QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CITATION:
Edwards v Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd (no. 2) [2022] QCATA 44
PARTIES:
In APL244-18:
DONALD BRUCE EDWARDS (applicant/appellant)
v
SOVEREIGN HOMES (QLD) PTY LTD (respondent)
In APL356-18:
DONALD BRUCE EDWARDS (applicant/appellant)
v
SOVEREIGN HOMES (QLD) PTY LTD (respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S:
APL244-18; APL356-18
ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:
BDL253-15
MATTER TYPE:
Appeals
DELIVERED ON:
8 April 2022
HEARING DATE:
On the papers
HEARD AT:
Brisbane
DECISION OF:
Senior Member Brown
Member BurkeORDERS:
In APL244-18:
1. Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd relating to the application to adduce fresh evidence filed 14 December 2018 and the application to adduce fresh evidence filed 12 July 2019 to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the indemnity basis on the District Court scale as if the applications had been brought in that Court;
2. Otherwise, Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd of the proceeding to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the standard basis on the District Court scale as if the proceeding had been brought in that Court.
In APL356-18:
3. Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd of the proceeding to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the standard basis on the District Court scale as if the proceeding had been brought in that Court.
CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE – COSTS – DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE – COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS – consideration of costs in appeal proceedings concerning building disputes – where the appellant sought an award of costs on an indemnity basis – consideration of whether there is any special or unusual features in the conduct of the appeal proceedings to justify indemnity costs – where the appellant’s applications to adduce fresh evidence in the appeal were misconceived, irresponsible and bound to fail – where the respondent was thereby put to considerable expense in responding to the appeal, an award of indemnity costs is appropriate – where the appellant’s applications for leave to appeal or appeal could not be characterised as being conducted in such an oppressive manner that there was an abuse of process, an award of indemnity costs is not justified and costs should be awarded on the standard basis.
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 77(3)(h)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 146
Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales (2006) 226 CLR 256
Colgate-Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225Di Carlo v Dubois [2002] QCA 225
Edwards v Sovereign Homes (QLD) Pty Ltd [2020] QCATA 146
Edwards v Sovereign Homes Qld Pty Ltd [2022] QCA 4
John Holland Pty Ltd v Adani Abbott Point Terminal Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] QSC 48
Todrell Pty Ltd v…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Edwards v Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd (no. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] QCATA 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether the appellant's conduct during the appeal proceedings warranted costs on an indemnity basis, and if there were any special or unusual features in the proceedings that justified such an award. The court also considered whether the appellant's applications to adduce fresh evidence were misconceived and irresponsible, and whether they had caused the respondent to incur considerable expense. Additionally, the court examined whether the appellant's applications for leave to appeal or appeal could be characterised as an abuse of process, which might justify an indemnity costs award.
The court found that while there were no special or unusual features in the proceedings to warrant indemnity costs, the appellant's applications to adduce fresh evidence were indeed misconceived, irresponsible, and bound to fail. This misconceived conduct caused the respondent to incur considerable expense in responding to the appeal. Therefore, the court held that an award of indemnity costs was appropriate for the applications to adduce fresh evidence. However, the court concluded that the appellant's applications for leave to appeal or appeal could not be characterised as oppressive or abusive, and thus, an indemnity costs award for these applications was not justified. The court ordered that costs be awarded on the standard basis for the substantive appeal proceedings and costs appeal proceedings.
In conclusion, the orders made by the court were that Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd relating to the applications to adduce fresh evidence on the indemnity basis, and the costs of the substantive appeal proceedings and costs appeal proceedings on the standard basis. The costs were to be assessed on the District Court scale as if the proceedings had been brought in that court.
Orders
Orders of the court
In APL244-18:
1. Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd relating to the application to adduce fresh evidence filed 14 December 2018 and the application to adduce fresh evidence filed 12 July 2019 to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the indemnity basis on the District Court scale as if the applications had been brought in that Court;
2. Otherwise, Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd of the proceeding to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the standard basis on the District Court scale as if the proceeding had been brought in that Court.
In APL356-18:
3. Donald Bruce Edwards pay the costs of Sovereign Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd of the proceeding to be agreed or failing agreement to be assessed on the standard basis on the District Court scale as if the proceeding had been brought in that Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Sovereign has filed submissions (not exceeding five pages) and says, among other things:(a)Mr Edwards should pay Sovereign’s costs of the unsuccessful applications to adduce fresh evidence on the indemnity basis;(b)Mr Edwards should pay Sovereign’s of the substantive appeal proceedings and the costs appeal proceedings on the indemnity basis;(c)The appropriate scale of costs is the District Court scale;(d)The applications to adduce fresh evidence were bound to fail, relating as they did to a ground of appeal asserting an error of law by the Tribunal at first instance.Consideration Costs may be awarded in proceedings for building disputes.[3] This includes Appeal Tribunal proceedings. The QCAT Appeal Tribunal has recently observed:The discretion to award costs in building dispute proceedings must be exercised judicially, not upon irrelevant or extraneous considerations but upon facts connected with or leading up to the litigation. The exercise of a discretion ‘judicially’ means for reasons that can be considered and justified.Costs do not follow the event in building dispute proceedings. However, success in a proceeding and the degree of success, particularly one involving complex litigation, are relevant considerations in the exercise of the discretion to award costs. A party’s success may be a significant factor in an application for an order for costs.The extent to which success in a proceeding may be eroded if a party is required to bear their own costs was considered by the Queensland Court of Appeal in Tamawood Ltd & Anor v Paans: If orders for costs were not to be made in favour of successful parties in complex cases, then just claims might not be prosecuted by persons who are unable to manage complex litigation by themselves. Such a state of affairs would truly be contrary to the interests of justice; and an intention to sanction such a state of affairs cannot be attributed to the legislature which established the Tribunal. (footnotes omitted)[4][3]Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 77(3)(h).[4]Steven Bryan Worthington t/as Worthington Simmons Builders v Dr Andrew William Ryan; Dr Andrew William Ryan v Steven Bryan Worthington t/as Worthington Simmons Builders [2022] QCATA 8, at [19] to [21]. In my view it is in the interests of justice that Mr Edwards pay Sovereign’s costs of the substantive appeal proceedings and costs appeal proceedings. Sovereign was entirely successful in both appeals. In the substantive appeal Mr Edwards’s advanced eighteen grounds of appeal some of which contained numerous sub-grounds. The litigation was complex and Sovereign was put to considerable expense in responding to the appeal. It would unduly erode the success of Sovereign if no order for costs was made in its favour. Similarly, in the costs appeal proceedings, it is appropriate that Mr Edwards pay Sovereign’s costs. As was noted in the reasons for decision relating to the substantive appeal, while Mr Edwards relied upon two grounds of appeal in the application for leave to appeal or appeal, his appeal submissions traversed matters well beyond the identified grounds.