Edie Creek Pty Ltd v Symes

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read
43 CLR 53

EDIE CREEK PROPRIETARY LIMITED SYMES

RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE CENTRAL COURT OF THE

TERRITORY OF NEW GUINEA. Appeal-Territory of New Guinea-Mining claim-Appeal from Warden's Court to

Central Court of Territory-Order of Central Court "final and conclusive" No appeal therefrom to High Court-New Guinea Act 1920-1926 (No. 25 of 1920- No. 15 of 1926)-Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 (N.G.) (No. 3 of 1921-No. 8 of 1927), sec. 24*-Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926 (N.G.) (No. 25 of 1926), sec. 18*-Mining Ordinance 1922-1926 (N.G.) (No. 19 of 1922-No. 25 of 1926), sec. 103B-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), sec. 73.

Sec. 103B of the Mining Ordinance 1922-1926 (N.G.), as inserted by sec. 18 of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926, provides that on the hearing of an appeal from the Warden's Court to the Central Court " the Central Court may make an order reversing or varying the decision of the Warden's Court, or dismissing the appeal, and all such orders shall be final and conclusive on the parties."

Held, by the whole Court, that as such orders are " final and conclusive' leave to appeal therefrom to the High Court cannot be granted under sec. 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 (N.G.). * The Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927

fit to permit it, an appeal under this (Territory of New Guinea) by sec. 24

section may be by case stated, with the provides :- (1) The Full Court of the

legal argument (if any) attached thereto High Court of Australia, consisting of

in writing, and in that case it shall not at least two Judges, may grant leave to

be necessary for the parties to appear appeal to the High Court of Australia

on the hearing of the appeal either per- from any conviction, sentence, judg-

sonally or by counsel. (5) The order ment, decree or order of the Central

of the Court on appeal shall have effect (3) The High Court

in the Territory as if it were a judgment sitting as a Full Court (constituted by at

of the Central Court of the Territory, least two Judges) may hear the appeal,

and may be enforced by the Central and may make such order therein as it

Court accordingly." thinks just. (4) If the High Court sees

43 CLR 54

APPEAL from the Central Court of New Guinea.

In October 1927 one W. D. Morris was the owner of a certain gold-mining claim situate at Edie Creek in the Territory of New Guinea. It was agreed between Morris and John Pearson Living. SYMES.

stone, manager for the Edie Creek Pty. Ltd., that the Company should purchase the claim from Morris for the sum of £200, which was duly paid. The arrangement was a verbal one between the parties, and no particulars of the sale nor a transfer were registered. At that time the respondent, Matthew Symes, was a foreman in the employ of the Company, and Livingstone asked him to peg the claim out under his (Symes's) miner's right…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edie Creek Pty Ltd v Symes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1929] HCA 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Edie Creek Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the High Court of Australia from an order of the Central Court of the Territory of New Guinea. The dispute concerned a gold-mining claim that had been registered in the name of Matthew Symes (the respondent) but was claimed by the appellant company. The Central Court had dismissed the appellant's appeal from a decision of the Warden's Court, finding in favour of the respondent.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether an appeal lay to the High Court from the order of the Central Court of New Guinea. This question turned on the interpretation of section 103B of the Mining Ordinance 1922-1926 (N.G.), as inserted by section 18 of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926, which stipulated that orders made by the Central Court on appeals from the Warden's Court were "final and conclusive" on the parties. The appellant had initially obtained leave to appeal under section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 (N.G.).

The High Court held that the orders of the Central Court made under section 103B of the Mining Ordinance were indeed final and conclusive, thereby precluding any further appeal to the High Court. The Court reasoned that the explicit wording of section 103B, stating that the orders were "final and conclusive," was a clear legislative intent to terminate the appellate process at the Central Court level for such matters. Consequently, the leave to appeal previously granted under section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance was rendered ineffective, as that section did not override the specific exclusionary provision in the Mining Ordinance.

The High Court rescinded the leave to appeal, finding the appeal to be incompetent. No order was made as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In October 1927, W. D. Morris owned a gold mining claim at Edie Creek in the Territory of New Guinea. Morris agreed to sell the claim to Edie Creek Pty Ltd for £200, but the agreement was verbal and no transfer was registered. John Livingstone, the manager for Edie Creek Pty Ltd, asked Matthew Symes, a foreman for the company, to peg out the claim under his miner's right until Livingstone could secure it otherwise. Symes pegged out the claim and it was registered in his name, but he continued working the claim for the benefit of Edie Creek Pty Ltd until he was discharged in October 1928. Edie Creek Pty Ltd then sought possession of the claim from Symes, who refused to relinquish it. The Warden's Court dismissed a complaint against Symes for trespassing and an application for an injunction to restrain him from selling or working the claim, finding that the agreement between Symes and Livingstone was illegal under the Mining Regulations.

An appeal to the Central Court of the Territory of New Guinea was dismissed in favour of Symes, with the Chief Judge stating that Symes was the agent and servant of Edie Creek Pty Ltd and the company could not succeed due to the prohibited transaction. The decision raised important questions for the mining community of the Territory, leading to an appeal to the High Court. However, it was found that a new section, 103B, had been introduced into the principal Mining Ordinance, providing that decisions of the Central Court in respect of appeals from the Warden's Court shall be "final and conclusive." The appeal to the High Court was granted under the Judiciary Ordinance, but the Mining Ordinance precluded any appeal from the decision of the Central Court except to the Judicial Committee as of grace.

The matter of Edie Creek Pty Ltd v Symes originated in the Warden's Court of Edie Creek in the Territory of New Guinea. Following a verbal agreement between W. D. Morris, the owner of a gold-mining claim, and John Pearson Livingstone, manager for Edie Creek Pty Ltd, Morris agreed to sell the claim to the company for £200. However, the arrangement was not registered, and Matthew Symes, a foreman for the company, was asked by Livingstone to peg the claim out under his miner's right. Symes did so, and the claim was registered in his name. After working the claim for the benefit of the company, Symes was discharged in October 1928, and the company sought possession of the claim, which Symes refused to give. The Warden's Court dismissed a complaint that Symes was trespassing and an application for an injunction to restrain him from selling or working the claim, finding that the agreement between Symes and Livingstone was illegal as it contravened Mining Regulations. An appeal to the Central Court of the Territory of New Guinea was dismissed in favour of Symes, leading to an appeal to the High Court of Australia. The High Court found that the decision of the Central Court was "final and conclusive" under section 103B of the Mining Ordinance, and therefore, the leave to appeal to the High Court was ineffective.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926 preclude an appeal to the High Court from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea?

2. Does section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 permit an appeal from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea to the High Court, notwithstanding the phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926?

3. Can the High Court grant leave to appeal from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea under section 73 of the Constitution if the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 does not expressly permit such an appeal?

4. Is the Central Court of New Guinea a Federal Court within the meaning of section 73 of the Constitution, and does the judge of the Central Court have the necessary tenure of office to permit an appeal to the High Court under that section?

5. Was the leave to appeal granted by the High Court in this case effective, given the provisions of section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926?

Held
1. The phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926 precludes an appeal to the High Court from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea. As a result, the leave to appeal granted under section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 is ineffective.

2. Section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 does not permit an appeal from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea to the High Court, given the phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926.

3. The High Court cannot grant leave to appeal from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea under section 73 of the Constitution if the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 does not expressly permit such an appeal.

4. The Central Court of New Guinea is not a Federal Court within the meaning of section 73 of the Constitution, and the judge of the Central Court does not have the necessary tenure of office to permit an appeal to the High Court under that section.

5. The leave to appeal granted by the High Court in this case is not effective, given the provisions of section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court in Edie Creek Pty Ltd v Symes examined the scope and limitations of appeals from the Central Court of New Guinea to the High Court of Australia. The Court found that section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926 precluded an appeal from a decision of the Central Court of New Guinea. The phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B was held to mean that no further appeal could be made from the Central Court's decision. This interpretation was consistent with the legislative intent to prevent multiple appeals and ensure finality in mining-related disputes within the Territory of New Guinea.

The Court also considered whether section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance 1921-1927 permitted an appeal from the Central Court to the High Court, despite the phrase "final and conclusive" in section 103B. The Court concluded that the power to grant leave to appeal under section 24 applied only to decisions on matters of original jurisdiction and appellate matters from the District Courts, and not to appeals from the Warden's Court to the Central Court. Therefore, the "final and conclusive" nature of the Central Court's orders under section 103B precluded an appeal to the High Court under section 24 of the Judiciary Ordinance.

Furthermore, the Court addressed whether section 73 of the Constitution could be invoked to grant leave to appeal, despite the lack of explicit permission in the Judiciary Ordinance. The Court found that the Central Court of New Guinea was not a Federal Court within the meaning of section 73, and even if it were, the judge of the Central Court did not have the necessary tenure of office to permit an appeal to the High Court under that section. Consequently, the Court could not grant leave to appeal under section 73 of the Constitution.

Finally, the Court considered whether the leave to appeal granted by the High Court was effective in light of the provisions of section 103B of the Mining Ordinance (No. 2) 1926. The Court held that the leave to appeal was ineffective because the order of the Central Court was "final and conclusive," and no further appeal could be made from that decision. Therefore, the leave to appeal granted by the High Court was rescinded, and the appeal was deemed incompetent.