Edwards and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Edwards and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2017] AATA 1068 (21 June 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2016/1428

2016/1454

2016/1455

Re:Peter Edwards

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy OAM QC, Deputy President

Date:21 June 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal finds that the decisions under review of 14 March 2016 should be varied pursuant to s 43(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) as follows:

(a)The applicant’s Grade 2 Flight Instructor Rating is suspended for a period of 6 months and until he has completed an instructor proficiency check (matter 2016/1455);

(b)The applicant’s private Pilot Licence – Aeroplane Category is suspended for a period of 6 months and until he has successfully completed a course In in Human Factors and Safety Systems (matter 2016/1428); and

(c)The applicant’s Commercial Pilot Licence – Aeroplane Category is suspended for a period of 6 months, contingent upon the applicant successfully completing courses in Human Factors and Safety Systems and to vary Edwards’ CPL and PPL by the imposition of a condition (matter 2016/1454). Such condition is as follows:

The holder is not to undertake any sales demonstration flights or advertising on behalf of Cirrus Aircraft Corporation or any other commercial entity other than under an Air Operator’s Certificate and the holder is to notify CASA prior to commencement of any such activities.

.............................[sgd]...........................................

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy OAM QC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION - suspension of licence - private pilot licence - commercial pilot licence - suspension of grade 2 flight instructor rating - whether failure by applicant in duty regarding safe operation of aircraft - whether applicant is a fit and proper person to hold a private and commercial pilot licence - conduct concerning crash of aircraft - whether applicant’s pilot log book contained anomalies - whether applicant conducted unauthorised commercial operations - decisions varied

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 27, 28

CASES

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 94 ALR 11

Law Society of New South Wales v Foreman (No 2) (1994) 34 NSWLR 408
Law Society of New South Wales v Walsh [1997] NSWCA 185

Quadrio and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2011] AATA 709 (12 October 2011)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Civil Aviation Advisory Publication, January 2007

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth), regs 233, 269
Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) as in force on 1 May 2014, reg 206

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) as in force on 21 May 2013, regs 5.51, 5.52, 282

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Dennis Cowdroy OAM QC, Deputy President

21 June 2017

  1. By Application for Review, the applicant (“Edwards”) seeks review of three decisions (“the decisions”) made by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (“the respondent”) on 14 March 2016 made pursuant to sub-reg 269(3) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (“CAR”). By such decision the respondent determined to:

    (i)suspend Edwards’ Grade 2 Flight Instructor Rating (“FIR”) for a minimum period of 12 months and until he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edwards and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1068
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered an appeal by Mr. Edwards concerning the Civil Aviation Safety Authority's (CASA) decision to suspend his private pilot licence, commercial pilot licence, and Grade 2 flight instructor rating. The dispute arose from Mr. Edwards' conduct during a flight that resulted in a crash, and CASA's subsequent determination that he was not a fit and proper person to hold these licences due to alleged anomalies in his pilot logbook and unauthorised commercial operations.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr. Edwards' actions constituted a failure in his duty regarding the safe operation of an aircraft, and consequently, whether he remained a fit and proper person to hold his pilot licences and instructor rating. This involved assessing the evidence surrounding the critical manoeuvre that led to the aircraft's catastrophic attitude and considering the credibility of Mr. Edwards' explanations for the events, particularly his assertion that another occupant had interfered with the controls.

The Tribunal found that Mr. Edwards was in control of the aircraft during the critical manoeuvre, which involved a specific flap selection, a left turn, power reduction, and a subsequent nose-up and right-dip manoeuvre. It dismissed Mr. Edwards' theory that another occupant caused the aircraft's attitude, noting this was not raised at earlier stages and was contradicted by expert evidence regarding the aircraft's controls. The Tribunal concluded that a suspension of Mr. Edwards' licences was warranted to underscore the importance of regulatory compliance and the responsibility that accompanies holding a pilot licence.

Ultimately, the Tribunal varied CASA's decision by reducing the suspension period for all licences to six months. The suspension of his Grade 2 Flight Instructor Rating was for six months. His private and commercial pilot licences were suspended for six months, with additional conditions imposed. These conditions included the successful completion of courses in Human Factors and Safety Systems for his private and commercial licences, and a prohibition on undertaking sales demonstration flights or advertising for commercial entities unless under an Air Operator's Certificate, with prior notification to CASA.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is no dispute that, at that critical juncture, Edwards was in control of the aircraft and that his selection of 50% flap, the roll of the aircraft into a left turn at about 25° angle of bank while reducing the power to idle and the raising of the nose of the aircraft was performed by him. In these circumstances it is unnecessary for the Tribunal to deal with many of the factual disputes which preceded this vital manoeuvre which caused the aircraft to be placed in a catastrophic attitude.EVIDENCE OF FLIGHT The Tribunal has had the benefit of both oral testimony and by the display of two digital reproductions of the flight. Such reproductions have been compiled from the Garmin G1000 on-board data recorder. The data retrieved has been used to create animations of the entire flight. For the respondent, the Garmin data was used in flight simulation software known as ‘Xplane 10’, whereas the applicant incorporated such data with Google Earth. Each of the reproductions graphically illustrates the events of the flight commencing with the initial movement to the run up bay at Bankstown airport. Those reproductions confirm, for the most part, the matters recalled by both the pilot and the passengers concerning, in particular, the movement of the aircraft at the critical juncture. They demonstrate, for example, the initial turn to the left, the levelling of the aircraft thereafter, another turn to the left then the rising of the nose of the aircraft and its sudden dip to the right as of right wing lowered and the aircraft then commenced its spiral towards the ground. Edwards testified before the Tribunal that he was certain that Lorincz, who was sitting in the left front seat of the aircraft, must have applied the right or the rudder of the aircraft at the critical juncture and that this was the cause of the nose rising and of the sudden and unexpected manoeuvre of the aircraft. Such proposition was denied by Lorincz, and had not been advanced by Edwards at the Show Cause Conference. Nor was such proposition advanced when Edwards provided his statement to the police following the accident. Accordingly the Tribunal concludes that such a theory should be dismissed. Edwards’ claimed that Lorincz could not have flown the aircraft at take-off stage because the take-off run was straight along the centreline and because the Cirrus uses a side stick rather than a yoke. In answer to the suggestion that Lorincz actually undertook the take-off manoeuvre, Edwards stated that such a manoeuvre “cannot be done by somebody who has never touched a Cirrus before”. David George Adkins, currently engaged as a Safety Systems Inspector who has been involved with safety in aviation for almost 20 years, is familiar with the Cirrus SR22 aircraft, and has had 17 hours experience in command of this type of aircraft provided evidence that side sticks are linked on both sides and that the runway alignment should be controlled by the rudder during the take-off roll. Such rudder is controlled by pedals on the floor, not the side stick.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Taking these factors into consideration, and the references provided which were not before the original decision maker, the Tribunal agrees that a suspension is warranted of all licences to bring home to Edwards the importance of the need for scrupulous observance of the regulations, but that the suspension should be reduced by period of 12 months to 6 months. Otherwise the conditions imposed should remain. The maintenance of the safety of the aviation industry is paramount. The licence holder’s duty attaching to the privilege of holding a licence carries with it concomitant obligation to ensure compliance with the requisite standards and that the licence holder is prepared to take responsibility for his or her actions. DECISION The Tribunal finds that the decisions under review of 14 March 2016 should be varied pursuant to s 43(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) as follows: (d)The applicant’s Grade 2 Flight Instructor Rating is suspended for a period of 6 months and until he has completed an instructor proficiency check (matter 2016/1455); (e)The applicant’s private Pilot Licence – Aeroplane Category is suspended for a period of 6 months and until he has successfully completed a course In in Human Factors and Safety Systems (matter 2016/1428); and (f)The applicant’s Commercial Pilot Licence – Aeroplane Category is suspended for a period of 6 months, contingent upon the applicant successfully completing courses in Human Factors and Safety Systems and to vary Edwards’ CPL and PPL by the imposition of a condition (matter 2016/1454). Such condition is as follows:The holder is not to undertake any sales demonstration flights or advertising on behalf of Cirrus Aircraft Corporation or any other commercial entity other than under an Air Operator’s Certificate and the holder is to notify CASA prior to commencement of any such activities.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.