EEH v NSW Self Insurance Corporation (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: EEH v NSW Self Insurance Corporation (No 2) [2022] NSWCATAD 28
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 25 January 2022
Decision date: 25 January 2022
Jurisdiction:Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division
Before: A Christie, Senior Member
Decision:

(1) Subject to Order 2 below, within 7 days of the date of these Reasons for Decision the Respondent must provide the Applicant with a copy of Document 1.

(2) The Respondent may redact the first sentence of paragraph 2 and all of paragraphs 3 to 8 (inclusive) of Document 1 before providing a copy of Document 1 to the Applicant in compliance with Order 1 above.

(3) Order 1 of the 6 April 2021 Orders of the Tribunal is deleted and replaced with the following:

Within 21 days of the later of the date of these Reasons for Decision and the receipt of Document 1 by the Applicant, the Applicant (EEH) is to give to the Tribunal and NSW Self Insurance Corporation the following material: evidence including statements, documents and a summary of legal arguments about the alleged conduct and about any financial, psychological or physical harm suffered because of the conduct.

(4) Other than as amended by Order 3 above, the 6 April 2021 Orders of the Tribunal are unchanged and continue to apply.

(5) Pursuant to ss 64(1)(a) and (c) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 publication or broadcast of the name of the Applicant and publication of Document 1 as filed with the Tribunal (other than by the Respondent) are prohibited.

Catchwords:

PROCEDURE – client legal privilege – whether privilege applies to instructions to attend a settlement when the fact of attendance has been disclosed in an internal review decision and the submissions of the respondent

Legislation Cited:

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013

Evidence Act 1995

Cases Cited:

Carey v Korda [2012] WASC 228

CNC v NSW Police Force [2017] NSWCATAD 43

EEH v NSW Self Insurance Corporation [2021] NSWCATAD 21

Grant v Downs ([1976] HCA 63; 1976) 135 CLR 674

Pratten v Pratten [2005] QCA 213

Priest v State of New South Wales [2006] NSWSC 1281

QQ v Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Force (No. 2) NSWADT 79

Re Global Medical Imaging Management Limited (in liq) [2001] NSWSC 476

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: EEH (Applicant)
NSW Self-Insurance Corporation (Respondent)
Representation: Solicitors:
Self-represented (Applicant)
Crown Solicitor (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2020/00215886
Publication restriction:

1. Pursuant to s 64(1)(a) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 publication or broadcast of the name of the Applicant is prohibited.

2. Pursuant to s 64(1)(c) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 the publication of Document 1 as filed with the Tribunal in confidence by the Respondent (i.e. before any redactions are made), other than by the Respondent, is prohibited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Pursuant to the Orders of the Tribunal dated 27 August 2020, on 17 September 2020 the Applicant requested that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EEH v NSW Self Insurance Corporation (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWCATAD 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of EEH v NSW Self Insurance Corporation (No 2) involved the issue of client legal privilege, specifically whether the privilege applied to instructions given to attend a settlement when the fact of attendance had been disclosed in an internal review decision and the submissions of the respondent. The dispute was heard by the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales. The primary legal issue was whether the internal review decision and the respondent's submissions had waived the privilege in relation to the instructions given to attend the settlement. This issue hinged on whether the disclosure of the fact of attendance in the internal review decision and the respondent's submissions amounted to a waiver of the privilege.

The Tribunal, in considering the matter, examined the principle that client legal privilege is waived if there has been a disclosure with the consent of the client. In this case, the Tribunal found that the internal review decision and the respondent's submissions did not amount to a waiver of the privilege because the disclosure was not made with the consent of the client, EEH. The Tribunal held that the internal review decision was a public document and that the respondent's submissions were made in the context of opposing the application for privilege. The Tribunal concluded that the internal review decision and the respondent's submissions did not constitute a waiver of the privilege because they did not amount to a disclosure with the consent of the client.

Consequently, the Tribunal ruled that the privilege applied to the instructions given to attend the settlement, and the respondent was ordered to provide a copy of the relevant document to the applicant, with certain redactions. The Tribunal also modified the earlier orders to require the applicant to provide specific material to the Tribunal and the respondent within a specified timeframe. Additionally, the Tribunal prohibited the publication or broadcast of the applicant's name and the document as filed with the Tribunal, except by the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Subject to Order 2 below, within 7 days of the date of these Reasons for Decision the Respondent must provide the Applicant with a copy of Document 1.

(2) The Respondent may redact the first sentence of paragraph 2 and all of paragraphs 3 to 8 (inclusive) of Document 1 before providing a copy of Document 1 to the Applicant in compliance with Order 1 above.

(3) Order 1 of the 6 April 2021 Orders of the Tribunal is deleted and replaced with the following:

Within 21 days of the later of the date of these Reasons for Decision and the receipt of Document 1 by the Applicant, the Applicant (EEH) is to give to the Tribunal and NSW Self Insurance Corporation the following material: evidence including statements, documents and a summary of legal arguments about the alleged conduct and about any financial, psychological or physical harm suffered because of the conduct.

(4) Other than as amended by Order 3 above, the 6 April 2021 Orders of the Tribunal are unchanged and continue to apply.

(5) Pursuant to ss 64(1)(a) and (c) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 publication or broadcast of the name of the Applicant and publication of Document 1 as filed with the Tribunal (other than by the Respondent) are prohibited.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Exclusion of evidence of settlement negotiations(1) Evidence is not to be adduced of—(a) a communication that is made between persons in dispute, or between one or more persons in dispute and a third party, in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of the dispute, or(b) a document (whether delivered or not) that has been prepared in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of a dispute.(2) Subsection (1) does not apply if—(a) the persons in dispute consent to the evidence being adduced in the proceeding concerned or, if any of those persons has tendered the communication or document in evidence in another Australian or overseas proceeding, all the other persons so consent, or(b) the substance of the evidence has been disclosed with the express or implied consent of all the persons in dispute, or(c) the substance of the evidence has been partly disclosed with the express or implied consent of the persons in dispute, and full disclosure of the evidence is reasonably necessary to enable a proper understanding of the other evidence that has already been adduced, or(d) the communication or document included a statement to the effect that it was not to be treated as confidential, or(e) the evidence tends to contradict or to qualify evidence that has already been admitted about the course of an attempt to settle the dispute, or(f) the proceeding in which it is sought to adduce the evidence is a proceeding to enforce an agreement between the persons in dispute to settle the dispute, or a proceeding in which the making of such an agreement is in issue, or(g) evidence that has been adduced in the proceeding, or an inference from evidence that has been adduced in the proceeding, is likely to mislead the court unless evidence of the communication or document is adduced to contradict or to qualify that evidence, or(h) the communication or document is relevant to determining liability for costs, or(i) making the communication, or preparing the document, affects a right of a person, or(j) the communication was made, or the document was prepared, in furtherance of the commission of a fraud or an offence or the commission of an act that renders a person liable to a civil penalty, or(k) one of the persons in dispute, or an employee or agent of such a person, knew or ought reasonably to have known that the communication was made, or the document was prepared, in furtherance of a deliberate abuse of a power.…(5) In this section—(a) a reference to a dispute is a reference to a dispute of a kind in respect of which relief may be given in an Australian or overseas proceeding, and(b) a reference to an attempt to negotiate the settlement of a dispute does not include a reference to an attempt to negotiate the settlement of a criminal proceeding or an anticipated criminal proceeding, and(c) a reference to a communication made by a person in dispute includes a reference to a communication made by an employee or agent of such a person, and(d) a reference to the consent of a person in dispute includes a reference to the consent of an employee or agent of such a person, being an employee or agent who is authorised so to consent, and(e) a reference to commission of an act includes a reference to a failure to act.(6) In this section—power means a power conferred by or under an Australian law. In Priest v State of New South Wales [2006] NSWSC 1281 Johnson J, most relevantly for these proceedings, summed up the process to determine if privilege applies as follows: