Durham v Collins No. Scgrg-98-1651 Judgment No. S163

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

DURHAM v COLLINS
[1999] SASC 163

Magistrates Appeal

Debelle J

  1. This is an appeal from orders made by a magistrate in respect of a claim for damages for assault.  The magistrate found that the assault had occurred.  He dismissed a counterclaim by the defendant for an alleged assault by the plaintiff.  The magistrate assessed the plaintiff's damages in the sum of $1000 plus $175 interest.  The magistrate ordered that the plaintiff and defendant each bear his own costs of the action.  The plaintiff appeals against the assessment of damages and the order for costs. 

  2. This action arises out of an unfortunate altercation between three men at the greyhound racing club at Mount Gambier on Saturday, 1 February 1997.  It is convenient to refer to the parties by their surnames.  The plaintiff Durham was involved in an altercation with the defendants Patzel and Collins.  Durham instituted this action against both Patzel and Collins, claiming damages for assault. Collins made a counterclaim for damages against Durham. The magistrate dismissed Durham's claim against Patzel and ordered Durham to pay Patzell's costs.  The magistrate upheld Durham's claim against Collins and dismissed the counterclaim by Collins. 

  3. The following summary of the facts is based upon the findings of fact made by the magistrate.  As a result of an incident which occurred inside the clubhouse, Durham, Patzel and Collins had gone outside the clubhouse building.  They argued with one another, Durham on the one side and Patzel and Collins on the other.  In the course of the argument, Collins forcefully shoved Durham in the chest causing him to fall to the ground.  When he fell to the ground, Durham landed on his buttocks and then his right elbow and right shoulder and, ultimately, his head hit the ground. 

  4. On the evening of the incident, Durham went to the Mount Gambier Hospital for some minor treatment.  He was then complaining of a severe headache and pain in his neck and right shoulder.  On the following Monday he consulted Dr Kiefer, his general practitioner.  Dr Kiefer examined Durham.  He saw that he was suffering from an acute muscular spasm.  He believed that it was a recent injury which was not related to a longstanding condition from which Durham suffers. Durham is an invalid pensioner. He receives the pension in respect of a longstanding disability to his back and neck.  The condition has been described as chronic. 

  5. Dr Kiefer prescribed some Panadeine to relieve the pain.  He also injected local anaesthetic into the muscles which produced significant relief of pain within about five to ten minutes.  Durham again consulted Dr Kiefer on 7 February, stating that he was still experiencing pain.  He described the pain as being higher in his neck and radiating into the back of his head in a way different from the earlier pain. It is Dr Kiefer's view that this pain was related to the injury suffered on 1 February and he relieved it by the administration of an occipital nerve block.  He recommended that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Durham v Collins No. Scgrg-98-1651 Judgment No. S163 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Durham v Collins, the South Australian Supreme Court heard an appeal from a decision made by a magistrate regarding a claim for damages resulting from an assault. The plaintiff, Durham, initiated the action against two defendants, Patzel and Collins, for damages related to an altercation at a greyhound racing club. The magistrate dismissed Durham's claim against Patzel and ordered Durham to pay Patzel's costs. However, the magistrate upheld Durham's claim against Collins and dismissed Collins' counterclaim. The plaintiff appealed against the assessment of damages and the order for costs.

The central legal issue was whether the injuries sustained in the assault continued to cause symptoms that Durham complained about after a subsequent motor vehicle accident. The magistrate had found it impossible to distinguish the symptoms arising from the assault from those caused by the initial chronic back condition and the subsequent motor vehicle accident. The court found that the magistrate's conclusion overlooked Dr Kiefer's evidence that it was possible for the injuries from the accident to have a different cause from the chronic back condition. Furthermore, the court determined that the magistrate had erred in depriving Durham of his costs without proper grounds and without hearing the parties.

The court concluded that the assessment of damages was inadequate and increased the award to $2,000, allowing the appeal on that ground. The court also found that Durham was entitled to recover his costs, but would hear the parties to determine the footing upon which those costs should be paid. After hearing the parties, the court ordered that Collins pay $600 costs plus disbursements to Durham. Additionally, the court increased the award for interest to $200 and fixed the appellant’s profit costs at $500.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a claim for damages for assault arising from an altercation at the greyhound racing club at Mount Gambier on 1 February 1997. The plaintiff, Durham, was involved in a dispute with two defendants, Patzel and Collins. During the altercation, Collins forcefully shoved Durham in the chest, causing him to fall and hit his head. Durham sought damages for the injuries sustained from this assault. Collins counterclaimed for an alleged assault by Durham. The magistrate dismissed Durham's claim against Patzel but upheld his claim against Collins. The magistrate awarded Durham $1000 in damages plus $175 interest and ordered that each party bear their own costs. Durham appealed against the assessment of damages and the costs order.

This matter is an appeal from orders made by a magistrate in the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The magistrate had found that the assault had occurred and dismissed Collins' counterclaim. The magistrate assessed Durham's damages at $1000 and ordered each party to bear their own costs. Durham appealed against the assessment of damages and the order for costs. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the assessment of damages by the magistrate manifestly inadequate?
2. Did the magistrate err in ordering that each party bear their own costs?
3. Should the successful party be deprived of their costs and, if so, on what footing?

Held
1. The assessment of damages by the magistrate was manifestly inadequate. The appeal against the assessment of damages was allowed, and the damages were set at $2,000.
2. The magistrate erred in ordering that each party bear their own costs. The order for costs was set aside, and the successful party was entitled to recover their costs.
3. The successful party was entitled to recover their costs, but the footing upon which those costs should be paid required further determination after hearing the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal arose from the orders made by a magistrate in an action for damages for assault. The plaintiff, Durham, had been involved in an altercation with the defendants, Patzel and Collins. The magistrate found that the assault had occurred but dismissed Durham's claim against Patzel. The magistrate upheld Durham's claim against Collins and dismissed the counterclaim by Collins. The magistrate assessed Durham's damages in the sum of $1,000 plus $175 interest and ordered that each party bear their own costs. Durham appealed against the assessment of damages and the order for costs.

In addressing the assessment of damages, the court found that the magistrate had erred in concluding that it was not possible to determine whether the symptoms of the injuries caused by the assault continued to persist after the motor vehicle accident. The evidence showed that Durham had sustained an injury causing symptoms which differed from his chronic back condition and that the symptoms persisted for some time. The court found that the award of damages was inadequate and set the damages at $2,000.

Regarding the order for costs, the court found that the magistrate had erred in depriving the successful party of their costs without hearing the parties. The court held that the magistrate's discretion to deprive the successful party of their costs had to be exercised judicially and confined to grounds relating to the litigation. The court found that there were no proper grounds to deprive the successful party of their costs. However, the footing upon which those costs should be paid required further determination after hearing the parties.

The court varied the magistrate's orders by setting aside the assessment of damages and the order for costs. The court ordered that $2,000 be awarded in damages to the plaintiff, that the second defendant pay $600 costs plus disbursements to the plaintiff, and that the parties be heard on the footing upon which those costs should be paid. The court also increased the award for interest to $200 and fixed the appellant's profit costs at $500.