Dunn v Howard

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Dunn & Anor v. Howard & Anor [2001] QDC 030
PARTIES: W. H. DUNN and C. A. DUNN  Plaintiffs
And
R.T. HOWARD and C.A. HOWARD           Defendants
FILE NO/S: No. 1965 of 1998
DIVISION:
PROCEEDING:
ORIGINATING COURT: District Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON: 5 March 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 26 and 27 February 2001
JUDGE: Judge Forde

ORDER:

Judgment is given for the plaintiffs against the defendants in the sum of $7,500.00.

It is ordered that the defendants do pay the plaintiffs’costs of and incidental to the action including reserve costs, if any, to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS: Water Resources Act 1989;
Waters Act 1926;
The Rights in Water and Water Conservation and Utilisation Act 1910;
Water Authorities Act 1891;
Beames v. Leader (2000) 1 Qd. R. 346 at 357-358;
Randel v Brisbane City Council (1990) 1 Qd. R. 440 at 444-447;
Donaldson v. Hemmant (1901) 11 Q.L.J. 35;
Amstad and Anor. v Brisbane City Council and Ward (No.1) (1968) Qd. R.334;
Hansen v. Gloucester Developments Pty. Ltd (1992) 1 Qd. R.14.
Adjoining property owners – riparian rights – ambulatory boundary – significance of survey and plans as secondary guides – action for trespass – exemplary damages.
COUNSEL: Mr M. Conrick for the Plaintiffs
Mr K. Geraghty for the Defendants
SOLICITORS:

Norman & Kingston for the Plaintiffs
Richard Hoare & Co. for the Defendants

Introduction

  1. The plaintiffs in this action are W.H. Dunn & C.A. Dunn.   They were at all material times the registered proprietors of an estate in fee simple of the land comprised in Lot 8 on RP 201714 County of Canning, Parish of Neara (hereinafter referred to as the “plaintiffs’ land”).  The defendants are R.T. Howard and C.A. Howard.  The defendants were at the material time the owners of land on the western side of the Brisbane River, on the western side opposite the plaintiffs’ land.  The Brisbane River flowed from north to south and so the plaintiffs’ land was on the eastern side.  The defendants obtained a permit to excavate gravel from the river so as to improve the water depth to allow more effective irrigation of their land.  The plaintiffs’ claim is for damages for trespass by the defendants for placing the spoil from the excavation on their land contrary to the permit and without their consent.  The plaintiffs conducted dairy farming and the defendants conducted  grazing operations on their respective lands.  The plaintiffs had access to the river to water their stock.

  1. The plaintiffs plead that by a Deed of Grant (Exhibit 13) their western boundary is defined by the Brisbane River. It is further alleged in the plaint that, by virtue of ss. 2, 5 and 34 of the Water Resources Act 1989, the line of the western boundary of the plaintiffs’ land is the line below which the waters of the Brisbane River normally flow. It is further alleged that the plaintiffs are therefore entitled to bring and maintain an action for trespass to their land which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dunn v Howard and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QDC 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the District Court of Queensland, the case of Dunn & Anor v Howard & Anor [2001] QDC 030 involved the plaintiffs, W.H. Dunn and C.A. Dunn, who were the registered proprietors of land that abutted the Brisbane River. The defendants, R.T. Howard and C.A. Howard, owned land on the western side of the river and had obtained a permit to excavate gravel from the river to improve water depth for irrigation. The plaintiffs sought damages for trespass by the defendants for placing spoil from the excavation on their land contrary to the permit and without their consent. The primary legal issues were whether the spoil was placed on the plaintiffs’ land, and if so, whether the defendants were liable for trespass and entitled to claim damages.

The court examined the definition of the western boundary of the plaintiffs’ land as described in their Deed of Grant, which referenced the Brisbane River. The plaintiffs argued that their western boundary was defined by the river, and any physical feature that marked the river's flow should be given precedence over survey lines. The court found that the true boundary was the natural feature of the river, and survey lines were secondary guides that could be corrected. The evidence of an experienced surveyor supported the concept of ambulatory boundaries, indicating that the surveyed boundary may not accurately reflect the true boundary due to changes in the river's course over time.

The court concluded that the defendants were in breach of their excavation permit by excavating over a significantly larger area than permitted. Furthermore, the place where the spoil was deposited was not within the bed and banks of the Brisbane River as defined by the Water Resources Act 1989, and the defendants had trespassed on the plaintiffs’ land by depositing the spoil without consent. The court assessed the damages at $7,500.00, considering the interference with the plaintiffs’ access to the river and the negative reaction caused by the extent of the deposit.

The court ordered judgment for the plaintiffs against the defendants in the sum of $7,500.00, and that the defendants pay the plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to the action including reserve costs, if any, to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established