| I | CATCHWORES |
| I | hanlstrative Law - iudiclal review - applicatlon for review of | |||||
| I | declslon of stipendlarp maaistrate in committal proceedinus - charae | |||||
| ||||||
| ||||||
| ||||||
| ||||||
| appreciate the relevance or importance of advices of solicltors and counsel on the question of mens rea - duty of the maqlstrace In commlttal groceedlnus. | ||||||
| ||||||
| Crimes Act 1914. S. 86rl)(b), (c) Sales Tax Assessment Act No. 3 1930, S. 9 Judicia-r-r Act 1903, S . 68 | ||||||
| I | ||||||
| ||||||
| I | ||||||
| ||||||
| ! | ||||||
| No. VG 191 of l934 | ||||||
| ||||||
| 12 OCTOBER 1984 | ||||||
| l |
| l |
| LN-THE | F'EDEXAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) |
| ) | No. VG 191 of 1984 |
| VICTORSAN REGISTRY | ) ) |
| GENERU. DIVISION | ) |
| BEmEEN: | JOHN FR3NCIS EDFIllRDS |
Appellant
| AND : | IAN VON EINEM and ROBERT RICHARD McDONALD |
Respondents
ORDER
| JUDGES EWXING O R D E 2 : | SWEENEY. | DAVIES & LOCKHART JJ . |
| D A E OF ORDER: | 12 XTOBER 1984 |
| biUE?E MFDE: | MELBOURNE |
| THE COURT ORDERS THAT: |
| ! | 1. | The sppeal | be dismissed. |
| 2. | John Francis Edwards Day the costs | of Ian Von Einem S.M. and |
Robert Richard McDonald of thls appeal.
!
I
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT | OF AUSTRALIA |
\
| VICTORIA | DISTRICT | REGISTRY | 1 | No. VG 191 of 1984 |
GZNERAL DIVISION
| On appeal from a slngle ]udge of the r'ederal Court | of |
| Australia |
| JOHN | BETWEEN: | FRULUCIS EDWARDS | Appellant |
IAN VON EIX'EM and
| ROBERT RICHARD McDONPLD | Respondenrs |
Coram: Sweeney, Davles and Lockhart JJ.
Date : 12 October, 1984
| ?lace: | Melbourne |
Reasons fo r Judgment
Sweeney, J.
| John Francis Edwards (the appellant) made appllcatlon to | a |
| slngle | ~ u d g e of | chls | court | for | review | pursuant | to | the |
| i | Administratlve Declslons Judlclal Revlew Act | 1977 | (the Judlclal |
Review Act) of the decisions of Xr. I. Von Einem (the maglstrate)
2
made on 29 Aprll 1983 In the course of committal proceedlngs:
| that ihere was at the close | of | tine | Crown case |
| sufficient evldence | to place the appellant upon h13 |
crlal In respecr of each of the tiiree charges of
consplracy against him:
that r'nere was a case to answer by the appellant in
respect of each of those charges;
not to discharge hlm out of custody as to tine
informatlon under enqulry but to caution hlm under
| s.56(1)(5) | of | the Maglsrrates Summary Proceedlngs |
| Act 1975, Victorla (:he | Act) and then to call upon |
nlm to plead to those charges.
| Two co-defendanrs of the appellant, | Ian Grant and Ian Davld |
Stafford Collle, made slmllar revlaw applicatlons to hls ilonour.
| All three appllcatlons were dlsmlssed. Thls | 1s… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Edwards, John Francis v Von Einem S.M., Ian and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1984] FCA 334
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.