Dyno Nobel Inc v Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dyno Nobel Inc v Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 258

File number: NSD 1500 of 2017
Judge: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 19 February 2019
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery – where indirect infringement, authorisation and joint tortfeasorship alleged in relation to a process patent – where liability is denied on the basis that the nature of the alleged infringer’s involvement not sufficient to give rise to liability – where a process description is proffered by the alleged infringer in lieu of discovery but is contested – application granted
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 20.14
Date of hearing: 19 February 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and Associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 25
Counsel for the Applicant and Cross-Respondents: Ms C Cochrane with Mr D Harris
Solicitor for the Applicant and Cross-Respondents: Shelston IP Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent and Cross-Claimants: Mr N Murray SC with Dr W Rothnie
Solicitor for the Respondent and Cross-Claimants: Davies Collison Cave Law Pty Ltd

ORDERS

NSD 1500 of 2017
BETWEEN:

DYNO NOBEL INC

Applicant and First Cross-Respondent

DYNO NOBEL ASIA PACIFIC PTY LTD (ACN 003 269 010)
Second Cross-Respondent

AND:

ORICA EXPLOSIVES TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD

Respondent and First Cross-Claimant

ORICA INTERNATIONAL PTE LTD (Singapore Company Registration No. 20080258K)

Second Cross-Claimant

JUDGE:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 FEBRUARY 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant/Cross-respondents (Dyno) give standard discovery of:

(a)the documents underlying Dyno’s Further Process Description dated 28 September 2018 (FPD), by 8 March 2019;

(b)documents falling within category 3 listed in Annexure A to this Order, by 29 March 2019; and

(c)documents falling within the categories 1 and 2 listed in Annexure A to this Order, by 10 May 2019,

subject to the confidentiality regime agreed by the parties for this proceeding restricting access to those documents and their contents to external Australian legal practitioners (including legal graduates), Australian external barristers, Australian external patent attorneys and external independent experts, retained by the Respondent / Cross-claimants (Orica) in this proceeding, who have given signed undertakings in the agreed form.

2.By 29 March 2019, Dyno serve on Orica a summary document identifying each Mine, identified by pseudonym, at which blasts referred to at paragraph 10 (a) (i) – (iv) of Dyno's Amended Defence to Cross-claim dated 24 July 2018 (Paragraph 10 Blasts) took place and for each Mine and each Paragraph 10 Blast at the Mine:

(a)the date of the Paragraph 10 Blast;

(b)the Blast Type (as defined in the FPD); and

(c)whether Dyno's involvement in the Paragraph 10 Blast was Type A, B, C, D, E, F or G Blast Involvement (as referred to in the FPD).

Evidence on infringement

3.The date specified in paragraph 2 of the orders made on 9 August 2018 for Orica to file any evidence in support of their cross-claim for patent infringement, including any independent expert affidavits or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dyno Nobel Inc v Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dyno Nobel Inc (Dyno) filed an application for standard discovery against Orica Explosives Technology Pty Ltd (Orica) seeking disclosure of documents relevant to a dispute over alleged infringement of a patent. The Federal Court heard the application and made orders for discovery, evidence, and procedure. The legal issues before the Court were the scope of the discovery orders, the provision of a process description by Dyno, and the timeline for the exchange of evidence and expert reports. The Court found that the application for standard discovery should be granted in part and ordered Dyno to provide certain documents by specified dates. The Court also ordered Dyno to provide a summary of blast information and a marked-up version of a technical primer and glossary. The Court further ordered the parties to confer to reach agreement on the final form of the process description and technical primer and glossary and to prepare joint expert reports. The Court set out detailed timelines for the exchange of evidence, objections, and submissions. The Court also vacated certain earlier orders and awarded costs to Orica.

The Court's reasoning was that the discovery orders should be tailored to the specific allegations in the case and the needs of the parties. The Court found that Dyno's process description was insufficient and ordered it to provide the underlying documents. The Court also found that the timeline for the exchange of evidence and expert reports should be extended to allow for the preparation of joint expert reports. The Court emphasised the importance of the parties working together to reach agreement on key documents and to prepare for trial. The Court's orders reflect its focus on efficient case management and the need for the parties to cooperate in the preparation for trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant/Cross-respondents (Dyno) give standard discovery of:

(a) the documents underlying Dyno’s Further Process Description dated 28 September 2018 (FPD), by 8 March 2019;

(b) documents falling within category 3 listed in Annexure A to this Order, by 29 March 2019; and

(c) documents falling within the categories 1 and 2 listed in Annexure A to this Order, by 10 May 2019,

subject to the confidentiality regime agreed by the parties for this proceeding restricting access to those documents and their contents to external Australian legal practitioners (including legal graduates), Australian external barristers, Australian external patent attorneys and external independent experts, retained by the Respondent / Cross-claimants (Orica) in this proceeding, who have given signed undertakings in the agreed form.

2. By 29 March 2019, Dyno serve on Orica a summary document identifying each Mine, identified by pseudonym, at which blasts referred to at paragraph 10 (a) (i) – (iv) of Dyno's Amended Defence to Cross-claim dated 24 July 2018 (Paragraph 10 Blasts) took place and for each Mine and each Paragraph 10 Blast at the Mine:

(a) the date of the Paragraph 10 Blast;

(b) the Blast Type (as defined in the FPD); and

(c) whether Dyno's involvement in the Paragraph 10 Blast was Type A, B, C, D, E, F or G Blast Involvement (as referred to in the FPD).

Evidence on infringement

3. The date specified in paragraph 2 of the orders made on 9 August 2018 for Orica to file any evidence in support of their cross-claim for patent infringement, including any independent expert affidavits or reports, as extended by paragraph 1 of the orders made on 22 November 2018, be extended to 11 June 2019.

3A. By 11 June 2019, Orica provide Dyno with a marked-up version of the FPD

indicating:

(a) which parts of that document Orica accepts as accurately stating Dyno’s involvement in the Blasts (as referred to in the FPD); and

(b) any changes, deletions or additions to that document that Orica considers necessary to accurately state Dyno’s involvement in the Blasts (as referred to in the FPD).

4. The date specified in paragraph 3 of the orders made on 9 August 2018 for Dyno to file any affidavit evidence in answer on patent infringement, including any independent expert affidavits or reports, be extended to 8 July 2019.

5. The date specified in paragraph 4 of the orders made on 9 August 2018 for Orica to file any affidavits in reply on patent infringement, limited to factual matters, be extended to 5 August 2019.

Technical Primer

6. By 26 March 2019, Orica provide Dyno with a marked-up version of the technical primer and glossary served by Dyno's solicitors on 13 February 2019 indicating:

(a) which parts of that document Orica accepts as stating accurately matters forming part of the common general knowledge in the relevant art(s) at the priority date; and

(b) any changes, deletions or additions to that document that Orica considers necessary to accurately state matters forming part of the common general knowledge in the relevant art(s) at the priority date.

7. The orders in paragraph 2 of the orders made on 23 August 2018 and paragraph 2 of the orders made on 22 November 2018 be vacated.

8. By 26 June 2019, the parties confer with a view to reaching agreement on the final form of the:

(a) FPD; and

(b) technical primer and glossary, which is to be taken as an agreed statement of matters forming part of the common general knowledge in the relevant art(s) at the priority date (Technical Primer).

9. By 28 June 2019, Dyno is to file the FPD and the Technical Primer. If there are matters in the FPD on which the parties do not agree, the document should clearly indicate each party’s position in respect of those matters.

Joint Expert Reports

10. The parties, by their counsel, confer with a view to reaching agreement by no later than 2 August 2019 in relation to the following matters:

(a) which of the parties’ expert witnesses ought to be involved in the preparation of a joint expert report or joint expert reports; and

(b) the general topics that the expert witnesses (or each pair or group of expert witnesses) participating in the preparation of the joint expert report (or each joint expert report), are to discuss,

provided that, if agreement cannot be reached by 2 August 2018, the parties approach the Court to resolve any such disagreement.

11. By 16 August 2019, each pair or group of expert witnesses, as agreed by the parties or otherwise determined by the Court, confer (by such means as they consider appropriate) to:

(a) identify those matters which they regard as significant upon which they agree and those matters on which they differ; and

(b) prepare and provide to the parties’ respective instructing solicitors a joint report signed by each of them for the Court recording the matters on which they agree and disagree and, with respect to the latter, a brief explanation by each of them of the basis upon which their views differ.

12. By 19 August 2019, the parties file the joint expert report or joint expert reports.

Court Book

13. By 5 August 2019, Dyno is to provide to Orica a draft index to a Court Book.

14. By 12 August 2019, Orica is to notify Dyno of any comments or amendments they have on the draft index to the Court Book.

15. By 23 August 2019, Dyno is to:

(a) provide 2 x hard copies and 2 x electronic copies of the Court Book to Justice Burley’s Associate; and

(b) serve on Orica a hard copy and electronic copy of the Court Book,

in a form to be discussed at the case management hearing referred to in order 24 below.

Evidence

16. By 12 August 2019, the parties are to exchange, and provide to Burley J's Associate, lists of deponents who are required for cross-examination.

17. By 12 August 2019, the parties are to notify objections to affidavits and legal representatives are to confer with a view to resolving objections to affidavits.

18. By 27 August 2019, the parties are to exchange and provide to Burley J's Associate, a list of objections to affidavits and documents that are unable to be resolved by agreement, including in each case the basis for the objection, including reference to relevant sections of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).

Submissions and authorities

19. By 27 August 2019,

(a) Dyno is to file and serve its outline of opening submissions on validity, limited to 15 pages; and

(b) Orica is to file and serve an outline of its opening submissions on infringement, limited to 15 pages.

20. By 3 September 2019,

(a) Orica is to file and serve its outline of opening submissions in answer, limited to 15 pages; and

(b) Dyno is to file and serve its outline of opening submissions in answer, limited to 15 pages.

21. By 6 September 2019, the parties are to provide to Burley J's Associate an agreed bundle of authorities in electronic format.

Other

22. Paragraphs 12, 13 and 14 of the orders made on:

(a) 18 July 2018; and

(b) 16 March 2018,

be vacated.

23. Dyno pays Orica's costs of the Interlocutory Application filed on 3 December 2018.

24. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on 19 July 2019.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Annexure A – Discovery categories

In these Discovery categories:

(i) a reference to “Dyno” is a reference to each Cross-respondent and its related bodies corporate (as defined in the Corporations Act 2001)

(ii) "Paragraph 10 Blast" means each blast referred to in paragraphs 10 (a)(i) – (iv) of Dyno's Amended Defence to Cross-claim dated 24 July 2018.

1. Documents recording or evidencing the terms of any agreement, arrangement or understanding between Dyno and a Mine in respect of the conduct of a Paragraph 10 Blast.

2. Documents recording or evidencing instructions, directions, advice, recommendations or suggestions:

(a) provided by or on behalf of Dyno to a Mine; or

(b) provided by or on behalf of a Mine to Dyno,

in respect of the technical objectives, features or conduct of a Paragraph 10 Blast including any proposals, templates, guidelines, presentations, marketing materials or reports.

3. Marketing materials, presentations, reports or other promotional materials made available to the public by or on behalf of Dyno in relation to Paragraph 10 Blasts.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.