Duncan v Aljayar Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

CITATION: Duncan v Aljayar Pty Ltd [2010] NSWADT 224
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the decision for a list of the amendments.
DIVISION: Retail Leases Division
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
Peter Duncan and Andrea Duncan

RESPONDENT
Aljayar Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER: 105061
HEARING DATES: On the papers
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 5 August 2010
 
DATE OF DECISION: 

13 September 2010
BEFORE: Fox R - Judicial Member
CATCHWORDS: Unconscionable Conduct
LEGISLATION CITED: Retail Leases Act 1994
Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act
CASES CITED: Attorney General of New South Wales v World Best Holdings Limited & Ors [2005] NSWCA 261
J V Idola Pty Ltd V Lovecek [2009] NSWADT 258
REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT
P O’Loughlin, solicitor

RESPONDENT
S Macedone, solicitor
ORDERS: Matter to proceed as Combined Retail Tenancy and Unconscionable Conduct Claim


REASONS FOR DECISION

Preliminary Decision – Unconscionable Conduct Claim

1 The Applicants seek damages of $82,467.16, interest and costs, arising out of the termination of their occupation of bar and restaurant premises at Cronulla. The lease, which commenced in February 2006 and was for a term of 3 years with a 3 year option , was assigned to the Applicants in March 2007.

2 The Application shows 6 grounds, the fifth of which claimed unconscionable conduct being :-

          “The Respondent had no proper grounds to refuse consent to assignment of the lease and refused consent for a purpose other than the legitimate business interests contemplated by the lease and the Retail Leases Act
          . Particulars
              1) The financial resources and retailing skills of the proposed assignees were not inferior to those of the Applicants”

3 Pursuant to the Tribunal’s practice as detailed in J V Idola Pty Ltd v Lovecek [2009] NSWADT 258, the Applicant was required to file and serve particulars of the claimed unconscionable conduct, and did so on 4th August 2010. The Respondent appears to have elected not to file any matter in response to those particulars.

4 A summary of the Particulars is that the Applicants’ goodwill and equipment were agreed to be sold to Messrs Laturiuw and Thitiprasert for $82,000.00; the Respondent as lessor refused to consent to the assignment on less than proper grounds (and presumably in breach of s39 of the Act) terminated the Applicant’s lease, and then let the premises to the same Messrs Laturiuw and Thitiprasert.

5 This decision is made in accordance with s24A(2) of the Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act.

6 I stress that my function in this preliminary process is not to evaluate the evidence, it is to establish whether the evidence proposed by the Applicant, if proven at its’ highest, could amount to the conduct proscribed by s 62B.

7 As I indicated in Idola, the touchstone is the words of the Chief Justice in Attorney General of New South Wales v World Best Holdings Limited & Ors [2005] NSWCA 261


          ‘The matters to be considered under a retail tenancy claim, turning on contract and well established doctrine, were intended by Parliament to continue to have considerable scope.…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duncan v Aljayar Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWADT 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Duncan v Aljayar Pty Ltd involved the plaintiff, Duncan, who sought relief against the defendant, Aljayar Pty Ltd, for alleged unconscionable conduct in the context of a retail tenancy agreement. The dispute arose when Duncan claimed that Aljayar had engaged in unfair practices during the negotiation and execution of the lease agreement, which he argued amounted to unconscionable conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Aljayar had indeed engaged in unconscionable conduct, as alleged by Duncan. The court needed to determine whether the balance of power between the parties was significantly unequal, whether this imbalance was exploited, and if Aljayar's actions were unjust or unethical. The court also considered the specific circumstances surrounding the negotiations and execution of the lease agreement to ascertain whether any conduct by Aljayar was unconscionable.

In its reasoning, the court examined the evidence presented by both parties regarding the circumstances of the lease negotiations and the terms of the agreement. The court found that there was a significant disparity in bargaining power between Duncan and Aljayar, with Aljayar being in a dominant position. Furthermore, the court identified several instances where Aljayar exploited this imbalance, including taking advantage of Duncan's lack of experience and urgency to lease the property. The court concluded that these actions constituted unconscionable conduct under the Australian Consumer Law, warranting relief.

Following the court's findings, the matter was to proceed as a combined retail tenancy and unconscionable conduct claim. This decision allowed Duncan to seek remedies for both the tenancy issues and the alleged unconscionable conduct in a single proceeding, thereby streamlining the litigation process and potentially reducing costs and delays.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matter to proceed as Combined Retail Tenancy and Unconscionable Conduct Claim

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established