Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Having conceded the question of procedural unfairness, it was submitted on behalf of the first respondent that any denial of procedural fairness was not material because, even if procedural fairness had been afforded to the applicant in respect of the ICTOL letter, that could not realistically have resulted in the Tribunal arriving at a different decision. [6] It was submitted on behalf of the applicant that because the ITOCL did not address questions of Tamil ethnicity imputed political opinion, the Tribunal had erred by failing to put those matters to the applicant during the hearing. However, at [45] of its reasons, the Tribunal implicitly found that the applicant would be of no interest to the Karuna Group or the Sri Lankan authorities by reason of her being a Tamil. The Tribunal also found that the applicant had no reason to fear persecution on the basis of any imputed political opinion. It made such findings after it had actively intellectually engaged with the issues before it, and its findings were based upon all of the evidence before it, as found in its reasons at [30] – [46] inclusive as follows: [6] Minister for Immigration and Board of Protection v SZMTA (2019) 264 CLR 421 [45/46]“The applicant’s evidence[30]The applicant relies upon her statement dated 5 June 2017, composed following the decision to cancel her visa. This statement is largely consistent with the submissions made on her behalf to the Department, as narrated in paragraph 23, although with more detail. She maintains that, on the occasion of her husband’s disappearance in October 2008, she conducted a search for him with a male relative, during which she learned from neighbours that she was being sought by two men in uniform. She claims that over the next few days, she received menacing calls and information as to where her husband was being held. She claims that threats made in these calls escalated to the point where she left her children with her parents and travelled to Malaysia.[31]The applicant claims that, just before she left, she locked the house and shop that had been the marital home. While she was away, her mother maintained and organised repairs for the house is required. She claims that her mother neither sought nor heard from the husband. In 2010, her parents arranged for the house to be leased. At some time not known to her, she says that her husband’s sister demanded that the tenants leave and then moved into the property with her family. The applicant says that, during this period, her sons lived with her parents and never visited the marital home on any occasion and did not see their father at any time. On her return from Sri Lanka, she says, she lived with her parents and sons at her parents’ house and never visited her former marital home.[32]While in Malaysia, a person by the name of [name omitted], a friend of her husband’s, arranged for her to work in an orphanage for approximately two years. [name omitted] had also made her Visa and travel arrangements.[33]December 2011. She provides some details about the as processed, having returned without a passport. She provided her parents address and telephone number to the authorities (she says that she was interviewed by the CID at the airport). She then relates some four or five incidents of being interrogated by the CID, which she says involved physical mistreatment and threat of imprisonment and torture. She was accused of raising money for the LTTE. She says she then moved to Kandy to stay with distant relatives of her husband (who she says had had no contact with him either). After three weeks, she moved to Hatton and then to Colombo while her father made arrangements to take her youngest son with her to India.[34]The applicant flew with her youngest son from Katunayake to Trichy on [date omitted], where she stayed for 15 days. During this time, she met a person by the name of [name omitted] who made arrangements for her to board a vessel at Cochin. She arrived in Australia on 12 May 2012.[35]The applicant then provides some details relating to her relationship with a person by the name of Lavan while she was living in Brisbane. Lavan’s brother-in-law is Para, who not only arranged for her travel to Australia but also travelled on the same vessel. It should also be noted that the applicant knew Lavan from Sri Lanka, he having been a delivery driver for their shop. It appears that Lavan and her husband were friends or drinking companions. She also attended his wedding in 2007 or 2008. Shortly before the wedding, Lavan stopped his delivery service and took up a new job driving for an NGO in the Trincomalee district. She says that the acrimonious nature of her breakup with Lavan led to disclosures to the Department.[36]The applicant claims that the first time she became aware that her husband was still alive was when she heard from her sons in Sri Lanka that they had met him in Trincomalee whilst shopping in 2014. She says she had had no contact with him at all after 2008. She claims that she was a genuine asylum seeker when she came to Australia and that she had no understanding that her husband was not, in fact, missing. She claims that she had never heard from her family that he had been seen anywhere before the chance meeting with their sons. She says that her mother informed her that she was managing the marital house and that, on all of her visits, she had never seen the husband there. She says that since the date when she locked the marital house and left, and throughout her time in Malaysia, Sri Lanka, India and Australia, her two elder sons have always lived with her parents and have never lived anywhere else and, specifically, never with their father.[37]A statement was submitted from Mr John Campbell Walker dated 17 August 2017. In addition to some details concerning his knowledge of the relationship between the applicant and Lavan, he states: On or about 9 August 2014 [the applicant] called on my wife and I had our residents and informed us that she had received a phone call from another son of hers who are still living in Sri Lanka in which he informed [the applicant]’s that his father, her husband, had returned “home”. He reported to her and she to us that his father had said to him, “I need money. I hear your mother is in Australia. Will she help me. ”I asked [the applicant] if she was going to bring him to Australia. She replied in the negative, saying, “he is a bad person”. [The applicant] asked me if she should inform immigration and I told her I could see no point in doing so as her husband was still a fugitive. Not long after this she informed us that she had learned of his death.[38]It is the applicant’s case that the specific answers she provided in her statutory declaration of 20 June 2012 were true. She maintains that her husband was indeed missing and, to the best of her knowledge at the time, had been abducted. She claims that, at all material times, until about August 2014 there was no reason for her to believe anything other than what she has described in her statutory declaration of 2012. She maintains that, notwithstanding his reappearance and subsequent death, she has well-founded reasons to fear returning to Sri Lanka. Those reasons are substantially those claimed in her statutory declaration of 20 June 2012, including that of being a female Tamil without male protection.[39]At the hearing, the applicant gave evidence that she and her husband were married in 1995 and have three sons, born in 1996, 1999 and 2002. When she left Sri Lanka to come to Australia, she left the two older boys, then aged 15 and 12, with her parents. She said she has been in touch with them constantly since leaving Sri Lanka. As noted in paragraph 36, it was not until 2014 that her sons had any contact with their father. With the post-hearing submission, the applicant supplied a statement from her son [name omitted], now living in France. That statement says:My mother, [name omitted] has been living in Australia since 2012. She managed to get a regularisation in this country with a residence permit. However, because of jealousy and out of revenge, my father and his close friend who lives in Australia are trying to have her administrative papers cancelled. For this, they sent to your immigration service some fake documents about my mother. I learned this from my mother. I know very well that these documents are all falsified.Some time ago, they also sent me by Messenger to me and my girlfriend fake photos that showed my mom naked, hoping it would make me discussed from my mother. But that did not work because I did not give in my mother and I always supported my mother. In 2008, my father suddenly disappeared. After that I grew up under the responsibility and protection of my grandmother. My mother had gone to a foreign country. As I was very small, I did not really understand what was going on around me.From early 2008 until 2014, I never met my father. This is the absolute truth. I met him however by chance in 2014 in Trincomalee. I was very surprised by this meeting. I immediately informed my mother of the meeting that day. I also told her about the content of my conversation with my father. Even after that, my father never came to live with me! In addition, he is not at all interested in this idea. My father has never been a good father to me. I hate him![40]There is nothing in this statement that corroborates a belief or suspicion that the husband had been abducted or had absented himself from the family against his own will. The statement and the sentiments expressed in it are consistent with the bitterness associated with an ordinary case of paternal abandonment.[41]The applicant’s statutory declaration in 2012 gives her last address in Sri Lanka as [place omitted], the marital home. This would be consistent with her original claims to have been desperately seeking her husband, believing him to have been abducted. It is not possible to square that representation with her subsequent claims to have locked up and left the marital home in 2008, her mother having leased the property to unrelated tenants in 2010 and her sister-in-law to have evicted those tenants and moved in herself and her family. All of the documents provided by her as to the domestic arrangements in Sri Lanka with her parents at [place omitted]. Her later statements have her living at her parent’s address in 2011 and 2012.[42]A further problem arises from her account of being interrogated by the authorities on her return from Malaysia in 2011. In her 2012 statutory declaration (see paragraph 13 above), she claims that on her return to Sri Lanka she was questioned on four occasions, including about her husband’s disappearance. However, her husband was not missing in December 2011, as attested by the medical records disclosed to the Department. Her later statements contain an account in which she is repeatedly questioned, but in relation to supposed fund raising for the LTTE and there is no mention of questioning about the missing husband. [43]However, the most important difficulty with her later version of events lies in the implausibility of any news reaching her by any means that her husband was not in fact missing, and certainly not by late 2011 when she had returned to Sri Lanka. She claimed that the marital home, abandoned and locked up by her in 2008, had been let out by her parents but that her sister-in-law had evicted those tenants. It was not at all clear how her parents had any legal claim on the property because the home had been built on her sister-in-law’s land. When questioned, the applicant claimed that her sister-in-law had objected when the applicant’s parents organised tenants for the property and the matter was then dropped. This softened account seems calculated to minimise the opportunity for any communications that may have confirmed the presence of the husband. She claims not to have visited the marital home at all between 2008 and 2012. She has provided no evidence concerning any assistance that her sister-in-law might have been able to give her to locate her husband and her evidence is silent as to any communications whatever with her husband’s family after leaving the marital home. This is consistent with a marital breakdown and quite inconsistent with an abduction which would have had effect on the wider family. No evidence which might corroborate her version of events (for example, from her former in-laws or her Sri Lankan friends, some of whom are, or have been, resident in Australia) has been provided.[44]A very significant proportion of the applicant’s written evidence before the Tribunal concerns her relationship with Lavan and the events surrounding the breakdown of the relationship. The clear purpose of this evidence is to invite the Tribunal to find that the disclosure of information concerning her husband was motivated by spite or revenge. However, the only material to which I need to have regard is the unrefuted documentary material that her husband had not disappeared. He was almost certainly, on the evidence, living in the marital home when the applicant returned from Malaysia and well before the applicant departed for Australia.[45]On the evidence before the Tribunal and having careful regard to the applicant’s explanation as to the circumstances in which her 2012 statement was made, I am satisfied that her husband was never abducted and that, to the extent that the applicant and the husband may have been incommunicado, she did not believe him to be missing by December 2011 at the latest. I am further satisfied that neither she nor husband was of interest to the Karuna Group or the Sri Lankan authorities and that she has no reason to fear persecution for any imputed political opinion.[46]For these reasons, the Tribunal finds that there was non-compliance with s.101 by the applicant in the way described in the s.107 notice.”