Edwards, John Francis v Von Einem S.M., Ian

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

I

CATCHWORES

I

hanlstrative Law - iudiclal review - applicatlon for review of

I

declslon of stipendlarp maaistrate in committal proceedinus - charae

of conspiracy to Promote a scheme to defraud the Commonwealth

of sales

tax -

whether there

was sufficient evldence

CO place the aopeilant

upon hls trlal -

whether mauistrate falled to observe the dlstinction

between avoidance and evasion of

tax - whether mauistrate falled to

appreciate the relevance or importance of advices of solicltors and counsel on the question of mens rea - duty of the maqlstrace In commlttal groceedlnus.

Admmlstratlve Decislons (Judrclal Review)

Act 1977

Crimes Act 1914. S. 86rl)(b), (c)

Sales Tax Assessment Act No. 3 1930, S. 9

Judicia-r-r Act 1903, S . 68

I

Maulstratps (Summar-? Proceedlnus)

Act

1375

(Vic), S .

5rj ( l ) (a ) ,

( b )

I

J a N FF-LNCIS

FDWARDS v. L X I VON EINEM m d R0EQ.T

RICHFAD McDONALD

!

No. VG 191 of l934

S W J E Y . DAVIES and LOCXHART

ZJ

12 OCTOBER 1984

l

l

LN-THE

F'EDEXAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )

)

No. VG 191 of 1984

VICTORSAN REGISTRY

) )

GENERU. DIVISION

)

BEmEEN:

JOHN FR3NCIS EDFIllRDS

Appellant

AND :

IAN VON EINEM and

ROBERT RICHARD McDONALD

Respondents

ORDER

JUDGES EWXING O R D E 2 :

SWEENEY.

DAVIES & LOCKHART JJ .

D A E OF ORDER:

12 XTOBER 1984

biUE?E MFDE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

!

1.

The sppeal

be dismissed.

2.

John Francis Edwards Day the costs

of Ian Von Einem S.M. and

Robert Richard McDonald of thls appeal.

!

I

IN THE FEDERAL COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

\

VICTORIA

DISTRICT

REGISTRY

1

No. VG 191 of 1984

GZNERAL DIVISION

On appeal from a slngle ]udge of the r'ederal Court

of

Australia

JOHN

BETWEEN:

FRULUCIS EDWARDS

Appellant

IAN VON EIX'EM and

ROBERT RICHARD McDONPLD

Respondenrs

Coram: Sweeney, Davles and Lockhart JJ.

Date : 12 October, 1984

?lace:

Melbourne

Reasons fo r Judgment

Sweeney, J.

John Francis Edwards (the appellant) made appllcatlon to

a

slngle

~ u d g e of

chls

court

for

review

pursuant

to

the

i

Administratlve Declslons Judlclal Revlew Act

1977

(the Judlclal

Review Act) of the decisions of Xr. I. Von Einem (the maglstrate)

2

made on 29 Aprll 1983 In the course of committal proceedlngs:

that ihere was at the close

of

tine

Crown case

sufficient evldence

to place the appellant upon h13

crlal In respecr of each of the tiiree charges of

consplracy against him:

that r'nere was a case to answer by the appellant in

respect of each of those charges;

not to discharge hlm out of custody as to tine

informatlon under enqulry but to caution hlm under

s.56(1)(5)

of

the Maglsrrates Summary Proceedlngs

Act 1975, Victorla (:he

Act) and then to call upon

nlm to plead to those charges.

Two co-defendanrs of the appellant,

Ian Grant and Ian Davld

Stafford Collle, made slmllar revlaw applicatlons to hls ilonour.

All three appllcatlons were dlsmlssed. Thls

1s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edwards, John Francis v Von Einem S.M., Ian and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1984] FCA 334
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia, sitting in the Victoria District Registry, considered an appeal by John Francis Edwards against a decision of a Stipendiary Magistrate in committal proceedings. Edwards was charged with conspiracy to defraud the Commonwealth, and conspiracy to prevent the execution or enforcement of sales tax laws. The appeal sought review of the Magistrate's decision to commit Edwards for trial, based on alleged errors of law in the Magistrate's reasons. The Court, comprising Sweeney, Davies, and Lockhart JJ, dismissed the appeal, finding no errors of law in the Magistrate's reasoning. The Court held that the Magistrate had correctly applied the legal standards and correctly identified the elements of the alleged offences. The appeal did not establish that the Magistrate failed to appreciate the distinction between avoidance and evasion of tax, or that he misapplied the relevance of legal opinions in assessing mens rea. The Court concluded that the Magistrate's decision was based on a sufficient volume of evidence and that the appeal did not present exceptional circumstances warranting intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.