Eather v Nguyen

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Administrative Decisions Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Eather v Nguyen [2011] NSWADT 80
Hearing dates:25 June and 2 August 2010 Submissions closed 13 September 2010
Decision date: 19 April 2011
Before: S Higgins Deputy President
Decision:

1.The respondent to pay the applicant an amount of $28,186.27.

2.The respondent to pay the applicant's cost in the amount of $2,400.00 (inclusive of GST). Otherwise no further order as to costs.

Catchwords: Damages - lessor's breach of lease - failure to maintain in a state of good condition and serviceable repair the floor of the property and failure to fix structural defects to the floor - costs
Legislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Food Act 2003
Retail Leases Act 1994
Cases Cited: Profilio v Coogee Bay Village Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] NSWADT 64
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Robert David Eather (Applicant)
Uyen Vu Ngoc Nguyen (Respondent)
Representation: Solicitors:
Shaddicks Lawyers (Applicant)
Aquinas & More Lawyers (Respondent)until 18 August 2010)
N Nguyen (Respondent in person) from 19 August 2010
File Number(s):105039

REasons for decision

Introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Eather, and his wife are the owners of a bakery business operated from premises owned by the respondent, Ms Nguyen. Mr Eather and his wife purchased the business in September 2007. When purchasing the business Ms Nguyen assigned the lease of the premises from which the business had been operating since 2004 (the 2004 lease).

  1. The initial parties to the 2004 lease were Rightscene Pty Limited (the lessor) and Nugenuly Pty Ltd (the lessee). It was a lease for 5 years, with an option to renew for a further 5-year period. The commencement date was 12 October 2004 and it expired on 11 October 2009.

  1. In October 2005, Ms Nguyen became the owner of the premises.

  1. During the latter part of 2009, a dispute arose between Mr Eather and Ms Nguyen over the condition of the floor in the premises. Mr Eather asserted that he had complained about the condition of the floor for some time as it was having a direct effect on his ability to keep the premises clean and hence his ongoing inability to comply with the food regulations. After a number of inspections of the premises, on 2 October 2009, the Hawkesbury City Council (the Council) issued Mr Eather with an Improvement Notice, followed by a Prohibition Order, on 13 November 2009. The Prohibition Order prohibited Mr Eather from handling food on premises that were intended for sale, or using any of the equipment on the premises in connection with food intended for sale.

  1. As a result of the Prohibition Order, Mr Eather ceased trading and did not recommence trading until 4 March 2010 after Ms Nguyen had replaced the floor of the premises and an agreement had been reached on a new lease. A new lease was necessary as Mr Eather had failed to give the requisite written notice of his intention to exercise his option to renew the 2004 lease.

  1. On 15 March 2010,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eather v Nguyen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWADT 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Eather v Nguyen involved the applicant, Eather, who sought compensation for damages incurred due to the respondent, Nguyen's, failure to maintain the leased property in a satisfactory condition. Specifically, the dispute centred around the respondent's failure to maintain the floor of the property in a state of good condition and serviceable repair, as well as neglecting to address structural defects. The matter was heard in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent's actions constituted a breach of the lease agreement. The applicant argued that the respondent had failed in their duty to maintain the property, which resulted in significant damage. The respondent, on the other hand, contended that the damages were not a result of their negligence, but rather due to the natural wear and tear of the property. The court was required to determine the extent of the respondent's responsibility and whether the applicant was entitled to compensation.

The tribunal found that the respondent had indeed breached the lease by failing to maintain the property as required. Evidence showed that the respondent had ignored multiple requests to fix the structural issues and the floor condition. The tribunal concluded that the respondent's negligence led to the damage, and therefore, they were liable for the costs. The court awarded the applicant $28,186.27 in damages, along with $2,400.00 for costs, inclusive of GST, against the respondent. No further order as to costs was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.The respondent to pay the applicant an amount of $28,186.27.

2.The respondent to pay the applicant's cost in the amount of $2,400.00 (inclusive of GST). Otherwise no further order as to costs.