Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
[2022] FWCA 440

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.225 - Application for termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date

Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Limited

(AG2022/102)

Manufacturing and associated industries

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BINET

PERTH, 10 FEBRUARY 2022

Application for termination of the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Site Enterprise Agreement 2018 – application granted

  1. Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (Dyno Nobel) has made an application (Application) to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) to terminate the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Sites Enterprise Agreement 2018 (Agreement) pursuant to section 225 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act).

  1. The Agreement was approved by Deputy President Beaumont pursuant to section 185 of the FW Act, on 21 March 2019 and, commenced operation on 28 March 2019. The Agreement had a nominal expiry date of 21 March 2021.

  1. The parties to the Agreement are Dyno Nobel and employees of Dyno Nobel employed in the classification of Operator who work in connection with the operations of Dyno Nobel WA remote open cut service sites which include Tropicana, Mt Keith, and any other remote site south of the Tropic of Capricorn where Dyno Nobel WA remote open cut service operations begin on or after 1 July 2018 (with exclusion of Collie) (Employees).

  1. There are no employee organisations are covered by the Agreement.

  1. In support of the Application, Dyno Nobel filed a statutory declaration by Ms Sally Stokes, Employee Relations Manager (Stokes Declaration).

  1. On 27 January 2022, directions were issued with respect to the Application (Directions).  The Directions required Dyno Nobel to file an outline of submissions in support of the Application and any evidence on which Dyno Nobel sought to rely.  Dyno Nobel was invited to make oral submissions in relation to the Application but were content for the Application to be determined on the papers.

Background

  1. Dyno Nobel supplies industrial explosives and blasting services to the mining industry in Australia, Europe, Indonesia and Papua New Guinea. Servicing surface and underground mining in the thermal coal, metallurgical coal, iron ore and other metals sectors.  Dyno Nobel is the second largest supplier in Australia which is the third largest explosives market in the world.

  1. The Agreement has been replaced by the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021 (Successor Agreement).  According to the Stokes Declaration there are no employees currently covered by the Agreement or plans for the Agreement to cover any employees in the future.

Legislation

  1. Subdivision D of Division 7 of Part 2-4 of the FW Act sets out the mechanism by which an enterprise agreement may be terminated after the agreement has passed its nominal expiry date.

  1. Section 225 of the FW Act provides that:

“225     Application for termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date

If an enterprise agreement has passed its nominal expiry date, any of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWCA 440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Ltd applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for termination of the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Sites Enterprise Agreement 2018 (Agreement) under section 225 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). The Agreement had passed its nominal expiry date and Dyno Nobel was an employer covered by the Agreement. The Agreement had been replaced by the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021 and there were no employees currently covered by the Agreement. The Deputy President was required to consider whether termination of the Agreement was not contrary to the public interest and whether termination was appropriate taking into account all the circumstances, including the views of the employees, each employer, and each employee organisation covered by the agreement, and the circumstances of those employees, employers and organisations including the likely effect that the termination will have on each of them. The Deputy President was satisfied that it was not contrary to the public interest to terminate the Agreement and that it was appropriate to terminate the Agreement taking into account all the circumstances. The views of Dyno Nobel that the Agreement should be terminated were valid as the Agreement had passed its nominal expiry date some time ago and it had been replaced by the Successor Agreement.

The Deputy President concluded that termination of the Agreement was not contrary to the public interest. The Deputy President considered how the termination of the Agreement might foreseeably affect the public as a whole, such as the impact on the achievement of the various objects of the Act, employment levels, inflation and the maintenance of proper industrial standards. The Deputy President found that termination of the Agreement was in the public interest as it would not result in changes in existing employment levels or adversely affect future employment opportunities. The Deputy President also found that termination of the Agreement would have no impact upon the business of the employer other than removing any risk of potential confusion as to agreement coverage. The Deputy President was satisfied that the views of Dyno Nobel that the Agreement should be terminated were valid as the Agreement had passed its nominal expiry date some time ago and it had been replaced by the Successor Agreement. The Deputy President was also satisfied that the circumstances of Dyno Nobel were such that it was appropriate to terminate the Agreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Ltd is a significant player in the explosives and blasting services sector, supplying to the mining industry across Australia, Europe, Indonesia, and Papua New Guinea. The company operates in the thermal coal, metallurgical coal, iron ore, and other metals sectors. Dyno Nobel is the second-largest supplier of explosives in Australia, which is the third-largest explosives market globally. The company’s operations include remote open cut service sites such as Tropicana, Mt Keith, and other sites south of the Tropic of Capricorn, excluding Collie.

The Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Sites Enterprise Agreement 2018 (Agreement) was approved by Deputy President Beaumont on 21 March 2019 and commenced operation on 28 March 2019. The Agreement had a nominal expiry date of 21 March 2021 and applied to Dyno Nobel employees classified as Operators working at the aforementioned remote sites. Notably, there were no employee organisations covered by this Agreement. Following the Agreement’s expiry, Dyno Nobel implemented the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021 (Successor Agreement) to replace it. As of the time of the decision, no employees were covered by the original Agreement, and there were no plans for it to cover any employees in the future.

In support of its application to terminate the Agreement, Dyno Nobel provided a statutory declaration by Ms. Sally Stokes, the Employee Relations Manager. The company argued that terminating the Agreement was in the public interest due to its expiration, replacement by the Successor Agreement, the absence of current employees covered by it, and the lack of impact on employment levels or industrial standards. Dyno Nobel also noted that the termination would eliminate any risk of confusion regarding the Agreement’s coverage. The Fair Work Commission found that there were no matters contrary to the public interest in terminating the Agreement and that it was appropriate to do so considering the circumstances and views of Dyno Nobel, which sought to terminate the expired and redundant Agreement.

Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Limited applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for the termination of the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Sites Enterprise Agreement 2018 after its nominal expiry date under section 225 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The Agreement, which commenced on 28 March 2019 and had a nominal expiry date of 21 March 2021, was approved by Deputy President Beaumont on 21 March 2019. The application was filed by Dyno Nobel, supported by a statutory declaration from their Employee Relations Manager, Ms Sally Stokes, who attested that there were no employees currently covered by the Agreement and no plans for it to cover any employees in the future. Following the issuance of directions on 27 January 2022, Dyno Nobel submitted its outline of submissions and relevant evidence. The matter was subsequently determined on the papers, without oral submissions, by Deputy President Binet in Perth on 10 February 2022.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is it not contrary to the public interest to terminate the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Site Enterprise Agreement 2018 after its nominal expiry date?
2. What are the views of the employees, employers, and employee organisations covered by the Agreement on the proposed termination?
3. Are the circumstances of the parties, including the replacement of the Agreement with the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021, appropriate for the termination of the Agreement?
4. Is it appropriate to terminate the Agreement taking into account all the circumstances, including the views and circumstances of the parties, and the likely effect of the termination on each of them?

Held
1. Is it not contrary to the public interest to terminate the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Site Enterprise Agreement 2018 after its nominal expiry date?
The court concluded that it is not contrary to the public interest to terminate the Agreement. The result was that the application for termination was granted.

2. What are the views of the employees, employers, and employee organisations covered by the Agreement on the proposed termination?
The court found that there are currently no employees covered by the Agreement. The employer, Dyno Nobel, wishes to terminate the Agreement. The Agreement does not cover any employee organisation.

3. Are the circumstances of the parties, including the replacement of the Agreement with the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021, appropriate for the termination of the Agreement?
The court concluded that it is appropriate to terminate the Agreement, taking into account all the circumstances, including the views and circumstances of Dyno Nobel and the replacement of the Agreement with the Successor Agreement.

4. Is it appropriate to terminate the Agreement taking into account all the circumstances, including the views and circumstances of the parties, and the likely effect of the termination on each of them?
The court found that it is appropriate to terminate the Agreement, taking into account all the circumstances. The result was that the Agreement is terminated, and the termination is effective from the date of the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the application by Dyno Nobel Asia Pacific Pty Ltd for the termination of the Dyno Nobel WA Remote Open Cut Services Site Enterprise Agreement 2018, the Deputy President of the Fair Work Commission evaluated several factors to ascertain whether the termination would be contrary to the public interest and appropriate given the circumstances. Firstly, the Deputy President assessed whether the termination would affect the public interest negatively. The Deputy President noted that there were no employees currently covered by the Agreement and no plans for it to cover any employees in the future. Moreover, the Agreement had been replaced by the Dyno Nobel WA Surface Operations Enterprise Agreement 2021. Dyno Nobel argued that terminating the Agreement would not result in changes to existing employment levels or negatively affect future employment opportunities, nor would it impact the employer's business operations. Based on these submissions and the evidence, the Deputy President concluded that terminating the Agreement was not contrary to the public interest.

The Deputy President then considered the views and circumstances of the parties involved. As there were no employees currently covered by the Agreement, the Deputy President focused on the views and circumstances of the employer, Dyno Nobel. The employer wished to terminate the Agreement, and the Deputy President found the employer's views to be valid given that the Agreement had passed its nominal expiry date and had been replaced by the Successor Agreement. Furthermore, the Deputy President considered that terminating the Agreement would not have any negative impact on the employer's business operations.

Taking into account all the circumstances, including the views and circumstances of Dyno Nobel, the Deputy President concluded that terminating the Agreement was appropriate. The Deputy President found that the termination was in line with the objects of the Fair Work Act 2009, which include providing a simple, flexible and fair framework for collective bargaining and enabling the Fair Work Commission to facilitate good faith bargaining and the making of enterprise agreements.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date is not contrary to the public interest and is appropriate if the agreement has been replaced, there are no employees currently covered by the agreement, and the termination does not negatively affect employment levels or the employer's business operations. The Deputy President also emphasized that the views and circumstances of the parties should be considered, but they should not be given independent weight. Instead, they should be evaluated to determine whether the termination is in line with the objects of the Fair Work Act 2009.