| SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | |
| COMMERCIAL & EQUITY DIVISION | Not Restricted |
No. 2073 of 1998
| Edingbay Pty Ltd & Ors | Plaintiffs |
| v | |
| Horwath (Vic) Pty Ltd | Defendant |
| v | |
| Benni Aroni & Ors | Third Parties |
---
JUDGE: | Hansen J | |
WHERE HELD: | Melbourne | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 3-7, 10-13, 17-21, 24-28, 31 May; 1-3, 7-10, 15-17, 21-25, 28-30 June; 1, 2, 5-8, 12-15, 19-22 July; 10-13, 16-18, 26 August 1999; 8 May; 5 & 13 June 2000. | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 8 September 2000 | |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | Edingbay Pty Ltd & Ors v Horwath (Vic) Pty Ltd; Benni Aroni & Ors (third parties). | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2000] VSC 351 | |
---
| Contract – Accountant and client – Implied term of reasonable care – Duty to exercise reasonable care and skill in tort – Tax effective investment – Extent of accountant's implied duty – Terms of retainer – Whether breach. Negligence – Accountant and client – Duty to exercise reasonable care and skill – Advice – Tax effective investment – Effect of terms of retainer on scope of duty in tort – Whether breach. Trade Practices – Misleading or deceptive conduct – Tax effective investment – Alleged representation that scheme existed and would produce benefits – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s. 52; Fair Trading Act 1985 (Vic), s. 11. |
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
For the Defendant | Mr. P.R. Hayes QC with Mr. I.D. Martindale & Mr. A.J. Paterson | Deacons Graham & James |
| For the Fifteenth Third Party | Mr. P.N. Vickery QC (until 11 June 1999) with Mr. N. Murdoch | Peter Black & Associates |
HIS HONOUR:
1. Introduction
This judgment is given on the issue of liability on a third party claim. The claim arises in a proceeding brought by 48 plaintiffs, one of whom was Hilip Pty Ltd, against Horwath (Vic) Pty Ltd, to recover the amount of their individual losses suffered in the circumstances outlined below. Horwath joined a number of third parties from whom it claimed relief in respect of the plaintiffs' claims. One of the third parties was Krampel Newman & Partners Pty Ltd. Horwath's claim against Krampel Newman was made pursuant to Part IV of the Wrongs Act 1958 for contribution or an indemnity in respect of any amount which Horwath was adjudged liable to pay to Hilip.
2. Background
Hilip was owned and controlled by Brian Andrew Hamersfeld. Its principal purpose was to make investments. Hamersfeld also owned and controlled Moose Enterprises Pty Ltd which was a trading company. Horwath conducted a chartered accounting practice. Krampel Newman conducted an accountancy practice. Norman Ralph Same is a principal of Krampel Newman. He was Hamersfeld's accountant and acted as such for him and his companies. It was only in the course of the events relevant to this judgment that Hamersfeld commenced to retain Horwath for certain accounting purposes.
The principal witnesses who gave evidence were Hamersfeld on behalf of Hilip, Stephen Andrew Bethune and Amanda Bloom on behalf of Horwath, and Same on behalf of Krampel Newman. Bethune and Bloom were…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Edingbay Pty Ltd v Horwath (Vic) Pty Ltd; Benni Aroni (third... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] VSC 351
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the accountants owed a duty of care to Edingbay in tort and, if so, what the scope of that duty was. The court also had to determine whether the accountants breached any implied term of their retainer by failing to exercise reasonable care and skill. Additionally, the court had to examine whether there was misleading or deceptive conduct by the accountants in relation to the tax effective investment scheme.
The court held that the accountants owed a duty of care to their client in tort, which was not limited by the terms of their retainer. The court found that the accountants breached this duty by failing to exercise reasonable care and skill in advising Edingbay. The court also concluded that the accountants engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by promoting the tax effective investment scheme without adequately assessing its viability or benefits. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that professionals must exercise a reasonable degree of care and skill, and that such a duty extends beyond the terms of any retainer agreement.
The court ordered that Horwath (Vic) Pty Ltd pay damages to Edingbay for the breach of duty and for misleading or deceptive conduct. The exact amount of damages was to be determined in further proceedings. Benni Aroni was also ordered to pay damages for his involvement in the misleading or deceptive conduct. The decision highlighted the importance of professional diligence and the broader obligations that accountants owe to their clients beyond contractual terms.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi