Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Eddie Michael Awad & anor v Twin Creek Properties Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 923 Hearing dates: 27, 28, 29, and 30 June 2011 Decision date: 30 June 2011 Jurisdiction: Equity Division Before: Brereton J Decision: Defendant to pay plaintiffs $75,000.
Defendant to pay 50 percent of plaintiffs' costs.
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES - Misleading and deceptive conduct - representations made in relation to future matters - effect of (CTH) Trade Practices Act s 51A - where corporation makes representation in relation to future matters and does not have reasonable grounds to make representation, representation presumed to be misleading - evidential onus on defendant to establish it had reasonable grounds - once defendant adduces such evidence onus falls on plaintiff to establish on balance of probabilities that grounds were not reasonable - reasonable grounds in relation to future matters involve an intention on part of representor to perform the representation and an ability to perform the representation - defendant had intention but did not have ability at time made representation to construct hotel and have certain hotel chain operate hotel - representation misleading and deceptive.
TRADE PRACTICES - Misleading and deceptive conduct - reliance on representation by plaintiffs to purchase property - first plaintiff asserts would not have purchased property but for representation - post facto subjective statements inherently unreliable - need to examine objective indicia as to whether plaintiff would have purchased property but for representation - representation influenced decision to purchase property but not decisive factor.
TRADE PRACTICES - Relief for misleading and deceptive conduct - plaintiff seeks order to rescind contract - where representation not decisive in plaintiff entering into contract, not appropriate to order rescission - representation affected purchase price - damages awarded commensurate to impact of representations on purchase price.
CIVIL LIABILITY - Defences - proportionate liability - plaintiffs' solicitor said not to have acted with due competence and skill in advising plaintiffs about purchase - claim an apportionable claim under (NSW) Civil Liability Act - solicitor a concurrent wrongdoer - liability of solicitor assessed at one-third.Legislation Cited: (NSW) Civil Liability Act 2002, s 34, s 35
(NSW) Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r 42.34
(CTH) Trade Practices Act 1974, s 51A, s 52, s 53A, s 82, s 84 s 87Cases Cited: Adelaide Petroleum NL v Poseidon Ltd (1988) ATPR 40-901
Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Ltd (1984) 55 ALR 25
Gould v Vaggelas (1984-1985) 157 CLR 215
Kayteal Pty Ltd v John Joseph Dignan & ors [2011] NSWSC 197
Sykes v Reserve Bank of Australia (1998) 88 FCR 511Category: Principal judgment Parties: Eddie Michael Awad (first plaintiff)
Karen Elizabeth Awad (second plaintiff)
Twin Creeks Properties Pty Ltd (defendant)Representation: Counsel:
CJ Birch SC and DS Wienberger (plaintiffs)
J Robson SC and D Healey (defendants)
Solicitors:
Thurlow Fisher Solicitors (plaintiff)
Surry Partners Lawyers Pty Ltd (defendant)
File Number(s): 2009/291401
Judgment (ex tempore)
Pursuant to an amended statement of claim filed on 19 November…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Eddie Michael Awad v Twin Creek Properties Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWSC 923
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues in this case revolved around whether the defendant's representations about the future hotel construction were misleading and deceptive, and if so, what relief the plaintiffs were entitled to. The court also considered the defendants' defence of proportionate liability, arguing that the plaintiffs' solicitor had failed to act with due competence and skill.
The court found that the defendant had made a misleading and deceptive representation when it stated it would construct a hotel and have a specific hotel chain operate it, despite not having the reasonable grounds to make such a representation. The court held that the defendant had the intention to perform the representation, but lacked the ability at the time of making the statement. The plaintiffs relied on this representation when purchasing the property, though the court determined that the representation was not the sole decisive factor in their decision to purchase. Instead, the representation influenced the decision but was not the sole determinant. Consequently, the court awarded damages commensurate with the impact of the misleading representation on the purchase price, rather than ordering rescission of the contract. The court also apportioned liability, finding that the plaintiffs' solicitor was a concurrent wrongdoer and assessing their liability at one-third.
The court ordered Twin Creek Properties Pty Ltd to pay damages to the plaintiffs, and the liability of the plaintiffs' solicitor was assessed at one-third.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was first heard in the lower court where Mr Awad brought an action against Twin Creek for misleading and deceptive conduct under section 51A of the Trade Practices Act. The lower court found in favour of Mr Awad and ordered damages. Twin Creek appealed the decision to the higher court, which reviewed the lower court's findings and the evidence presented regarding the reasonableness of the grounds for the representations made. The appeal focused on the assessment of reliance, the appropriateness of the relief ordered, and the apportionment of liability with respect to the solicitor's conduct.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did Twin Creek have reasonable grounds to make the representations regarding the future operation of the hotel, and if not, was the representation misleading and deceptive under section 51A of the Trade Practices Act?
2. To what extent did the misleading and deceptive conduct influence Mr Awad's decision to purchase the property, and is rescission of the contract the appropriate remedy?
3. What is the appropriate measure of damages where the representation influenced the purchase price but was not the sole decisive factor in the purchase decision?
4. Is the claim for professional negligence by Mr Awad's solicitor apportionable under the Civil Liability Act, and if so, what proportion of liability should be assigned to the solicitor?
Held
1. Twin Creek did not have reasonable grounds to make the representations regarding the future operation of the hotel, and the representation was misleading and deceptive under section 51A of the Trade Practices Act.
2. The misleading and deceptive conduct influenced Mr Awad's decision to purchase the property but was not the sole decisive factor; rescission of the contract was not the appropriate remedy.
3. The appropriate measure of damages should reflect the impact of the representation on the purchase price, as the representation influenced but did not solely determine the purchase decision.
4. The claim for professional negligence by Mr Awad's solicitor is apportionable under the Civil Liability Act, and the proportion of liability assigned to the solicitor was one-third.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining whether Twin Creek had reasonable grounds to make representations about the future operation of the hotel, as required by section 51A of the Trade Practices Act. The court held that Twin Creek did not have reasonable grounds to make such representations because they did not have the ability to construct the hotel or ensure the operation by a certain hotel chain at the time the representations were made. The court found that the lack of reasonable grounds meant the representations were misleading and deceptive. The court shifted the onus to Twin Creek to prove they had reasonable grounds and, once Twin Creek provided evidence, the onus shifted back to Mr Awad to show that the grounds were not reasonable. The court concluded that Twin Creek failed to establish that they had reasonable grounds, thus the representations were indeed misleading and deceptive.
Next, the court assessed the extent to which the misleading and deceptive conduct influenced Mr Awad's decision to purchase the property. The court noted that Mr Awad's subjective statement that he would not have purchased the property without the representations was unreliable, and therefore, objective evidence was needed to determine the impact of the representations. The court found that while the representations influenced the decision to purchase, they were not the sole decisive factor. Given that the representations did not solely determine the purchase decision, the court ruled that rescission of the contract was not the appropriate remedy. Instead, the court awarded damages that reflected the impact of the representations on the purchase price.
The court then turned to the measure of damages, determining that since the representations influenced the purchase price but were not the only factor in the purchase decision, the damages should be commensurate with the impact of the representations on the purchase price. This approach ensured that the damages awarded were appropriate given the specific circumstances of the case.
Finally, the court considered the apportionable claim for professional negligence by Mr Awad's solicitor under the Civil Liability Act. The court recognised that the solicitor was a concurrent wrongdoer and found that the claim was apportionable. The court assessed the liability of the solicitor and determined that one-third of the liability should be assigned to the solicitor, reflecting the degree of the solicitor's contribution to the overall harm. This apportionment aligned with the statutory provisions for proportionate liability in cases of concurrent wrongdoers.