DXVN and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

DXVN and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2018] AATA 2152 (9 July 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

Re:DXVN

APPLICANT

AndTelstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:9 July 2018

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review

................................. [SGD].......................................

Deputy President J Sosso

Catchwords

Workers’ compensation – whether the Applicant suffers a condition outside the boundaries of normal mental functioning and behaviour – when condition arose – whether aggravation of condition contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment - reasonable administrative action in a reasonable way - counselling action – s 14 Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14.

Cases

Dean v Australian Postal Corporation [2010] FCA 680; 52 AAR 54
Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439
Quick and Comcare [2010] AATA 209
Telstra Corporation v Hunter [2016] FCA 318

Wiegand v Comcare [2002] FCA 1464; 72  ALD 795

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

9 July 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. DXVN (“the Applicant”) seeks a review of a decision of Telstra Corporation Limited (“Telstra”) dated 31 October 2016 (Exhibit 1 T38 pp. 225 – 231) which affirmed a Determination of 12 July 2016 (Exhibit 1 T23 pp. 116 – 123), denying any liability of Telstra to pay the Applicant compensation under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“the Act”) in respect of anxiety, depression and stress.

  2. This matter principally concerns events that occurred on 19 March 2016, at the Capalaba Telstra store (“the incident”). Much of the evidence relates to some unhappy interpersonal relationships at the store that led up to the incident, and, in particular, alleged bullying and homophobic behaviour that the Applicant claims he was subjected to. There is a key divergence in the factual accounts of what happened during the incident, with one account suggesting the Store Leader, Ms E, was overly aggressive, and on the other hand, a suggestion that the Applicant engaged in inappropriate and insubordinate behaviour from start to finish.  In resolving these differences, it is necessary to set out at some length the events that transpired and to provide, as far as is practicable, the various versions of events so that the ultimate resolution can be properly understood.

  3. There are two other matters that also need to be mentioned. The first is that there was video footage of the incident. Unfortunately, the video footage was destroyed and all that remains is a very short clip, which is a few seconds in duration. It provides little help to the Tribunal. The circumstances surrounding the destruction of the video footage, and the inferences that could be drawn, were the subject of considerable debate.

  4. The second, is that there were two different processes unfolding after the incident. The first was an internal Telstra investigation and the second was a workers’ compensation review. Both should have operated independently of each other. I note that there were emails between Ms D (who conducted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DXVN and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 2152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for compensation by DXVN against Telstra Corporation Limited. The applicant sought compensation for a psychological condition, alleging it was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment with Telstra. The dispute centred on whether the applicant's condition constituted an "ailment" as defined by the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth), and if so, whether it arose from reasonable administrative action taken by Telstra in a reasonable manner.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain whether the applicant suffered from a condition that fell within the boundaries of "ailment" as defined by section 4(1) of the Act, which includes any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect, or morbid condition. Secondly, the court had to consider when this condition arose and whether the applicant's employment with Telstra contributed to it to a significant degree. Crucially, the court also had to assess whether any actions taken by Telstra, such as the denial of breaks or reduction of shifts, constituted reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable way, which would exclude compensation under the Act.

In its reasoning, the court considered the medical evidence, particularly reports from Dr. Varghese, which indicated the applicant suffered from Recurrent Major Depression, with a history of mental health issues predating his employment with Telstra. While acknowledging the applicant may have experienced some stress at work and potentially a degree of dysthymia, the evidence did not establish a major depressive episode arising during his employment. Furthermore, the court found that even if the applicant's claimed condition was aggravated by certain incidents, such aggravation stemmed from reasonable administrative actions. Specifically, the scheduling of breaks and the reduction of casual shifts were deemed reasonable responses to business requirements and budget restraints, undertaken in a reasonable manner by Telstra.

Ultimately, the court found that the applicant's claimed condition, to the extent it was linked to employment, fell within the exclusionary provisions of the Act concerning reasonable administrative action. Therefore, the application for compensation was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant was self-represented, and the conduct of the hearing was, at times, very difficult. The Applicant has a number of health issues, both physical and emotional, and by the second day of the hearing, the stress caused by the proceedings resulted in him unilaterally leaving the hearing room. Eventually he was able to return and the matter proceeded to its conclusion. The Tribunal endeavoured to ensure that the Applicant was not disadvantaged, and was satisfied that despite some difficulties, he was able to present his case fairly and appropriately.BACKGROUND The Applicant was born in 1982 and at the time of the hearing was 35 years of age. He has worked in various positions, including retail outlets (e.g. Crazy Clarks), a veterinary clinic and also in the IT sector. Prior to working for Telstra, the Applicant operated his own start-up company in the IT sector – Exhibit 4 pp. 1 – 2. The Applicant was examined by Dr Frank Varghese, Consultant Psychiatrist, on 13 March 2017 – Exhibit 4. Dr Varghese noted that the Applicant suffered emotional problems in circa 2007 – 2008, manifesting in depression and loss of self-esteem. He was prescribed Lexapro in November 2008 and subsequently recovered fully – Exhibit 4 p. 8. The Applicant has been in a long-term relationship since 2009, with the exception of a 12 month separation in circa 2011. The Applicant told Dr Varghese he was “down” for about one month after the separation, but he recovered and reconciled with his partner. Dr Varghese was subsequently briefed with summonsed medical records and prepared a second report dated 25 September 2017 – Exhibit 16. The summonsed records disclose that the Applicant’s mother attended the Princess Alexandra Hospital on 24 August 2003, requesting treatment for her son. She was concerned about his behaviour and said it had been deteriorating steadily over the previous two years. His mood was low, he was “out of control” and she was very concerned about both his welfare and her own. She claimed that the Applicant was paranoid, socially withdrawn, had lost his job and friends, his self-care had declined and he was not feeding himself properly. The Applicant was said to have obsessional and delusional beliefs regarding his facial hair – Exhibit 16 p. 3. The Applicant was assessed by the Division of Mental Health on that day. The assessment disclosed that the Applicant was unable to look after himself, was totally socially withdrawn, unable to leave his flat and very paranoid. He believed people were talking and looking at him and he had deliberately driven on the wrong side of the road to avoid persons looking at him. Dr Varghese made these comments – pp. 3-4:“(COMMENT: The records indicate that [the Applicant] presented with mental health issues at the PA Hospital prior to his treatment by Dr Theodoros. The clinical picture that emerges is of a severe depression with secondary psychotic like symptoms as against a primary psychosis. It seems that [the Applicant] was not admitted under an involuntary treatment order as there are no notes of any admission. I assume he was then transferred to Dr Theodoros.)”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The remainder of the Determination focused on whether the condition arose from reasonable administration action taken by Telstra. Ms D found that, even if she had accepted that the Applicant’s claimed condition was aggravated to a significant degree by the incident, such aggravation arose from reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner by Telstra. In that regard, the following observations were made at Exhibit 1 T23 p. 120:“a. it is reasonable for your manager to schedule team breaks and I accept that [Ms E] was in a position to make that decision;b. there is no evidence to support that [Ms E] did not undertake the decision to deny you your break when requested in a reasonable manner;c. as a casual employee your rostered shifts are determined by Telstra’s demand for labour and budget allowances. It is reasonable for Telstra to reduce your shifts based business requirements and budget restraints. There was significant reduction in labour across the entire business that affected many casual employees, not just you;d. [Ms E] advised you in her text message dated 25 March 2016, and during your telephone conversation with her on 31 March 2016, that the Incident had nothing to do with the reduction in your shifts; that she made no initial change to the shifts immediately following the incident and due to labour being limited you would not receive shifts for April 2016;e. [Mr K] confirmed the advice given by [Ms E] that rostered shifts were reduced across the broader team for casual employees due to budget restraints;f. the reduction in rostered shifts has been a driving point in your belief of being treated unfairly;g. it was not until after your conversation with [Mr K] on 22 April 2016 where you raised your concerns with no rostered shifts that an Incident report was raised; you presented to Dr Zia who certified you incapacitated for work; and you lodged your claim form dated 27 April 2016;h. I accept that there is direction connection between your presentation to Dr Zia and being certified incapacitated for work and lodging your claim for compensation due to the loss of rostered shifts associated with your role as a casual employee;i. I do not accept that the reduction in your rostered shifts was due to the Incident but was entirely due to labour and budget restraints for Telstra casual employees in your business unit;j. failure to receive rostered shifts falls into the exclusionary provisions of failure to retain a benefit and failure to retain a benefit;k. I accept that your Claimed Condition falls under the exclusionary provisions of reasonable administrative action under the Act; andl. I accept [Ms E] undertook those actions in a reasonable manner.”REVIEWABLE DECISION – 31 OCTOBER 2016 On 21 September 2016, the Applicant requested a reconsideration of the Determination – Exhibit 1 T32 pp. 135 – 136. The Applicant outlined nine grounds for seeking reconsideration. One of those grounds was that “video footage in support of my claim has been withheld by Telstra Ltd.” According to the Applicant, he telephoned Ms D on 13 July 2016, requesting a copy of the video footage, but this request was declined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, “ailment” is defined in s 4(1) to mean:“any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development).”CONSIDERATIONApplicant’s Medical Condition The only medical evidence presented to the Tribunal were the medical reports of Dr Zia, two reports of Dr Varghese and his testimony. Having examined the Applicant and subsequently having the benefit of perusing all of the summonsed medical material, Dr Varghese provided this diagnosis – Exhibit 16 pp. 4 – 5:“The principal clinical issue is that [the Applicant] suffers from Recurrent Major Depression meaning that there has been more than one episode of Major Depression. The first reported presentation was in late 2003…although there is reference to problems two years prior to this with anxiety and weight loss. By 2003 the depression appears to have been quite severe as revealed by the symptomatology described with secondary dysmorphic phobia and also paranoid ideation as well as some OCD symptoms, all of which are likely to be manifestations of depression occurring in the context of personality vulnerability.[The Applicant] appears to have recovered from this episode presumably as a result of treatment by Dr Theodoros…Alternatively there has been remission in line with the natural history as Major Depression is episodic as against a chronic condition.The subsequent history is one of chronic dysthymia perhaps with periods of remission and intermittent Major Depression which has been in the mild to moderate range as against severe, presumably as a result of ongoing treatment with antidepressants (Lexapro [Escitalopram]).On the data available it seems that although [the Applicant] experienced some stress at work when he first joined Telstra there is no evidence of any Major Depression until after he ceased work with Telstra. There may have been a degree of dysthymia of varying intensity. By his account his work performance at Telstra was good. Data from his employer as to his performance in comparison to others could confirm this.It is possible that [the Applicants’] experiencing that he was discriminated against on the basis of his sexual orientation is a manifestation of social anxiety secondary to dysthymia and personality dysfunction however it seems to me that this issue is ultimately an issue of fact to be determined. If it was the case that [the Applicant] was not discriminated against as he claimed, then I would understand his experiencing discrimination as being secondary to social sensitivity in the context of depression and personality.The issue of whether he was in fact shouted at and treated unfairly by his superior in the incident of March 2016 is again an issue of fact as is the question of whether he was unfairly denied further shifts as discussed in my previous report.[The Applicant] does appear to have suffered an episode of Major Depression following his employment at Telstra as emerges from the data as described in my previous report. This Major Depression is now in remission and [the Applicant’s] current condition can be considered a dysthymic disorder which is a continuation of what was present previously.Thus overall although there is new information which confirms that the pre-existing issues go back a long way, and moreover that there are significant issues of personality, my opinion on the clinical issues has not substantially changed.”