Dyinda Pty Ltd ACN 009 020 526 v First Distribution Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dyinda Pty Ltd ACN 009 020 526 v First Distribution Services Ltd
[2004] FCA 12

REMEDIES – interlocutory injunction – proceedings alleging misleading or deceptive conduct and breach of fiduciary duty by co-joint venturer – joint venturer entering into agreement and acquiring controlling interest from one co-joint venturer without knowledge of others – long delay in commencing proceedings – whether serious question to be tried – balance of convenience – discretionary factors – proposed acquisition of business by third party – claim for interlocutory relief dismissed – conditions attached and directions for disclosure to co-joint venturer made

Trade Practices Act 1974  (Cth) s 52
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1041H
Australian Securities and Investment Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12DA
International Companies Act 1987 (Samoa) s 16(2)

United Dominions Corporation Ltd v Brian Pty Ltd (1984) 157 CLR cited
Yunghanns v Elfic Pty Ltd (2000) 1 VR 92 cited
Brunninghausen v Glavanics (1999) 46 NSWLR 538 cited
Carr Boyd Minerals Ltd v Ashton Mining Ltd (1989) 15 ACLR 599 cited
Port Kennedy Resorts Pty Ltd & Ors  v Huat & Ors [2000] WASCA 328 cited
Hopkins Professional Services Pty Ltd v Foyster Holdings Pty Ltd (2001) 39 ACSR 519 cited
Re Medefield (1977) 2 ACLR 406 cited

DYINDA PTY LTD ACN 009 020 526, WINIAM PTY LTD ACN 009 020 277 and GILDEROY PTY LTD ACN 009 020 446 v FIRST DISTRIBUTION SERVICES LTD, BADGERUP NOMINEES PTY LTD ACN 008 821 636 and ANTHONY CARMIGNANI
W238 of 2003

FRENCH J
15 JANUARY 2004 (Publication of Reasons)
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W238 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

DYINDA PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 526
FIRST APPLICANT

WINIAM PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 277
SECOND APPLICANT

GILDEROY PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 446
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

FIRST DISTRIBUTION SERVICES LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

BADGERUP NOMINEES PTY LTD
ACN 008 821 636
SECOND RESPONDENT

ANTHONY CARMIGNANI
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 JANUARY 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The claims for interlocutory relief against the Second and Third Respondents are dismissed without prejudice to the right of the Applicants to apply to renew those claims.

2.Costs of the claims for interlocutory relief against the Second and Third Respondents are reserved.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W238 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

DYINDA PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 526
FIRST APPLICANT

WINIAM PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 277
SECOND APPLICANT

GILDEROY PTY LTD
ACN 009 020 446
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

FIRST DISTRIBUTION SERVICES LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

BADGERUP NOMINEES PTY LTD
ACN 008 821 636
SECOND RESPONDENT

ANTHONY CARMIGNANI
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 JANUARY 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Upon the representatives of the First Respondent on the board of T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd, namely David Brian Argyle, Gavin John Argyle and David Anthony…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dyinda Pty Ltd ACN 009 020 526 v First Distribution Services... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dyinda Pty Ltd, Winiam Pty Ltd and Gilderoy Pty Ltd (the applicants) brought an action against First Distribution Services Ltd (FDS), Badgerup Pty Ltd and Anthony Carmignani (the respondents) seeking interlocutory relief in the form of an injunction and declarations. The applicants sought to restrain the respondents from entering into an agreement that they claimed was inconsistent with an alleged oral agreement, and to have the oral agreement specifically enforced. The applicants also sought damages for breach of fiduciary duty, negligence and for misleading and deceptive conduct. The applicants sought to restrain the respondents from entering into an agreement for the acquisition by FDS of the Badgerup interest in the Aveve Unit Trust and the land and the Share. They sought declarations that FDS had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and had breached a fiduciary duty to them arising out of what was in substance a joint venture. The applicants argued that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interlocutory relief and that the delay in bringing proceedings did not militate against the grant of relief.

The court found that there was a serious question to be tried and that it was reasonably arguable that FDS had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct or had breached a fiduciary duty. However, the court found that the balance of convenience did not favour the grant of interlocutory relief and that the delay in bringing proceedings militated against the grant of relief. The court dismissed the claims for interlocutory relief against FDS, Badgerup and Mr Carmignani but made an order that the representatives of FDS on the board of TCC Holdings Pty Ltd provide the applicants with copies of the terms of the offer made by FDS and any counter-offer or independent expert opinion obtained by FDS. The court also reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The claims for interlocutory relief against the Second and Third Respondents are dismissed without prejudice to the right of the Applicants to apply to renew those claims.

2. Costs of the claims for interlocutory relief against the Second and Third Respondents are reserved.

Note:

1. Upon the representatives of the First Respondent on the board of T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd, namely David Brian Argyle, Gavin John Argyle and David Anthony Argyle, undertaking, in a form acceptable to the Court, not to permit T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd to enter into an agreement pursuant to the offer in confidential exhibit DBA22 unless it is expressed to be conditional upon the obtaining of an independent expert opinion that the proposed consideration is fair and reasonable, the claim for interlocutory relief is dismissed.

2. The said representatives of the First Respondent on the board of T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd are to provide Salvatore Iannello, Silvino Cinalli and Anthony Iannello with a copy of the confidential exhibit DBA22 forthwith and any counter-offer made by T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd at the time that it is made and a copy of any independent expert opinion obtained by T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd pursuant to the undertaking, as soon as practicable after it is received by T.C.C.Holdings Pty Ltd.

3. The provision of the documents to the persons mentioned in the preceding order is to be upon the basis that they treat these documents as confidential and not disclose them to any other person except for the purpose of obtaining legal or accounting advice and then only upon the basis that the persons from whom such advice is sought undertake to treat the information so disclosed as confidential and not disclose it to any other person.

4. Costs of the claim for interlocutory relief as between the Applicants and the First Respondent are reserved.

5. There be liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

The questions raised on the claim for interlocutory relief are whether there is a serious question to be tried, where the balance of convenience lies and whether, in any event, in the exercise of its discretion, the Court should decline to grant relief. In the circumstances I have come to the view that although there are arguable questions to be tried between the applicants and FDS, the balance of convenience is not strongly in favour of the applicants and their delay in bringing proceedings militates against the grant of interlocutory relief as a matter of discretion. For those reasons I have decided to dismiss the claim for interlocutory relief subject to an undertaking offered by FDS and certain directions to FDS to make disclosure to the applicants of the terms of the offer which has been made. Factual Background The following factual background is based upon affidavit material filed in connection with the claim for interlocutory relief. Not all of that material would be admissible at the trial of the action. Some of it is contested. To the extent that findings of fact are made at this stage of the proceedings, they are provisional and for the purposes of the claim for interlocutory relief only. Total Corrosion Control Pty Ltd (TCC) carries on the business of sand and grit blasting and painting heavy industrial equipment and plant, erection of scaffolding in relation to such plant and applying rubber linings and other surface treatments. It has been in operation since 1982. Initially TCC carried on the business as trustee of the Aveve Unit Trust constituted by a Deed of Trust dated 25 March 1982. The precise distribution of units across unit holders at that time is not clear from the papers. However, from 6 February 1986 the unit holders under the Trust comprised two groups, one an operating group (the Operators) which provided personnel for the conduct of the business and the other a group of ‘passive investors’. The Operators comprised the three applicants and the second respondent. Dyinda Pty Ltd, the first applicant, was controlled by Sam Cinalli and his wife. Winiam Pty Ltd, the second applicant, was controlled by Anthony Iannello and his wife. Gilderoy Pty Ltd, the third applicant, was controlled by Terry Iannello and his wife; and Badgerup, which is the second respondent, was controlled by Anthony Carmignani. The passive investors, so called, were four companies associated with the steel fabrication business of United Construction Pty Ltd. They were Bontempo Nominees Pty Ltd, Giovani Nominees Pty Ltd, Trettel Nominees Pty Ltd and Santino Nominees Pty Ltd. By their participation as unit holders in the Aveve Unit Trust and so, indirectly in the business of TCC, they obtained the advantage of an interest in the grit blasting and painting side of the industries which were activities in which United Construction had never actively been involved. They built facilities at Office Road, Kwinana, title to which was divided into shares held by the unit holders in the same proportion as their holdings. The business of TCC was carried on from those premises and is still carried on there today. The cost of construction of the premises was paid for by TCC performing works for United Construction. The contribution by the Operators was said to be to put up the money to get the business running and to supply personnel to operate it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicants argue that damages will be no adequate compensation for loss of control. They also contend that the location of FDS’s incorporation is unclear. In the event, this was resolved by an exhibit to the affidavit of David Argyle sworn 12 January 2004 showing that FDS is registered in Samoa as a redomiciled company pursuant to the provisions of s 16(2) of the International Companies Act 1987 (Samoa). Evidence for FDS There is a factual dispute raised on the evidence through the affidavit of David Brian Argyle sworn 12 January 2004 and filed on behalf of FDS. In particular he referred to Anthony Iannello’s contention that a meeting took place at which his sons, David Anthony Argyle and Gavin Argyle congratulated Sam Cinalli on the agreement that they had made with Mr Carmignani and expressed the sentiment that it was a ‘deal well done’. David Brian Argyle said he was informed by Gavin Argyle and believed that this did not take place and that the primary purpose of the meeting was the discussion of other unrelated business. Anthony Iannello had made a passing reference to an arrangement with Mr Carmignani but did not discuss any terms. Neither of his sons had consented to or objected to the arrangement. Mr Argyle Snr denied that FDS concurred with any agreement with Mr Carmignani. In particular it did not agree to the transfer of the Holden Calais. He said he was also informed by Gavin Argyle and believed that he could not recall any conversation with Anthony Iannello or Terry Iannello in terms deposed to in par 22 of Anthony Iannello’s affidavit. That paragraph of Anthony Iannello’s affidavit referred to the telephone conversation which he claimed to have had with Gavin Argyle and David Argyle shortly after 16 May 2001 about the agreement with Mr Carmignani. Mr Argyle Snr said it was only after the agreement of 16 May 2001 was entered into that he was informed of its existence. At no stage was he informed of, nor did he participate in, any negotiations with Mr Carmignani which may have led to the agreement. Neither of his sons was present at any board meeting of TCC on 23 May 2001. They informed him and he believed that it was only after the agreement was entered into that they were informed of its existence and, like him, they had not been informed of, or participated in, any negotiations with Mr Carmignani which may have led to the alleged agreement. He said that, on or about 29 November 2001, FDS had entered into binding Heads of Agreement with Badgerup and Mr Carmignani. At the time of execution of the agreement a deposit of $100,000 was paid to Badgerup. A further $50,000 was paid subsequently. At the time the agreement was executed Mr Carmignani was paid $1 for his share in the capital of Holdings. The Heads of Agreement has been lodged for assessment of stamp duty and it has been assessed. The stamp duty has not yet been paid as it is not due until 5 February 2004. There was an objection to the assessment in respect of the transaction. That has been resolved. On 30 November 2001 and pursuant to their powers under the constitution of Holdings, FDS and Mr Carmignani being collectively the registered owners of all the shares in Holdings, appointed Gavin John Argyle, David Anthony Argyle and David Brian Argyle as directors of Holdings. The only other directors at that time were Sam Cinalli and Terry Iannello. At the same time Badgerup issued a transfer notice under the Aveve Unit Trust Deed giving notice to Holdings that it desired to transfer the eight units it held in trust for $12,500 per unit. A copy of the transfer notice was exhibited to Mr Argyle’s affidavit. A share transfer form was executed on 3 December 2001 between Mr Carmignani and FDS to transfer Mr Carmignani’s share in Holdings to FDS. That form was stamped on 25 January 2002.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
Anthony Iannello said that he relied on the fact that the applicants’ ownership position as unit holders in the Aveve Unit Trust had been strengthened by the agreement with Mr Carmignani to decide to cause his company Winiam Pty Ltd to advance in June 2001 a further $100,000 to TCC for use by it as working capital. Similar amounts were advanced at that time by the two other applicants. He says that the applicants now find that, because of the agreement secretly entered into behind their backs by the respondents for the acquisition by FDS of the Badgerup interest in the Aveve Unit Trust and the land and the Share, the applicants are in a materially worse position than they would otherwise be in. Conclusions In my opinion, on the applicants’ evidence, taken at its highest, a serious question may arise that FDS has engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct. Alternatively, it is reasonably arguable, on the applicants’ case, that FDS has breached a fiduciary duty to them arising out of what was in substance a joint venture. I emphasise that in so saying I am taking the applicants’ case at its highest and assuming in their favour facts which are disputed by FDS. Notwithstanding that view, I am not prepared to grant the relief sought. I am not satisfied that the balance of convenience favours the grant of interlocutory relief. Moreover the delay that has ensued since the applicants became aware of the essential elements of the arrangements of which they now complain, militates against the grant of relief. There has evidently been a serious breakdown in relations between the applicants and FDS. The parties seem to have been stalemated for over two years. The interest which the applicants seek to protect is, at best on their view, an equal interest in a joint venture with FDS. The oral agreement for which they seek specific performance as against Badgerup and Mr Carmignani seems unlikely to proceed. Assuming that it is arguable that the agreement was part performed by the transfer to Mr Carmignani of a Holden Calais motor vehicle, discretionary considerations would affect the grant of specific performance not least, in this case, the lapse of time that has occurred since the agreement was made. As was pointed out in the submissions for FDS the applicants knew: (a)on or about 3 December 2001 that Mr Carmignani had on 30 November 2001 voted his share in Holdings to appoint the Argyles as directors of Holdings; (b)on or about 3 December 2001 that Badgerup, on 30 November 2001, had served a transfer notice on Holdings; (c)on or about 4 December 2001 that: (i)Mr Carmignani transferred his share in Holdings to FDS; (ii)FDS intended to cause Holdings to appoint David Argyle and Ron Gajewski as additional directors of TCC; and (iii)FDS intended to cause Holdings to offer at least four units in the Aveve Unit Trust formally held by Badgerup to FDS.FDS submits that by virtue of these matters the applicants knew or ought reasonably to have known of the existence of some agreement fundamentally inconsistent with the alleged oral agreement and yet took no steps to enforce the alleged oral agreement until the commencement of this action some two years later. As to the balance of convenience, it is said that the applicants are seeking to restrain the entering into of a transaction at a time when they are not in a position to assess whether as unit holders in the Aveve Unit Trust the transaction is in their best interests. Only when a valuation report is obtained will they be in a position to make that assessment. Accordingly, the application is said to have been brought without consideration of the impact of the proposed transaction upon the applicants. The applicants cannot show any harm that will be done to them as a result of the proposed transaction. On the other hand, if the injunction succeeds Holdings would lose the opportunity of accepting an offer for the acquisition of TCC.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

The court considered the evidence and arguments presented by the parties, including the applicants' claims of misleading or deceptive conduct and breach of fiduciary duty by FDS. The court acknowledged that on the applicants' evidence, taken at its highest, there may be a serious question to be tried. However, the court was not satisfied that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interlocutory relief. The applicants had not shown any harm that would be done to them as a result of the proposed transaction, and the delay in bringing proceedings was a significant factor. The court also noted that there had been a serious breakdown in relations between the applicants and FDS, and the applicants had not taken steps to enforce the alleged oral agreement until the commencement of this action.

The court exercised its discretion not to grant interlocutory relief, but it did so subject to certain undertakings and directions to FDS. The court required FDS to provide the applicants with copies of certain documents and to undertake not to permit T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd to enter into an agreement pursuant to a particular offer unless it was expressed to be conditional upon the obtaining of an independent expert opinion that the proposed consideration was fair and reasonable. The court also required FDS to provide the applicants with any counter-offer made by T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd and any independent expert opinion obtained by T.C.C. Holdings Pty Ltd.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the principles of equity, the balance of convenience, and the discretionary factors relevant to the grant of interlocutory relief. The court also took into account the applicants' delay in bringing proceedings and the breakdown in relations between the parties. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the court will not grant interlocutory relief where there is a serious question to be tried, but the balance of convenience does not strongly favour the applicant and the delay in bringing proceedings militates against the grant of relief, subject to certain undertakings and directions being given.

The court distinguished the current case from prior authority on the basis that the applicants had not shown any harm that would be done to them as a result of the proposed transaction, and the delay in bringing proceedings was a significant factor. The court also departed from prior authority in so far as it exercised its discretion not to grant interlocutory relief subject to certain undertakings and directions being given.