Duzdiker v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Duzdiker v Minister For Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 390

IMMIGRATION – application for review of decision of Refugee Review Tribunal – whether Tribunal applied a mistaken meaning of “persecution” – degree of harm required to constitute persecution – course of selective harassment – whether relocation of the applicant would amount to an unreasonable denial of fundamental rights.

Migration Act 1968 (Cth), s 476(1)(e)

United National Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment 1984, Art 1(1)

Abdalla v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 51 ALD 11, applied
Applicant A v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1998) 190 CLR 225, applied
Chan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379, applied
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic (1993) 43 FCR 280, applied
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259, applied

Montes-Granados v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 60, applied

Hathaway The Law of Refugee Status 1991

ALI DUZDIKER v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
N 310 of 1999

MADGWICK J

31 MARCH 2000
SYDNEY




IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

 N 310 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

ALI DUZDIKER
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MARCH 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The parties are to pay their own costs.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 310 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

ALI DUZDIKER
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE:

31 MARCH 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:

  1. Despite the initial attractions of the comprehensive and well-considered submissions of counsel for the applicant, I have come to the conclusion that the applicant’s claim for relief in this Court must fail. 

  2. The applicant, Mr Ali Duzdiker, is a Turkish national who was born on 15 January 1964.  He arrived in Australia on 15 January 1996 and his brother, Dervis Duzdiker, arrived on 23 March 1996.  Together on 25 October 1996 they applied for protection visas.  In February 1998 a delegate of the respondent refused their applications and they sought review of these decisions before the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).  On 16 March 1999 the Tribunal refused their applications.  On 14 April 1999 they applied to this Court seeking judicial review of the Tribunal’s decisions.  The matters were heard consecutively (see Duzdiker v Minister For Immigration And Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 391).

    Factual background

  3. The applicant is an Alevi Muslim.  Alevis (or Alawis) in Turkey are a stream of Shiite Islam.  The Alevis constitute a religious minority amongst Turkish people, the majority of whom are Sunni Muslims.  They seem to constitute between 15% and 30% of the population.  The Alevis are generally under-privileged.  Approximately one third of all Alevis in Turkey are also Kurdish and, according to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duzdiker v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 390
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Duzdiker v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, Ali Duzdiker, a Turkish national and Alevi Muslim, sought judicial review of the decisions of the Refugee Review Tribunal, which had refused his and his brother's applications for protection visas. The Tribunal had found that the applicant's fear of persecution for his political and religious beliefs, if he were to return to Turkey, was not well-founded. The central legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had erred in its determination that the applicant's fear of persecution was not well-founded. The court considered whether the Tribunal had correctly applied the definition of persecution under the Refugee Convention and whether it had properly assessed the applicant's personal circumstances and the evidence before it.

The court found that the Tribunal had properly considered the evidence and applied the correct legal standards. The Tribunal had recognised that not every threat of harm or interference with a person's rights for a Convention reason constituted persecution and had assessed whether the treatment experienced by the applicant amounted to persecution of a degree sufficient to meet the Convention definition. The court noted that the Tribunal had detailed the incidents of harassment and violence the applicant had experienced, but concluded that these incidents, while regrettable, did not reach the threshold of persecution. The Tribunal had also found that the applicant could reasonably relocate within Turkey to avoid any risk of persecution, which further supported the conclusion that his fear was not well-founded. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision and dismissed the application.

The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that each party bear their own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The parties are to pay their own costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Mr Ali Duzdiker, is a Turkish national who was born on 15 January 1964. He arrived in Australia on 15 January 1996 and his brother, Dervis Duzdiker, arrived on 23 March 1996. Together on 25 October 1996 they applied for protection visas. In February 1998 a delegate of the respondent refused their applications and they sought review of these decisions before the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”). On 16 March 1999 the Tribunal refused their applications. On 14 April 1999 they applied to this Court seeking judicial review of the Tribunal’s decisions. The matters were heard consecutively (see Duzdiker v Minister For Immigration And Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 391).Factual background The applicant is an Alevi Muslim. Alevis (or Alawis) in Turkey are a stream of Shiite Islam. The Alevis constitute a religious minority amongst Turkish people, the majority of whom are Sunni Muslims. They seem to constitute between 15% and 30% of the population. The Alevis are generally under-privileged. Approximately one third of all Alevis in Turkey are also Kurdish and, according to cables issued by the Department of Foreign Affairs, Alevis are generally regarded to be “liberal in thought and practice and left leaning politically”. The applicant’s political allegiances are moderately to the left of centre. As a general rule, Alevis can practice their religion freely. However they suffer from some discrimination. On occasions they have been the targets of extremist violence, usually emanating from the resurgent Sunni extremists. For example, in Sivas in 1993, during Alevi festivities, fundamentalist Sunnis burned down a hotel in which a popular Alevi satirist was staying; some 40 Alevis were killed and 145 injured. Another sporadic threat to Alevis is that posed by some right-wing police officers who see Alevis as being sympathetic to “leftist” elements. Turkey is, of course, hardly noted for civil libertarianism generally. The applicant himself, with regard to treatment by the police, offered the view that: “we don’t attach much importance to … little beatings or detentions for about an hour”. Further he said before the Tribunal that:“Applicant:Because I’m an [Alevi] and I have left-wing opinions and because my family is also involved in the events, I am scared to go back to Turkey. I’m scare of my own safety. I can go to Turkey, I could go anywhere in Turkey and I could settle there, but nobody can give a guarantee for my safety. I want to live like a human being. For the last three years and one month, I’m in Australia and no police officer has stopped me on the street and asked for my ID. They never ask for any Ids in a pub or in a club, for which produce an ID. It’s possible that a thing like that does happen at least three times in one day.Tribunal:Just on that point, is this something which the police do to any person who’s in the street, anyone can be stopped?Applicant:Of course. Anywhere and anytime they could ask for something.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant claimed to have suffered persecution predominantly at the hands of the Turkish authorities, however, the applicant’s representative before the Tribunal maintained that fundamentalist Sunni Muslims were also “capable of being agents of persecution”. The applicant asserted that he had been physically harassed and assaulted by the authorities because of his religious convictions and his participation in Alevi political activities. In particular he claimed that:“(i)on 1 May 1984 while living in Antakya, he attended a May day celebration and afterwards he was arrested by the police, beaten, psychologically abused and questioned about his involvement in the demonstration;(ii)as a result of this incident he was further harassed and eventually moved from Antakya to Istanbul in September 1985;(iii)in Istanbul he continued to support Alevi organisations attending cultural events and participating in gatherings. He was harassed by the police;(iv)he continued to attend May day celebrations and although never formally ‘arrested’ he was often detained by the police and beaten following his attendance;(v)he was held up by the police and beaten after attending a ‘left wing’ concert in 1994 in Istanbul;(vi)he returned to Antakya in June 1995 and attended a commemoration of the ‘Sivas massacre’ which was broken up violently by police; and(vii)thereafter, he and his family were harassed which included the burning down of the family shop.” (references omitted) The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal member had the advantage of a departmental interview with the applicant. The member accepted that in 1986 the applicant had sustained a very serious beating at the hands of police in Istanbul. Her major concerns were whether the applicant’s apparently genuine fear of police persecution, for imputed political opinion and/or religion in the reasonably proximate future, was well-founded, and whether, in any case, the applicant could not reduce any chance of persecution to a remote one by relocating himself away from his home city of Antalya. The transcript confirms that she was careful to raise her major concerns with him. In the section of her reasons for decision entitled “Findings and Reasons” the Tribunal member stated the rationale for her decision. Despite its length, it is worth setting this out, almost in full:“The Tribunal has noted that not every threat of harm or interference with a person's rights for a Convention reason constitutes "being persecuted". It is a matter of degree. The independent evidence indicates that there have been occasional incidents, such as the tragic killings of Alevis at Sivas in 1993 and killings of Alevi Kurds in Istanbul in March 1995, in which Alevis are singled out for violent attack. The source of those two notorious attacks was Sunni extremists, whose attitude to Alevis is neither representative of government policies towards Alevis nor of the views of the majority of the Turkish population. Events such as that at Sivas appear to be rare, and other violent incidents are not so common that they amount to a "course of selective harassment" of Alevis as a group. In general, the evidence indicates that Alevis suffer some government-sanctioned discriminatory treatment, and that attacks on them by Sunni fundamentalists are occasional. However I am satisfied, and so find, that that treatment does not represent so serious a violation of human rights of Alevis that it amounts to persecution of them as a group.The Tribunal has considered whether there may be particular circumstances in the case of the present applicant which may lead, nevertheless, to a real chance that he will be persecuted for a Convention reason if he returns to Turkey. In doing this I have taken the following into account:·I accept that Mr Duzdiker was a member of the Alevi Cultural Association in Antakya until 1985, when he left for Istanbul. He never re-joined it.·I accept that he was detained for a day by police, and beaten, on May Day in Antakya in 1984.·I accept that he was seriously beaten and injured by the police in 1986 when they attacked a Kurdish new year celebration in Instanbul, at which he was a bystander. I also find highly plausible his claim that such treatment left him very fearful of the police. Given this fear, it is also plausible that he was afraid to settle anywhere in case local police began to know and harass him.·I accept that he attended May Day marches annually from 1985 to 1994 in Istanbul, that often police detained some marchers and that he was occasionally included among them. I accept that he was detained on these occasions for up to a day and beaten. I find that it was his perceived political opinion (as politically left of centre) that motivated this treatment by right wing police.·His brother, Mr Dervis Duzdiker, claimed that police raided the family home in Antakya in 1992, but was unable to explain what prompted this raid to occur. The Applicant has not mentioned this raid in his own claims. However I accept that it occurred.·…In my view it indicates that he did not consider there was any serious police interest in him in Antakya. This interpretation is consistent with his vague responses to questions on this subject during the Tribunal hearing. It is also consistent with the fact that the police did not come to the family home looking for him, nor ever attempt to detain him, after his return to Antakya in 1995, despite having his home address and even loitering around his shop.·I accept that, after his return to Antakya, with many other Alevis in 1995 he attended a commemorative protest against the Sivas killings of 1993. Although he was not detained by the police, I consider it plausible that this demonstration may have motivated some right wing Sunni Moslems in Antakya to make threatening calls to his home, and to prompt some right wing police to behave in a threatening manner at the family shop. It is not implausible that the shop was burned down by some of these people. He claimed that other Alevis in Antakya were having similar problems in the months after the protest. That evidence suggests that the harassment, linked to a particular event, was likely to subside after a time. The evidence suggests that has occurred. His parents have returned to live in Antakya after visiting Australia, two of his brothers continue to live in Antakya, the shop which was damaged by fire has been refurbished and is now being run by one of those brothers, and Mr Duzdiker is unaware of any harassment of his parents or brothers related to their well-known connections with the Alevi Association. There is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that the Alevi Association has been closed down or that its other members are being seriously harassed for a Convention reason. Mr Dervis Duzdiker has claimed that his ex-wife is being seriously harassed by the police. However on that matter I have found that, if any such harassment is occurring, it is for non-Convention-related reasons, or reasons unrelated to the Applicant's brother, and it follows that those reasons are unrelated to the Applicant. For these reasons I am satisfied that the family is not suffering any significant detriment or disadvantage in Antakya as a result of their religion or political opinions.…Antakya policeI have found that the Applicant may have a subjective fear of persecution because of his experiences with the police in 1986, but must consider whether his fear is well-founded. That requires an assessment of the other evidence. I have accepted that the harassment of the Applicant in 1995 in Antakya was prompted by increased tensions after the commemoration of the 1993 deaths of Alevis in Sivas, and that local right wingers, both police and others, may have been responsible for the harassment of many Alevis in Antakya at that time. I have also found that these tensions have subsided. Noting his claims that his family members are all known locally as left wing Alevis, (that is, they are longstanding members of the Alevi Association and often attend May Day marches) I consider it significant that, according to the evidence, his parents and brothers are not suffering any form of significant detriment or disadvantage in Antakya. The reasons why the police may have questioned his father on two occasions about the Applicant's current activities are unclear. The Applicant has done nothing that would lead the police in Antakya to treat him more harshly than other family members. In fact so far as they are aware he has done less. As far as they know, twenty years ago he supported a centre-left political party (which was legalised in 1992 and now holds the balance of power in the Turkish parliament); he has not attended a May Day celebration for fifteen years; he was a member of the Alevi Association in Antakya until 1985; he was not heard from for ten years; and in 1995 he attended a Sivas commemoration ceremony. If anything, he is less likely than the brothers who remain in Antakya to be targeted by right wing police. He has not claimed they are being so targeted. For these reasons the Tribunal considers that the chance of the Applicant's being detained or harmed to a degree amounting to persecution if he returns to Antakya is remote. Nevertheless, given his subjective fear of harm there, I have considered whether he could relocate within Turkey.Relocation within Turkey:…From 1985 to 1994 Mr Duzdiker moved from place to place around Istanbul to avoid the police, who he feared would target him if he settled down. I am not satisfied that, if he had settled down, he would have been the target of harassment serious enough to amount to persecution. During his last eight years in Istanbul, right wing police briefly detained and beat up at random individuals leaving "left wing" theatre performances, including Mr Duzdiker from time to time, but they released him after a few hours, showed no further interest in him, and never bothered to contact Antakya police about him. Those periods of detention, unjust as they were, were not so serious that they amounted, even cumulatively, to persecution. They were occasional and brief. I accept that, if Mr Duzdiker were to live in Istanbul or elsewhere, it is plausible that this is the type of treatment he may face from time to time if he attends similar cultural events. However, the ability to attend such performances is not so central to his political or religious beliefs that it would be a denial of a fundamental right if he could not attend them. There are legal Alevi organisations which he could join, and he could also join the political party of his choice. If he does so, in my view the chance of his being detained and harmed, to a persecutory degree, for a Convention reason is remote.Mr Duzdiker left Turkey from the airport in Istanbul in 1996 without being questioned or stopped. He used a passport in his own name. The evidence from DFAT is that security measures at that airport allow the authorities to identify individuals who are wanted by the police. He does not claim to have paid bribes to airport officials, and his ability to openly leave the country is, in my view, a further indication of the Turkish authorities' lack of interest in detaining him in 1996.For the following reasons I find that it would not be unreasonable to expect the Applicant to relocate within Turkey if he wished to do so:·There are large Alevi communities in other parts of the country in which he could settle.·He lived in and around Istanbul for ten years, where he was able to work and live. His only contact with the police was occasional and occurred by chance.·The chance that he will be persecuted because he is an Alevi, if he does not live in Antakya, is remote. Even if there were to be one of the occasional outbreaks of violence by Sunni right-wingers against Alevis, the chance is remote that the Applicant will find himself a victim of it.·The Applicant has provided no convincing argument as to why he could not resettle elsewhere.·The Applicant's past history with Antakya police is not known to the authorities outside Antakya. His own evidence is that the police do not contact their counterparts in the person's home town unless the matter is "serious". The evidence does not indicate that The Applicant plans to become involved in any activity sufficiently serious to prompt the Turkish police to contact Antakya police. ·The Applicant does not claim to hold strong political views, nor does the evidence suggest that he does. In his final two years in Turkey he was involved in no political activities of any kind. He never joined the CHP (the party with which he sympathised during the 1980s), despite the evidence, which he did not dispute, that it is legal and that its members are not harassed. At the hearing he stated that he would join this party if he could. The evidence suggests that, if he wished to express his political opinion, he could do so by joining that party, and the chance would be remote that he would face persecutory treatment for doing so.For the above reasons the Tribunal finds it would not be unreasonable for the Applicant to relocate within Turkey, and that his fear of Convention-related persecution in that country is not well-founded.”The meaning of ‘persecution’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established