DZAEK v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DZAEK & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2016] FCCA 1824
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Refugee applications – whether well-founded fear of harm from religious extremists in Pakistan because of extended stay in Australia, attendance at school and female sex.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.36

First Applicant: DZAEK
Second Applicant: DZAEL
Third Applicant: DZAEM
Fourth Applicant: DZAEN
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: DNG 36 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Young
Hearing date: 17 September 2015
Date of Last Submission: 17 September 2015
Delivered at: Adelaide
Delivered on: 19 July 2016

REPRESENTATION

The First Applicant appeared in person on behalf of all applicants
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Brown
Solicitors for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. The application filed 18 June 2015 be dismissed.

  2. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application fixed in the sum of $6,825.00.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

DNG 36 of 2015

DZAEK

First Applicant

DZAEL

Second Applicant

DZAEM

Third Applicant

DZAEN

Fourth Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to reject applications for protection visas for a family of four who are citizens of Pakistan. The first applicant is aged 35 years, the second applicant, his wife, is aged 33 years and the third and fourth applicants, their children, a son and daughter, are aged 9 years and 6 years respectively. Both children were born in Australia and have lived here all their lives.

  2. The first applicant arrived in Australia as a student in 2005. He returned to Pakistan and brought his wife to Australia in 2006. The first applicant’s second application for a student visa was refused in September 2010. After an appeal to the Migration Review Tribunal this application was remitted to the Department in August 2012. The application was refused in November 2012. A further appeal to the Migration Review Tribunal was unsuccessful in December 2012.

  3. The applicants applied for protection visas in November 2012. These were refused by the delegate in August 2013. The applicants appealed to the Refugee Review Tribunal in September 2013. The delegate’s decision was affirmed in July 2014. The applicants appealed the decision to the Federal Circuit Court which remitted the matter by consent to the Refugee Review Tribunal for reconsideration in February 2015. The applications were rejected in May 2015. The applicants applied to this court for judicial review in June 2015 and the application was heard in September 2015.

  4. The first applicant has been employed in Darwin and his children attend a local primary school.

  5. The applicants made various claims to the delegate. The first applicant claimed that he and his family had a well-founded fear of persecution in Pakistan or that there was a real risk that they would suffer significant harm if they…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DZAEK v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 1824
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DZAEK (the applicant) sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration (the respondent) to refuse to grant a protection visa. The applicant, who was from Iran, claimed to have been persecuted in Iran and sought protection in Australia. The Minister's delegate had refused the application, and this decision was affirmed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The applicant then brought proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate's decision, as affirmed by the Tribunal, was affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the applicant argued that the delegate had failed to properly consider relevant information and had made findings of fact that were not supported by evidence, thereby failing to exercise their jurisdiction according to law. The applicant contended that this failure constituted a jurisdictional error that vitiated the decision.

Judge Young found that the delegate's decision-making process, as reflected in the Tribunal's reasons, did not demonstrate a failure to consider relevant information or the making of unsupported factual findings. The Court held that the delegate had adequately assessed the applicant's claims and the evidence presented, and that the Tribunal had correctly applied the relevant legal principles in affirming that decision. Therefore, there was no jurisdictional error.

The application for judicial review was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of DZAEK v Minister for Immigration involves a family of four Pakistani citizens who have applied for protection visas in Australia. The first applicant arrived in Australia as a student in 2005 and returned to Pakistan, subsequently bringing his wife to Australia in 2006. Their two children were born in Australia and have lived there all their lives. The family applied for protection visas in November 2012, which were subsequently refused by the delegate in August 2013. The applicants appealed to the Refugee Review Tribunal, but the delegate's decision was affirmed in July 2014. The applicants further appealed to the Federal Circuit Court, which remitted the matter to the Refugee Review Tribunal for reconsideration in February 2015. The applications were again rejected in May 2015, prompting the applicants to apply for judicial review in June 2015.

The applicants claimed that they had a well-founded fear of persecution in Pakistan or that there was a real risk they would suffer significant harm if they returned. The claims were based on the first applicant's occupation as a social worker, the children's attendance at Christian and Western schools, the family's extended residence in Australia, imputed association with Western values and culture, the sex of the female applicants, and the first applicant's marriage which was said to have transgressed certain customary norms. They also raised a claim of lack of effective state protection in Pakistan and argued that internal relocation within Pakistan was not reasonable or practicable.

The delegate made adverse findings about the first applicant’s credibility due to his failure to provide frank information about his criminal record. The delegate rejected the applicants' claims but found that there was a lack of effective state protection in Peshawar, Pakistan. The delegate found that it was reasonable and practicable for the applicants to relocate within Pakistan to a large city such as Rawalpindi or Islamabad. The Tribunal reached the same conclusion about the first applicant’s lack of credibility but recognised the necessity to properly examine the applicants' claims based on reliable or independent information. The Tribunal rejected the applicants' claims, finding that the risk of harm to the family, including the children, from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the attendance of the third applicant at a Christian school was remote if they relocated within Pakistan. The Tribunal also found that there was no real risk of harm to the female applicants if they relocated within Pakistan.

This case involves an application for judicial review by DZAEK and three others against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, challenging a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to reject their applications for protection visas. The applicants, all citizens of Pakistan, argue that they have a well-founded fear of persecution or significant harm if returned to Pakistan, based on various grounds including religious extremism, the children's education in Australia, and the family's imputed association with Western values. The case originated with applications for protection visas made in November 2012, which were refused by the delegate in August 2013. Subsequent appeals to the Refugee Review Tribunal were unsuccessful, culminating in the Tribunal's decision in May 2015. The applicants then applied to the Federal Circuit Court for judicial review in June 2015. The application was heard in September 2015 and the judgment was delivered in July 2016. The court found no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision and dismissed the application with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the decision of the Second Respondent affected by jurisdictional error in that it asked itself the wrong questions when determining the claims of the Fourth Applicant?
2. Did the Tribunal fail to properly consider the Third Applicant’s claim about his alleged speech impediment or disorder and related health issues?
3. Was there a jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s consideration of the applicants’ claims of a well-founded fear of harm from terrorist groups due to their Westernised appearance and education, and the female applicants’ risk due to their gender?
4. Did the Tribunal err in finding that it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate within Pakistan, and thereby not definitively answering whether the applicants faced a real risk of significant harm in Peshawar?
5. Did the Tribunal appropriately consider the risks to the applicants from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the children's attendance at Western and Christian schools?
6. Was there a failure by the Tribunal to properly assess the risk to the female applicants from the general poor status of women in Pakistan and potential discrimination or violence due to their sex and Western dress?
7. Did the Tribunal properly address the lack of effective state protection claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan?

Held
1. The court concluded that there was no jurisdictional error in the Second Respondent's decision regarding the Fourth Applicant, as the questions posed by the Tribunal were relevant to the claims made. The application on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court found that the Tribunal did not err in rejecting the Third Applicant’s claim about his alleged speech impediment or disorder and related health issues, as there was insufficient evidence provided. The application on this issue was dismissed.
3. The court determined that there was no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s consideration of the applicants' claims of a well-founded fear of harm from terrorist groups due to their Westernised appearance and education, and the female applicants’ risk due to their gender. The application on this issue was dismissed.
4. The court held that the Tribunal did not err in finding that it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate within Pakistan, and therefore did not definitively answer whether the applicants faced a real risk of significant harm in Peshawar. The application on this issue was dismissed.
5. The court concluded that the Tribunal appropriately considered the risks to the applicants from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the children's attendance at Western and Christian schools. The application on this issue was dismissed.
6. The court found that there was no failure by the Tribunal to properly assess the risk to the female applicants from the general poor status of women in Pakistan and potential discrimination or violence due to their sex and Western dress. The application on this issue was dismissed.
7. The court determined that the Tribunal properly addressed the lack of effective state protection claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan. The application on this issue was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicants' first contention is that the decision of the Second Respondent was affected by jurisdictional error in that it asked itself the wrong questions when determining the claims of the Fourth Applicant. The applicants submitted that the Tribunal should have considered whether the Fourth Applicant had a well-founded fear of being persecuted upon her return to Peshawar for reasons of her membership of a particular social group of girls who attend or have attended a school and/or a Western school, and whether there were substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of her being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there was a real risk that she would suffer significant harm. The applicants argued that the Tribunal instead asked itself incorrect questions about the risk of abduction, killing, or persecution of the children while attending school in Peshawar and the risk to the Second and Fourth Applicants as a result of their gender.

The court held that the Tribunal did not err in the questions it asked. The questions posed by the Tribunal were relevant to the issues before it. The Tribunal considered the risks to the applicants if they returned to Peshawar and the claims of the Second and Fourth Applicants as females, which were the relevant grounds for assessing the applicants' claims. The Tribunal did not limit itself to the questions posited by the applicants but rather considered the entirety of the applicants' claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan. The Tribunal accepted that there was a risk of harm to the children attending school in Peshawar and considered the risk to the female applicants due to their sex. The questions asked by the Tribunal were appropriate to the issues before it.

The applicants' second contention is that the Tribunal failed to properly consider the Third Applicant’s claim about his alleged speech impediment or disorder and related health issues. The applicants submitted that the Tribunal was provided with available medical reports but did not consider them and did not accept that the Third Applicant would be unable to access speech therapists or special teachers in Pakistan. The court found that the Tribunal did not err in its consideration of the Third Applicant’s claim. The Tribunal noted that there was no evidence of an assessment of the Third Applicant by a speech therapist and that there was no evidence that he suffered from a speech impediment or any learning difficulties. The Tribunal concluded that even if the Third Applicant did have some such difficulties, it did not accept that he would be unable to access speech therapists or special teachers in Pakistan. The Tribunal's consideration of the issue was proper.

The applicants' third contention is that there was a jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s consideration of their claims of a well-founded fear of harm from terrorist groups due to their Westernised appearance and education, and the female applicants’ risk due to their gender. The court held that the Tribunal properly considered these claims. The Tribunal accepted that there was a risk to the applicants from terrorist groups because of their Westernised appearance and education and the female applicants' risk due to their gender. The Tribunal considered the risks in attending English medium or girls’ schools elsewhere in Pakistan and the risks to the family from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the attendance of the Third Applicant at a Christian school. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence of attacks on schools elsewhere in Pakistan and did not accept that the female applicants had any particular vulnerability to harm from the Taliban or other extremist groups. The Tribunal's consideration of these claims was proper.

The applicants' fourth contention is that the Tribunal erred in finding that it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate within Pakistan, and thereby not definitively answering whether the applicants faced a real risk of significant harm in Peshawar. The court held that the Tribunal did not err in its consideration of the issue of internal relocation. The Tribunal considered the risks to the applicants if they returned to Peshawar and found that it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate to another part of Pakistan such as Rawalpindi or Islamabad. The Tribunal did not limit itself to the question of whether there was a real chance that the children would be abducted, killed, or otherwise persecuted while attending school in Peshawar but rather considered the entirety of the applicants' claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan. The Tribunal's consideration of the issue was proper.

The applicants' fifth contention is that the Tribunal did not properly consider the risks to the applicants from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the children's attendance at Western and Christian schools. The court held that the Tribunal properly considered these risks. The Tribunal accepted that there was considerable Western influence in Pakistan, particularly in large urban areas such as Rawalpindi and Islamabad, and that there are many Pakistanis who have relatives living in Western countries and many who have lived abroad. The Tribunal referred to Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade advice that there was no evidence that such individuals suffer discrimination or violence because they have lived in Western countries and that such large urban centres are home to mixed ethnic and religious communities and offer greater opportunities for employment, access to services, and a higher level of state protection. The Tribunal's consideration of these risks was proper.

The applicants' sixth contention is that the Tribunal failed to properly assess the risk to the female applicants from the general poor status of women in Pakistan and potential discrimination or violence due to their sex and Western dress. The court held that the Tribunal properly considered these risks. The Tribunal accepted that the status of women in Pakistan is poor and that there is violence and discrimination against women in Pakistan but did not accept that the Second and Fourth Applicants had any particular vulnerability to harm from the Taliban or other extremist groups and did not accept that if they chose to wear Western dress that they would be subjected to harm for that reason. The Tribunal found that Western influence was pervasive in Pakistan, particularly in large urban centres, and did not accept that there was a real chance that the female applicants would be persecuted for reasons of their membership of the particular social group of women and girls in Pakistan or their adoption of Western culture or dress in places such as Islamabad or Rawalpindi. The Tribunal's consideration of these risks was proper.

The applicants' seventh contention is that the Tribunal did not properly address the lack of effective state protection claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan. The court held that the Tribunal properly considered the lack of effective state protection claims. The Tribunal found that there was a lack of effective state protection in Peshawar but found it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate within Pakistan. The Tribunal considered the risks to the applicants if they returned to Peshawar and found that it was reasonable for the applicants to relocate to another part of Pakistan such as Rawalpindi or Islamabad. The Tribunal's consideration of the lack of effective state protection claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan was proper.

The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the Tribunal did not err in its consideration of the applicants' claims, and there was no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s decision. The Tribunal properly considered the applicants' claims of a well-founded fear of harm from terrorist groups due to their Westernised appearance and education, the female applicants’ risk due to their gender, the risks to the applicants from their extended stay in Australia, perceived Westernisation, and the children's attendance at Western and Christian schools, and the lack of effective state protection claims in the context of internal relocation within Pakistan. The Tribunal did not err in the questions it asked or in its consideration of the applicants' claims, and there was no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal’s decision.