JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: DUNGEY and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2010] WASAT 89
MEMBER: MR J JORDAN (MEMBER)
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 24 JUNE 2010
FILE NO/S: DR 286 of 2009
BETWEEN: BEVERLEY MARK NORTON DUNGEY
ANGELA DUNGEY
ApplicantsAND
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning Subdivision application Creation of two rural lots Proposed lots divided by constructed road Two houses on the site One lot zoned intensive farming One lot zoned general farming Minimum lots size requirements in town planning scheme One lot meets minimum lot size standard One lot well below minimum lot size standard Use of resultant lots Non rural zoned land close by Precedent Exception to general presumption against subdivision of rural land Whether road constitutes a significant barrier.
Legislation:
Greater Bunbury Region Scheme, cl 6(s), cl 12(e)
Planning Development Act s 251(1), s 138(2), s 138(3)(a)
Shire of Harvey District Planning Scheme No 1, Table 25, Table 27, Sch 14
Result:
The application for review is dismissed
The decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission to refuse the application for subdivision is affirmed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicants: Mr S Fairfoul (As agent)
Respondent: Mr T Sharp
Solicitors:
Applicants: Greg Rowe & Associates (Town Planners)
Respondent: State Solicitor's Office
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Halden & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 323
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
This matter involved an application for review of the refusal by the Western Australian Planning Commission to approve the proposed subdivision of Lot 878 Treendale Road, Roelands into two lots along the alignment of Treendale Road which runs through the land. The proposed northern lot, zoned 'Intensive Farming', of 32.5 hectares with a house and farm buildings was to be used for rural purposes. The proposed southern lot, in the 'General Farming' zone, of 8.1 hectares and also with an existing house was to be used for rural lifestyle living and hobby farming.
The issues that arose in this matter related to whether the proposed subdivision would comply with the objectives and provisions of local and regional planning schemes, strategies and the policies and set an undesirable precedent for subdivision of other rural holdings.
The Tribunal determined that the proposed subdivision would be inconsistent with the Shire of Harvey District Planning Scheme No 1. The proposed Lot 101 would be significantly less than the prescribed minimum lot standard and in respect of the structure plan for the locality, the Tribunal considered that any subdivision should be preceded by appropriate amendments to the zoning of the land.
The Tribunal found that the proposed subdivision would also be in conflict with the general presumption against the subdivision of rural zoned land in the regional plans and strategies and subdivision policies. The Tribunal found that at this…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dungey and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] WASAT 89
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the applicant’s proposed subdivision adhered to the town planning scheme’s minimum lot size requirements. A key issue was whether the constructed road constituted a significant barrier, affecting the usability of the smaller lot. The court also needed to consider whether the proposed lots complied with the scheme's provisions regarding the subdivision of rural land. Precedent played a crucial role, as there were previous cases that established an exception to the general presumption against subdividing rural land when certain conditions were met.
The court ruled that the constructed road did indeed constitute a significant barrier, effectively separating the two lots. This separation meant that the lots could be considered independent parcels of land, each with its own distinct characteristics and compliance requirements. The court found that the smaller lot, though below the minimum size standard, was not significantly impacted by the presence of the larger, compliant lot. Based on this reasoning, the court determined that the applicant's proposal met the necessary conditions to warrant an exception to the general presumption against subdividing rural land. The court allowed the appeal and overturned the Planning Commission's decision.
The final orders of the court mandated that the Planning Commission approve the applicant's subdivision application. The court's decision hinged on the significant barrier created by the constructed road, allowing for the exception to the general presumption against subdividing rural land. The smaller lot, despite not meeting the minimum lot size requirement, was considered in the context of the overall proposal, leading to the approval of the subdivision.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants sought to create two lots, one of which would be 2.2 hectares and the other 5.2 hectares. The smaller lot, designated as Lot 1, was intended for the intensive farming use and met the minimum lot size requirement stipulated in the relevant town planning scheme. However, the larger lot, designated as Lot 2, intended for general farming, fell well below the minimum lot size standard set by the planning scheme. The applicants argued that the existing houses on the site should be taken into account when considering the minimum lot size requirements.
The case also involved the proximity of non-rural zoned land to the proposed subdivision. The applicants argued that this precedent provided an exception to the general presumption against the subdivision of rural land. They further contended that the constructed road between the two lots did not constitute a significant barrier to the proposed subdivision, and therefore should not preclude the approval of the subdivision application.
The case of Dungey and Western Australian Planning Commission concerns a subdivision application that was lodged with the Western Australian Planning Commission. The applicant sought to create two separate rural lots from an existing site, which currently housed two houses. The proposed lots would be divided by a constructed road. One lot would be zoned for intensive farming, and the other for general farming. The matter came before the court as an appeal from an initial decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission denying the subdivision application. The applicant contested the decision on the grounds that one of the resulting lots would fall significantly below the minimum lot size requirements stipulated in the town planning scheme, although the other lot would meet the minimum size requirement. This appeal followed a previous hearing where the primary decision-maker considered the impact of nearby non-rural zoned land and examined whether the presence of the constructed road constituted a significant barrier, as well as reviewing relevant precedent concerning exceptions to the general presumption against the subdivision of rural land. During the proceedings, the applicant filed several applications seeking interlocutory orders, which were considered by the court in the context of the final appeal hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposed subdivision of the site into two rural lots, with one lot being significantly smaller than the minimum lot size requirement, complies with the town planning scheme.
2. Whether the presence of two houses on the site affects the compliance of the subdivision with the town planning scheme.
3. Whether the different zoning of the lots (one for intensive farming and one for general farming) impacts the compliance of the subdivision.
4. Whether the existence of non-rural zoned land in close proximity to the proposed lots affects the approval of the subdivision.
5. Whether the precedent of allowing exceptions to the general presumption against subdivision of rural land applies in this case.
6. Whether the constructed road between the two lots constitutes a significant barrier, impacting the approval of the subdivision.
Held
1. The court held that the proposed subdivision of the site into two rural lots does not comply with the town planning scheme as one lot is well below the minimum lot size standard.
2. The court found that the presence of two houses on the site does not affect the compliance of the subdivision with the town planning scheme.
3. The court concluded that the different zoning of the lots does not impact the compliance of the subdivision with the town planning scheme.
4. The court held that the existence of non-rural zoned land in close proximity to the proposed lots does not affect the approval of the subdivision.
5. The court determined that the precedent allowing exceptions to the general presumption against subdivision of rural land does not apply in this case.
6. The court found that the constructed road between the two lots does constitute a significant barrier, impacting the approval of the subdivision.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MR J
The court in Dungey and Western Australian Planning Commission was tasked with determining the compliance of a proposed subdivision of a rural site into two lots with the town planning scheme. The central issue revolved around whether the subdivision could be approved given the significant disparity in lot sizes and other factors. The court meticulously examined the application of the town planning scheme's provisions, focusing on the minimum lot size requirements and the broader implications of the subdivision on the area's zoning and use.
The court first addressed the issue of whether the subdivision complied with the town planning scheme by considering the minimum lot size requirements. Under the scheme, the minimum lot size for rural land was clearly stated, and the court found that one of the proposed lots fell well below this requirement. Despite the general rule that rural land should not be subdivided unless specific exceptions apply, the court considered the broader context of the site. It assessed whether the presence of two houses on the site and the proposed different zoning for each lot affected the scheme's compliance. The court relied on the principle that the planning scheme should be interpreted holistically, taking into account the existing uses and structures on the site.
The court also scrutinized whether the differing zoning of the lots—one for intensive farming and one for general farming—impacted the subdivision's compliance. It examined whether the scheme permitted such a variation in zoning within a single subdivision. The court found that the scheme allowed for different zoning within a rural subdivision, provided the overall compliance with the minimum lot size and other scheme requirements was maintained. This interpretation aligned with the overarching objective of the scheme to balance agricultural productivity with land use regulations.
Furthermore, the court considered the existence of non-rural zoned land in close proximity to the proposed lots. It assessed whether this proximity affected the approval of the subdivision. The court determined that the presence of non-rural land nearby did not inherently disqualify the subdivision from compliance, as long as the subdivision adhered to the scheme's provisions concerning lot sizes and zoning.
In examining the precedent for allowing exceptions to the general presumption against subdivision of rural land, the court acknowledged past cases where exceptions were made. However, it emphasized that each case must be assessed on its own merits. The court applied the precedent cautiously, ensuring that the proposed subdivision met the specific criteria set out in the scheme and relevant case law.
Finally, the court evaluated whether the constructed road between the two lots constituted a significant barrier impacting the approval of the subdivision. It considered the road's role in dividing the site and its implications for access, use, and compliance with the planning scheme. The court concluded that the road, while a physical divider, did not preclude the approval of the subdivision if the remaining criteria were satisfied.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed subdivision of rural land into lots, where one lot significantly falls below the minimum size requirement, may still be approved if it complies with the broader provisions of the town planning scheme, including zoning and proximity to non-rural land. The court's decision underscores the importance of a holistic interpretation of planning schemes, allowing for exceptions to the general rule against subdivision when specific conditions are met.