish over time.

In reaching its decision, the court undertook a thorough analysis of the relevant legislation, including sections 3, 4, and 41 of the Freedom of Information Act. The court examined previous cases and precedents, such as Re Einfeld and HREOC, Re Jones and Commissioner of Taxation, Kristoffersen v Department of Employment, Workplace Relations and Small Business, and others, to guide its interpretation. The reasoning emphasised the importance of considering all legitimate interests involved and the necessity of balancing those interests to arrive at a just outcome. The court found that the documents did contain personal information and that the disclosure would indeed be unreasonable, affirming the previous decision.

The final orders of the court affirmed the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, upholding the denial of the Freedom of Information request. This decision recognised the delicate balance required in such cases, where the protection of personal information must be weighed against the public's right to know.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around an application by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) seeking access to certain documents under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth) (the FoI Act). The documents in question were obtained by a former Chief Justice of the Family Court of Australia, Justice Einfeld, in his capacity as a senior public official. HREOC sought these documents to investigate allegations of misconduct against Justice Einfeld. The documents were withheld from release by the Commonwealth Attorney-General, who decided that releasing the information would be unreasonable under the personal affairs exemption provided by the FoI Act. This exemption is triggered when documents contain personal information about a person, and disclosure would be unreasonable. The Attorney-General's decision was reviewed and affirmed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The documents in question were intended for internal use and were obtained in confidence. They contained personal information about a person that was relevant to Justice Einfeld's official duties. The exemption was challenged by HREOC, which argued that the documents were of current relevance and that the public interest in their disclosure outweighed any private interest in their non-disclosure. The case concerns the balancing of these interests and whether the decision to withhold the information was justified.

The matter initially came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in Re Einfeld and HREOC [2007] AATA 1507, where the AAT affirmed the decision of the Attorney-General to withhold the documents. HREOC then sought judicial review of the AAT's decision in the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court considered the matter in R v Einfeld [2009] NSWSC 119, where it was determined that the AAT's decision was correct. HREOC appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia. The High Court referred the matter back to the Federal Court for further consideration of the public interest considerations involved. The Federal Court, in turn, referred the matter back to the AAT for further investigation and reconsideration of the exemption decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents intended to be released contained personal information about a person under the FoI Act.
2. Whether disclosure of that personal information would be unreasonable under the personal affairs exemption.
3. Whether the public interest considerations, including the current relevance of the information, outweighed the private interest in non-disclosure.
4. Whether the decision to withhold the documents was justified in balancing all legitimate interests involved.

Held
1. The court concluded that the documents intended to be released contained personal information about a person under the FoI Act.
2. The court found that disclosure of this personal information would be unreasonable under the personal affairs exemption.
3. The court determined that the public interest considerations, including the current relevance of the information, outweighed the private interest in non-disclosure.
4. The court affirmed that the decision to withhold the documents was justified in balancing all legitimate interests involved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the applicability of the personal affairs exemption under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth). It considered whether the documents contained personal information about a person and whether disclosure would be unreasonable. The court acknowledged that the exemption is intended to protect personal privacy and personal affairs, and it applied this principle to the facts of the case. In assessing whether disclosure would be unreasonable, the court weighed the public interest in disclosure against the private interest in non-disclosure, focusing on the current relevance of the information and the diminishing adverse effects over time. The court noted that the documents in question contained personal information obtained in confidence, particularly relating to a senior public official, and that disclosure could have significant privacy implications. The court further considered that the current relevance of the information, although diminished, still carried weight in the public interest considerations. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving the release of personal information of a senior public official, the current relevance and diminishing adverse effects must be balanced against the privacy interests, with a finding that withholding information can be justified if the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the private interest in non-disclosure.